HomeMy WebLinkAboutAH 09-27-2018 Cupertino, CA 95014
(408) 777-3308
APPROVED MINUTES OF THE REGULAR MEETING OF
THE ADMINISTRATIVE HEARING HELD ON September 27, 2018
ROLL CALL
Hearing Officer present: Benjamin Fu, Assistant Director of Community Development
Staff present: Erick Serrano, Associate Planner
Ellen Yau, Associate Planner
Applicant(s) present: Susan Chen, Architect for Medina Lane
Josh Selo, Director of West Valley Community Services
APPROVAL OF MINUTES:
1. August 9, 2018
The minutes of August 9, 2018 were approved as written
POSTPONEMENTS/REMOVAL FROM CALENDAR:
None
ORAL COMMUNICATIONS:
None
WRITTEN COMMUNICATIONS:
None
PUBLIC MEETING ITEMS:
2. Application No.(s): ASA-2017-06
Applicant: Hanna Smiloch (Gu/Ming residence)
Location: 22861 Medina Ln APN#(s): 342-30-013
Architectural and Site approval to consider allowing a 1,161 square foot first floor addition and
a 326 square foot second floor addition to an existing duplex.
Administrative Hearing decision final unless appealed.
Staff member Serrano addressed the Hearing Officer. He explained the specific scope of the
project, the FAR, the zoning designations and neighborhood conditions. The project meets the
requirements of the City's Municipal Code. During the noticing period, Staff member Serrano
heard from neighbors concerning noise construction and noise from the proposed air
conditioning system. He explained that these concerns are subject to conditions outlined in the
2 Administrative Hearing
September 27,2018
in the Nuisance Ordinance. The applicant is required to adhere to these conditions regarding
construction hours and noise levels of equipment or be subject to Code Enforcement action. He
heard concerns regarding privacy. Duplex Zones are not required to plant trees for privacy,
however, there are Cypress trees on site that currently provide screening. Those trees will not
be removed as part of this project. Views are also currently obscured by an existing fence. The
fence will remain as is and is not included in the scope of the project. Staff supports the project
and recommends it approval.
The Hearing Officer asked how the proposed lot coverage of 35.3% compares with the lot
coverage of other homes in the neighborhood. Staff member Serrano stated that the 10 homes
he surveyed in the neighborhood have lot coverages ranging from 25% to 32.6%. The hearing
Officer asked for clarification of the surrounding lot sizes and for clarification how many other
homes on the street have second stories. Staff member Serrano stated that the majority of the
surrounding homes have a net lot size of between 8500 and 9500. One has a net lot size of
12,000, there are a few homes farther up the street with second story additions and the
townhome development behind the subject lot are all two story. The Hearing Officer asked
how far the rear building wall will be from the building wall to the property in the rear. Staff
member Serrano said it is about 38' or 39' building to building.
The project Architect, Susan Chen, addressed the Hearing Officer. She explained the project
scope and the thought process behind the project. She said that the addition was designed to
reduce as much as possible, the impact to the neighbors.
The Hearing Officer opened the public comment period.
Farah Tabatabai, 22841 Medina Lane — She rents out this address, but plans to move back
when she retires. To one side there is a wall. On the other side there is open space. She wants
to retain her privacy and views.
The Hearing Officer closed the comment period.
Staff member Serrano explained again the Duplex Zones are not required to provide privacy
screening, however, homeowners have options available to mitigate privacy concerns such as
opaque glass, inoperable windows and landscape plantings. Staff member Serrano reviewed
the title reports for both properties. He can confirm that there are no "light and air" easements.
The Hearing Officer explained that the City's needs to balance the rights of the property owner
to develop their properties and the needs of the neighborhood. Homes should "fit" and be of
good design. The City cannot take factor in sunlight and sight lines. This proposed
development is on a flag lot which makes this balance even more difficult. The Hearing Officer
reviewed the findings as listed in the Staff Report. He felt that the project meets development
zoning requirements per the Code with the exception of the "gradual transition" required in
the mass and scale of the project. He asked for a revision to the project design. He wanted the
second floor addition reduced. Staff member Serrano asked for clarification of where the
second story should terminate and if there were other design features that should be modified.
The Hearing Officer asked Staff to continue to work with the Architect to refine the design and
scale of the addition to accommodate reasonable access and connection to the ground floor.
The Hearing Officer approved the project with the following modification: Amend the design
to minimize the second story expansion to the minimum necessary connection between the
3 Administrative Hearing
September 27,2018
second floor and the ground floor and to allow architectural details and materials to be
consistent with the existing building.
DECISION: The application was approved by the Hearing Officer with the above mentioned
revision to the Draft Resolution.
3. Application No.(s): DP-2018-06,ASA-2018-07
Applicant: West Valley Community Services(SCC Fire Protection District)
Location: 10104 Vista Drive APN#(s):316-24-059
Development Permit and Architectural and Site Approval to consider a 1,016 square foot
second floor addition to an existing office building.
Administrative Hearing decision final unless appealed.
Staff member Yau addressed the Hearing Officer.The parcel was originally developed with 12
one-bedroom and 12 two-bedroom housing units and a 5177 square foot community center
and administrative offices building for West Valley Community Services. The proposed
project is to add square footage to the multi-use building to facilitate the reconfiguration of
interior space to improve efficiency and functionality. They will move conference rooms
around and be able to better use the food pantry. They will not be increasing staff so the
parking space count (52) will not be affected. The building is located in the Heart of the City
Specific Plan, so the design has been structured to include architectural features and minimize
wall massing. Staff recommends approval of the project.
The Hearing Officer asked the applicant to describe the partnership they have with the
residents. A representative of West Valley explained the public outreach process. They noticed
property owners within 500' of the project site. They held 2 evening, neighborhood meetings,
but had a very low turnout.
The Hearing Officer opened the public comment period.
There were no speakers:
The Hearing Officer closed the comment period.
The Hearing Officer thanked the Staff at West Valley Community Services for their service to
the community.He agrees with Staff's recommendation to approve the applications.
DECISION:The application was approved by the Hearing Officer per the draft resolutions.
ADJOURNMENT
Respectfully submitted:
6LAL a,9�
Beth Ebben
Deputy Board Clerk