TR-2020-024 Approved Combined Plans Com m - ynin Development Department
Plang Division — Cupertino
CUPERTINO APPROVED 3/24/2021
Case# TR-2020-024
Application Number(s)
Stonebridge HOA
Approva I Body'
ve Director/Staff
StensdCNr lffd Old Oak Way
Approva I Date
Signature CUPWA"44MM
Case Manager
To: City of Cupertino Planning Dept.
I have inspected the Stonebridge site both from above and below. I estimate the urban tree
canopy to be 80 to 82% coverage. This is relatively high for an HOA located in an urban setting.
do not believe that planting any additional Aleppo pine trees would benefit the Stonebridge
HOA at this time. The Aleppo pine is a large tree with a large canopy. Planting small to medium
trees to supplement the existing landscape would allow for a multi storied canopy, with
diversity, better aesthetics and a healthier landscape. It would also allow the existing trees to
mature with less pruning and less stress which occurs from pruning.
In addition, with such a dense tree canopy it makes it difficult to maintain the understory
landscape. The canopies shade out the shrubs underneath which then require additional
disease and pest control and fertilization. Pruning could remedy the situation but would have to
be done annually to be effective and as mentioned above would causes unnecessary stress to
the trees. For the reasons mentioned above I am recommending not to replace the Aleppo
pines with the same species.
Respectfully,
Paul West
Certified Arborist
W E-3760A
Community Development Department
3/4/2020
Planning Division — Cupertino
CUPERTINQ APPROVED
Case # TR-2020-024
Application Number(s)
Approval Body: Director/ Staff
Approval D14?e^ebrMg¢j"9►
Signature Ste%*iPPGrehArhndQjd Oak Way
Case Manager
Cupertino, CA 95014
To: Stonebridge Management
This letter is to confirm that I visually inspected the 22 trees identified on the attached map and
spreadsheet for the Stonebridge Home owners Association.The trees are located throughout
the property along the perimeter fence. In total there are 22 trees numbered 2-23 on the
attached list of removals. 16 Aleppo Pines, 1 Monterey Pine, 2 Magnolia's, 3 Eucalyptus, and 1
pear tree. I am basing my recommendations on one or more of the following observations I
observed at each tree.
Tree is dead
Tree has an excessive lean
Poor growth form
Poor branch attachment
Codominant stems
Declining health
For the above mention reasons,the trees are a liability to the association. There are no
corrective actions within reason that can be taken to maintain the trees health/vigor and
eliminate the liability. Therefore, I recommend the removal of all 22 trees.
Respectfully,
Paul West
I1e� Certified Arborist WE-3760A
Attachment C
§T0N ' ftfrjd'rT `I'k' tEPR1VLtANTING CSHOA Table
Planning Division
�—rv��Cupertino � Removed Dead Trees
CUPERTINO TR2VLV—VL'T
Case # TIR-28215-624
Application Number(s)
Appro va I�. 4y: Director/ Staff
Approval9)a�e 01 cofl Replacement
w z o 1 ~-
Signature 13 B ianneAd 1171tR ptig 15.0 1 E 1 2-24" Box or 1-36" Box Tree
14 Aleppwp4we 25.0 E 2-24" Box or 1-36" Box Tree
15.1 Aleppo Pine 21.7 E 2-24" Box or 1-36" Box Tree
15.2 Aleppo Pine 21.7 E 2-24" Box or 1-36" Box Tree
16 Aleppo Pine 22.6 E 2-24" Box or 1-36" Box Tree
19 Aleppo Pine 9.9 E 1-24" Box trees
20 Aleppo Pine 20.1 E 2-24" Box or 1-36" Box Tree
21 Aleppo Pine 22.1 E 2-24" Box or 1-36" Box Tree
22 Aleppo Pine 18.2 E 2-24" Box or 1-36" Box Tree
23 Aleppo Pine 24.5 E 2-24" Box or 1-36" Box Tree
P Purple Plum 14.6 D 2-24" Box or 1-36" Box Tree
Attachment C
Com lh ,el eloppment Department
Trees Only C:UPERTINO S�ONEBRIDGE TREE REMOVALS 5/22/2020
I.@.n.n.i-n�Q.v l s.l-o-n - - .pe-rIM 6
CUPERTINO E A PFj)VE v
d
Z " � A Z
Case # FrR- 0 V2 0 a _
r ' Justification Reason Comment
Application Num er(;) ^
Fallen Tree-removed when it fell on home.
r 13 Aleppo Pine AO.1 13 Dead-not living whatsoever 10 4 47.0 15.0 B
Ap pro vad- A! t r 14 Dead-not living whatsoever 10 1 78.5 25.0 C Fallen Tree
Approvadl Qg e Aleoo Pp1 j),2 22 AO.1 15 Dead-noLliving whatsoever 10 1 68.0 21.7 C Fallen Tree
Dead-Demise is imminent-- Restricts economic enjoyment of the
Slgnatur Brian�� H rkg�ish:� Poorly rooted Root Ball
V - _ — 10 1 71.0 22.6 C
19 Aleppo PineL a e -AI IgP1 19 Dead-not living whatsoever 6 15 31.0 9.9 B Dead Tree
20 Aleppo Pine AO.1 20 Dead-not living whatsoever TC TC 63.0 20.1 C Fallen Tree
21 Aleppo Pine AO.1 21 Dead-not living whatsoever TC TC 77.0 24.5 C Fallen Tree
22 Aleppo Pine AO.1 22 Dead-not living whatsoever TC TC 69.5 22.1 C Fallen Tree
Vt 23 Aleppo Pine AO.1 23 1 Dead-not living whatsoever TC TC 57.0 18.2 C Fallen Tree
CSHOA Code Cupertino tree removal classifications
A0.1 Dead not living whatsoever
A0.2 Dead IDernise is imminent
A1.1 Irreversibly diseased
A1.2 In Danger of Falling
A1.3 Can Cause potential Damage to existing structures
A1.4 Interferes with Private on-site utilities
A2 lRestricts economic enjoyment of the property
A3 ITree is a detriment to the property and can not be supported according to good urban forestry practices
A4 single trunk Trees with DBH between 12"and 48"or multi-trunk trees between 24"and 48" will be replaced.
Attachment C
Comojunity Development�-47partment
&anning Division —�EurpTe� t-i-ne
C J PERTINO ` APPROVES
Case #0' ~ TR-2020-02
ILW
Application Number(
Approval B �: Director/Staff
A pro I De 01/12/22
P
5ignat AlBrianne Harkousha -
Case Manager
IA
r
cc -
to
- t
160mmIA,�,
m it velopment Department
��,yisiN-aR'Rt%gL_1ST LANDSCAPE MAINTENANCE COMPANY
-CUPERTINO APPRU EIUNEY DRIVE SAN DOSE,CALIFORNIA 95112 (408)298-4720 FAX(408)298-1761
Case# TR-2020-024
Application Number(s)
Approval Body: Director/Staff
Approval Da Decem81ir11 /Ao19
Signature Brianne Harkousha -`
Case Manager .i
Cupertino Stonebridge HOA
C/O Community Management Services, Inc. �� a. rf?; s V
1935 Dry Creek Road, Suite 203
Campbell, CA 95008 t"
�S
Re: 22821 Stonebridge i't
PROBLEM '
Flowering Plum tree at this address is in decline.
OBSERVATION
Specimen: Flowering Plum (Prunus cerasifera)
Trunk circumference = 46" cumulative (multi-leader).
Tree has experienced heavy crown die back. '
Tree has been planted over main water service lines.
Main water line found to be leaking under tree.
Tree roots have been severed to facilitate line repair.
DISCUSSION
Disease symptoms are consistent with a root rot fungus.
There is no know chemical treatment to control this disease.
Severed roots may compromise tree's anchorage ability.
Target should tree fail could be the House, sidewalk to front door, driveway, or street.
RECOMMENDATION
Tree should be considered Hazardous and Removed.
RESPECTFULLY SUBMITTED
WU&4
wc-5728a, Warren Nakamura P
441, �
Attachment C
Community Development Department
Planning Division — Cupertino
CuFLRTINO APPROVED
Case # TR-2020-024
Application Number(s)
Approval BodCui � e-rlifno Stonebridge Tree Program Submittal Index
Pp
A roval Date 01/,2/22
Signature Brianne Harkousha
Case Manager
• CSHOA Tree Project
• Analysis of plan
• Dead Trees TR2020-024
• TR2020-024 Summary Table
• TR2020-024 Remove Map
• TR2020-024 Replacement Map
• Living Trees
• TR2019-035 Summary Table
• TR2019-035 Remove Map
• TR2019-035 Replacement Map
12/20/2021
Community Development Department
Planning Division — Cupertino
CuFLRTINO APPROVED
Case # I ITA2R20-9-24
•
�J lic tJum e (s) r r j e ct
Ap pro val.BZdYi&j Mtf)etl�fft TR2019-035 covered dead, dangerous or declining trees
Approval Date. -194AN? 92 nr 9�1 trap-.
Signature Bria-FrpMAImm;jtarj in-.irlp and outside CSHOA boundary fence
• Paiaafees Vased upon request.
• City responded with request for additional data and clarification
• Our request evolved to respond to hazard posed by dead trees — With agreement from City we
change our approach
• City approved immediate removal of one (1) tree from original TR 2019-035 — (see Permit TR
2020-001) for a water line problem.
• Submitted TR2020-024 covering 10 dead or down trees (Arborist concurrence letter)
• Resubmitted TR2019-035 to cover 7 declining or dangerous living trees. (Arborist letter concurring
with removals)
• We removed several street side trees from our request.
• Status
• All dead and down trees removed (10+1 Trees).
• Resubmitted TR2019-035 to clarify request removing street trees
• Supplied additional Arborist report concerning TR2019-035 trees and choice replacement trees
• At city request - Separated Living and dead tree applications, 21 Dec 2021
• Submitted a separate replacement tree plan, for all tree permits TR 2019-035 plus TR 2020-001,
and TR 2020-024.
12/20/2021
Community Development Department
Planning Division — Cupertino
CUPERTINO APPROVED
Case# TR-2020-024
A n a i VP' p l a n
Approval Body: Director/ Staff
Approva I Date 01/12/22
Signature Brianne Harkousha
Case Manager
• 1 • • • Replacement
Dead or Fallen 11/21 24" Box 14
Declining or damaging 7/11 36" Box 9/18
Total 18 32 Total 23/0
Tree • - •
Evergreen 16/90% 16/70%
Deciduous 2/10% 7/30%
18 23 Equivalent number of 24"
Box size trees
12/20/2021
f
CommuniQepv W"M6r46ffaWLGrAOATREE Maintenance Plan TR2020=024
PIannjktUI-'hI 14� Cupertino 20 Dec 2021
CVPERTIN0 APPROVED
Case # T� Replacement 1(Note 3)
,, -"4 Replacement size Replacement 2-as needed (Note
e
F1 c oice(Note 2) 3)
d
Approva Bo y: Director/ Staff Z
Approva Dat 01/12/22 o N
Signatur E �Bribnne Harkousl�a I ° I m I
o Case Mana ei N y o�
m p U
c. a.
a�i y w d a H a r
E E
y O Gl x x C V C u
o y is y co m° :. M :. A 0pp,
d d m S �O Q W fp M �, aJ T
cc Q Current Tree Q W tg N M C. N a07: F- C. VI cc F-
13 D Aleppo Pine 15.0 E 2 2 U 24 Tristania E W 24 Live Oak E
14 D Aleppo Pine 25.0 E 2 1 E 36 Crape Myrtle D
15.1 D Aleppo Pine 21.7 E 2 1 B 36 Branford Pear D
15.2 D Aleppo Pine 21.7 E 2 1 1 36 Tristania E
16 D Aleppo Pine 22.6 E 2 1 F 36 Crape Myrtle D
19 D Aleppo Pine 9.9 E 1 1 L 24 Red Maple E
20 D Aleppo Pine 20.1 E 2 1 D 36 Olive E
21 D Aleppo Pine 22.1 E 2 2 K 24 Live Oak E 0 24 Bradford Pear E
22 D Aleppo Pine 18.2 E 2 1 V 36 Jacaranda E
23 D Aleppo Pine 24.5 E 2 1 N 36 Crape Myrtle D
P D Purple Plum 14.6 D 2 1 G 36 Jacaranda E
NOTES:
1. City code allows use of 36"box trees In lieu of two 24"Box trees. CSHOA has chosen this option for trees numbered;12,14.15.1,15.2,
16,20,22,23,P.
2. These two column identify the size choices made for each removed tree. j
3. Identifies the species and size of each tree replacing removed trees. The letter designation correlates with the Attachment A"CSHOA
Replacement Tree Locations". Location of replacement trees are not necessarily at the location of the removed tree. Our arborist
replacement recommendations in Attachment B are based upon the DBH of the removed tree,not the Associations decision on the size of
tree to replace the removed tree. For example the two magnolias being removed,15.1 and 15.2,will be replace by 36"box olive and E
Crape Myrtle trees not 24"box trees.
4. The removed tree designated"P"was to be included in this permit but an adjacent home water line could not be repaired without
removing the tree. See the arborist report at the end of our permit request.
I
Community Development Department
Planning Division — Cupertino
CUPERT APPROVED
Case. TR-2020-024
TM Application Number(s)
Appr5?1 B : Director/ Staff M C4
Appri i DN 01/12/22 gn
Sign4 MqI VBrianne Harkousha
Case ManagerA
O inx
N o
OC N
x
x
F
N N
0.
- x
V S
x '
� xx �
Q i
V �
N
O
N
t`
r-1
CO
Community Development Department Ln
Planning Division — Cupertino
CUPERTINO APPROVED
Case# TR-2020-024
v Application Number(s)
� W
Approv d irector/ Staff
Approv at 01/12/22
Signatl (� nne Harkousha
Case Manager �
W
N
0
H .
X
J
h C
x z
i x
H �
N
O
N
c-I
00
\ ' ` , "+r H}�, "s�. 'L' 1 ' � r��"d � ,�`. ,�j� i�i� :S} '�� .r�' i 's�►-�, �b,� ,`tip ''j
g, _/� �, ",� � i mot, y t f ��*y� y3�• ..4 • S�� �"1 � ,ti _
a�i,'Z .T . � •a� , ! •+ �9'+ � �'F'� �i � l� ', ,t'� f -r- ISI .`4
+'fft; / I• t,' ` r , LLL 4l • 7{ Yr. Ae
• `1 r -f- �4 T
ICU
��? ' .(l`■�{!Y�- if .� r ,� ��H J- 1.� ��. IS, - I
r -. 1'Y- �.JI ff"a�`—� ♦.y� '�f,: �+y>' -fie� -��"' r_ -tr� — 'r�,_ f
� s3� .r` • " `•�a —._ .�� .�.� a. r y�V sec �' ` ��' �.. �: 1,f . ! ,7 .� ��
•� r "a `_��li i� '� 1�',� rl�,�� {'�I,I !�, �' � ti. S .t � I_- 4 p�'�
• � - i. � �_ ' - �\`tit�}fj'�1 M�' ! r � y" � .' 1 \ \ '-i
r + 6
-4
do
1.4
, A
(A
. - . 4• .r a
qp 'A It
A 10,
,40r
�w
t + 4
Aie
y � w
4 '
A �
• 1
•s• Pine
Ao.
ja
�♦'r4 +9•l� �'� i'� µear: �• tea, ° aIF,"(,fl,
, �'1 ar �. Ci r' A''�Sc q" 3t��'; � , r ,•. ,►�- � � �5 �
} , ,ski
4:1,
• 41C
OF
- ��R`l '• � +, .� � - * `"'�! - _a '` }� t , °y'rt�' '[r ry:A,S �Sr� ir�!�} fE{ ' ; f':� �
' �, y •! _ - .. _ '1. `��,- (-a. �R.LI t � p. { , r ,•�I°• r ,.,11 a a'F•, a .+4•,'
�yyy� r y. k�_. - s it .". �' 1 • �j� '`R�` r ,
' r¢ i
qk
Nam.
4-1
Ilk
LLJ
tip
Is
�^'} • p �' � '�- � e f�.� �'�' ,� � .ti'i �" �� �7�1�� I ! ' ��'�i b 3 { �� {n+ ' ��' � ,E E 8�•:' 1
tt �'yr • LLyy
r
�� • ,'fir � ^ ► ; �• 1 � � !.
'A
0.At.
Ok.
�.-.•� '' ty i' fir+ +•. '�
_ -'�` ,s �pF�lEli r,,. �D' v .fir• a�' ' � 0. fll�l ` �. „; ~'.1F-., � �s � �?,P`1;i`� �+ v 9 :�'A,
1411
.kin iI
:4 ate'+ ►� �� ,,�rl ��.
" yam. •.a, ,`!N. '� *
l �_�.:`t ��. '!- `.• a ?�• �.'1!,•.r.F'`" _z.
-XY
46
���`��,art �ti g• •� .��� ���r1 _x_, E•'
. ' M r r r Yr • 1ff
5Jtj3 Mf(r'l
T y�,F lY. V 't1 r � k i. �..� �•� ■ �.�.
-eWr 4'y�'�Y •''
{ •` .�i `'(ram,1 '�4� ' 'j', � 'i -<+ � I.1�' •�Y�:t
TAU
14
� . : . Aleppo Pine
At -
ht t;
.3rr' i•�,H .� y4�r`'Y' ' y(.,p\'. � ��..f, iob1�K�%'� `fir.
Y i"� a ?�� -tti=i`� ��_ �;•�y�i�� "1 !fit„ '•�.1 ;,,��� �;r.,. y
- r to. s'"��y .. - � :✓ � _ H r�.
At j ?
4 .F• may,-
is
. - -. -• r ,ems, ���'��;,,,,,
I + / •p• F .
! '
f �r �'�
•�}� J• J,IIr <
�._ \ 1r �;-.vim-i,;•` - �� ,-w�i� .-.iw��a �c� '. � � y'.?
,
.71
1
' .�� -a. 7p..•, S._ �t�
15
Aleppo pip
wiry
Ewa-T�—
•! i
k:
k
`k
r.
i
E
7
'
NN
It low
01. y l pia
.pit �' �11 '►, t='. waR."� � �+' � +'� '•l
lok
. �
t ' I•l ,� }i� .
-��
. •ramt iAle
law
za.AL AL
Qcft
AIO
�. •r_ - is �'.�� � �s�`� !. R f i f- �
' _ ;};`•t M ..�is J ,� "� �t� ';\ - �: .r,�.^� AIC n � _ i`• .
.P s
f
°j-yp !*1�1Rdie ,,,► �;. 'i',1,� �'�' .._; //• � V �'fi ' !. s$b'TJ �,�� ,W
i � '� 'S• s ��.�t.7 ' �¢ .a.� a.Y"�%, .•�tvi. sib''' ' d �� .�:3i.I' �� ��ri
51
Wit
let
Zd � _t :s .c �.•; :�� ;•y� '-_��r;� ��.��..�- ra., - v i� •I. ? �' 4:�I.r� .r� �u►s a, i
MS 1 ► Y u 1;'Ii- f ;. ';'a •r•.�` .t �� f J' F• %S ?- 15 V �i
J; /J/} .!' \,yr• { r' - _- i7�• '•�
4a ".N f y W 7,{y-,F• f�� �jj ,:4,�_`r :¢,. F _� "r y." >+� XiN
\�+•li e►G
Ilk
T16
44
� t�� a} '1`l�'. �� r; •i'r a ; ,/�� rt 1r a'4lY y � , `�r�;{i� � r 1��f", �� � _ r ��ii+�`�4�1 ��l ' r •'��
S r� � gyp - y -1 � ".�' -~ r�; .%`. - l + `r+L'R� - i��• !. 4
te
aj
41
20
ie
Aleppo Pk
1 � '� 1, '� � r s�` t, 1 �• •ti � �5 '
w T � t�1 [ A ♦ .?��r,
1�N110
to • • ik
4 �.
yr •.�. f- i
•; r �„' /Sr�� �7'>• >F.' ' , •t tea_ ,•,��� t .ti_ r., ,�{{� '
' n ti�I*V1
�" .• y � , y: ,fit ! '� `t� ::.' : „ Oro
`•' y�
ge
51
911.
d
3X � iip
AA
v .cif rLar �.4
� �`i 'ice ;i;t�!�H�'' 't.: •'.�'S\ ���� F�I�'t t - }I . •
0 L.-,Si
14
�`. � `I�� FF to � r .�� • I ' �� j � 4 �t �� � �
- 77 �i'9�
4} � ' r _ f� i��j,' T� � ��r �t 'r�`'K�����' •yam"��,�+ I+
^ \ �
; ' '�` i -. •' +` �"' +�' `_' •,4 `. ..Y,,.-
h, 4 �.,, a s a
' _ �' `'/r 'ls � C•. -�'•+w/'�� �'�_ 'V ��•+tom/` ' ��,_'�
j`
!
fj
574 .1
X Aleppo Pine
��► '�r .'� .�_� -3. �~r� } '�Mf'_ i 1 - �! mot' •� i r 1 .
}
��.r} rt�r.. nb'.!: �1/ 6 J — _+r,,.. � ,�, � ,r' r','• r '+1r �•��
Community Development Department
Planning Division — Cupertino
CUPERTINO APPROVED
Case# TR-2020-024
Application Number(s)
Approval Body: Director/Staff
Approva I Date 01/12/22
Signature Brianne Harkousha
Case Manager
Community Development Departmentillp
Planning Division — Cupertino ;{: 41r ,' �LLr1F�,'j `• .�, c
CUPERTINQ -. - APPROVED [ "• ' - •� R"•'';;. ' �."..':R,. _
° ' fi � i♦ '
Case # TR-2020-024 }' 'F'''"►' jj�= 1
Application Number(s) p -; ,o, 3� {A
y
Approval Body: Director/ Staff
Approval Date 01/12/22
Signature Brianne Harkoush ram�►♦` ! J
Case Manager a , , F w 1 ,:
r fjJ $ ,
rwry. �'� 1lI•
•' ,rr ilk v /f'f. `' ♦ �.;. I-�I♦.•
,v .� s. � � ♦ ,^ : JET sY L`�- '
d j- �
�I
1 -•
y
r '
Aleppo Pine
F
r 1 ••• w
.�� • i ; a '.,`r' �` f, !, �j
t .
f
JI
I Yt � r f • �
1 ' '
ti�