HomeMy WebLinkAboutAH 08-09-2018 Cupertino, CA 95014
(408) 777-3308
APPROVED MINUTES OF THE REGULAR MEETING OF
THE ADMINISTRATIVE HEARING HELD ON August 9, 2018
ROLL CALL
Hearing Officer present: Benjamin Fu,Assistant Director of Community Development
Staff present: Gian Martire,Associate Planner
Catarina Kidd, Senior Planner
Applicant(s) present: Jane Lau, property owner 10550 Bette Ave
Bernard Baker, Project Manager for Tantau 14
Rebecca Tolentino, Planning Manager, Apple Inc.
Chris Grimmer, Landscape Architect, Apple Inc.
APPROVAL OF MINUTES:
1. April 12, 2018
The minutes of April 12, 2018 were approved as written
POSTPONEMENTS/REMOVAL FROM CALENDAR:
None
ORAL COMMUNICATIONS:
None
WRITTEN COMMUNICATIONS:
None
PUBLIC MEETING ITEMS:
2. Application No.(s): R-2018-20, INT-2018-01
Applicant: Clayton Johnson (Lau residence)
Location: 10550 Bette Ave APN#(s): 369-26-016
Front Yard Interpretation to designate the property line along Bette Avenue as the front lot
line to allow for a 198 square foot addition to the first floor and a Two Story Permit to allow a
980 square foot second floor to an existing single-story residence.
Administrative Hearing decision final unless appealed.
2 Administrative Hearing
August 9,2018
Staff Member Martire addressed the Hearing Officer. The subject lot is a corner lot. The current
Municipal Code calls for the shorter lot line of a corner parcel to be designated as the front
yard. This has caused many of the older housing developments to be non-compliant with
regard to front and side yard setbacks. The City has allowed Interpretations for front yard
definitions for corner lot homes where it can be shown that other corner lots have the same
configuration. Half of the homes (situated on a corner) in the neighborhood have a similar
layout. The applicant would like to add square footage to the first floor and add a second floor
to the existing residence. The additional square footage would not be allowed without a
determination to show the longer lot side as the front yard. Staff has worked with the
applicant for several months to develop a design that meets the current setback requirements
should the Interpretation be granted. One window on the east side of the proposed new
second floor will be required to have privacy tree planting. The neighbor requested a different
of tree species be planted and would like to have the window sill raised 5 feet.
The Hearing Officer asked for clarification of how this lot is compatible with the
neighborhood. Staff member Martire stated that half of the homes along Glenview Avenue
have the same lot configuration as proposed. This allows more light and air for the homes
along Bette Avenue that they otherwise wouldn't have. The Hearing Officer confirmed the
location of the easterly neighbor asking for the window revision. He then asked if the property
owner would like to make a statement. The property owner, Jane Lau, told the Hearing
Officer that she was redesigning her home to make it more comfortable to raising her family
in.
The Hearing Officer opened the public comment period.
David Herbert, 6693 Clifford Dr (property owner to the south) - He feels that the setback
encroachments make the structure too close to his home and will reduce his property value.
Elisa Herbert, 6693 Clifford Dr - She also feels that the encroachment of the addition and the
second story are too close to their house. The backyard privacy has been diminished. She
would like for the tree in the back yard remain to protect privacy.
Jennifer Griffin, a Cupertino resident - she asked if the front yard is determined to be on
another side of the house, does the house address have to change?
Kitty Moore, a Cupertino resident - asked for clarification of the second floor setback is, what
the elevation of the first floor is and what the other structures on the site are
The Hearing Officer closed the comment period.
Staff member Martire said that there is a pool in what is currently the side yard (per
definition). The pool will remain. The second story setback is 25 feet from the eastern property
line. This is consistent with how the City prescribes second story setbacks. It is also 20 feet
from the southern property line. The first floor is between 9 and 10 feet high. The Hearing
Officer asked if the Zoning Code contained any reference to property values or visibility. Staff
member Martire stated that is does not. The Hearing Officer clarified that the house address is
at the functional front of the house which is physically the side of the house and that the house
has been in its current orientation (usability) for 30 years or more. He clarified that the
3 Administrative Hearing
August 9,2018
addition is not going to be encroaching on existing open spaces. The Hearing Officer referred
to emails that were received by Staff and included in the packet. Staff member Martire
confirmed that they were from the neighbors on the east side of the subject property.
The Hearing Officer stated for the speakers that for these types of projects the Code is very
clear about what the property owner can and cannot do in terms of encroachment setback. In
reviewing the prosed project,Staff evaluated what the impacts to neighboring properties could
be and the overall affect in the neighborhood. They look at the impacts to the existing
properties as well as the reasonable and literal functionality of the subject property. They
cannot take into consideration perceived impacts to visibility, privacy and house values. He
noted that changing the current configuration of the home will still provide adequate
separation per the Municipal Code. The setbacks and lot coverage requirements are being met.
The development lot coverage is being increased from 32% to 35% and is in conformity with
the other homes in the neighborhood.
The Hearing Officer approved the findings on the Staff report.
DECISION: The application was approved by the Hearing Officer per the draft resolutions.
3. Application No.(s): ASA-2018-08, EA-2018-05
Applicant: Bernard Baker(Apple, Inc)
Location: 19020 Pruneridge Ave APN#(s):316-06-063
Architectural and Site Approval to consider a proposed 85,247 square foot office building
including revisions to the parking structure, from above grade to below grade, for a previously
approved office, research and development campus (Apple Park Phase 2-Tantau 14).
Administrative Hearing decision final unless appealed.
Staff member Kidd addressed the Hearing Officer. The project is part of Phase II of the
approved Apple Campus.This phase of the construction project is called Tantau 14. The Apple
Campus was originally approved in 2013. This project is being heard by the Administrative
Hearing Officer as the proposed changes to the original development approval are a reduction
in the scale of the project, change the parking from above ground to below ground and the
addition of a green roof. The Hearing Officer asked for clarification of how the proposed
changes to the originally approved development application are still in conformity. Staff
member Kidd explained that the development agreement master plan covers Phase I of the
new campus included the main campus building, the garage and associated amenity
buildings. The Phase II portion of the original development agreement includes all the
buildings on Tantau, the visitor center, R & D building and the office building, which is the
subject of the hearing today. The development agreement specified square footage, parking
spaces, height limits, the amount of staffing and the landscaping plans. As the development
has evolved over the years, necessary minor adjustments have come up. She stated that the
proposed project is still in conformity in that the changes are at or are less than the original
4 Administrative Hearing
August 9,2018
allowances. She referred to a chart in her staff report. The office space is a little less, the
amenity space is a little more, and the allocated number of parking spaces is the same, just
being broken up into above and below ground locations.
The Hearing Officer opened the public comment period.
Kitty Moore, a neighbor of the project - asked what the new Apple Park building, employee
and parking totals are. She also wanted all of the EIR addendums added to the Apple
webpage.
Milt Kosner, a neighbor of the project - spoke in favor of the underground parking and
retaining the concrete walls by his house. He wanted to make sure that the new tree species
being planted wouldn't interfere with power lines. He wanted to know when the estimated
end date of construction is. He wanted to know that Apple is constructing the building to the
highest earthquake standards and when Apple was going to be repairing the damage from the
construction vibrations to the homes near the visitor center was going to be done.
Pat Robbins, a neighbor of the project - listed several concerns regarding the Apple campus
operations: late hours, street sweeping, residential sound wall, smoking in the right of way.
Specific to the project, he wants to see better parking management. Employees and contractors
are parking in the neighborhoods around the visitor center.
Michael Stout, a neighbor of the project- was concerned about the deep excavation that would
be necessary for underground parking. There is current damage being done to homes in the
area from construction vibrations now. This will only continue with this proposal.
Underground parking is preferred, but the construction is a concern. He also expressed the
need for earthquake preparedness for an underground garage.
Rob Wagner, a neighbor of the project - emailed his comments earlier and brought a copy of it
with him to give to staff.
Jennifer Griffin, a neighbor of the project - wanted to know if this building construction was
the last of the construction. She also wanted to know how the dirt was going to be removed
from the site and how traffic around the site was going to be managed.
The Hearing Officer reviewed all of the concerns the speakers for the applicant. Most of the
concerns are related to the Apple Campus construction project as a whole rather than Tantau
14 specifically. He asked the applicant to address these questions.
The applicant, Bernard Baker, Apple Real Estate Development, addressed the Hearing Officer
and the speakers. He said the current completion date is the summer of 2020. The dirt removal
will be hauled according to the traffic management plan needed as one of the conditions of
approval for the project. They have a different street sweeping company than they have used
in the past. He hopes that they are more effective. This project should have less lane closure
occurrences than the larger project did. The neighbor fence along the side of the property
between Apple and the 27 residences was a project his predecessor had worked on. He said
that there had not been consensus with the neighbors regarding the new fence, so the project
to build a new fence has not moved forward. He recently spoke to the landscape architect,
Chris Grimmer. Cedar trees have been proposed as they will provide a nice visual screen.
They will be planting approximately 80 new trees and will confirm their growth rate and will
5 Administrative Hearing
August 9,2018
be maintaining them. He wasn't sure about the current parking space count,but was confident
that Apple, Inc. would be maintaining/retaining the originally approved space count allotted
for employees. The number of construction workers for this phase of the project is significantly
less and they should be using designated parking. Any complaints about contractors parking
will be forwarded to the Construction Manager. The buildings are constructed to Building
Code, including earthquake ready requirements. Not being a structural engineer, he could not
attest to anything else. Apple prides itself on high quality work and the buildings are being
built to code or above. All of the buildings have low-glare paint treatments, the lights have
been adjusted to reduce or eliminate night time light pollution and the rooftop mechanical
equipment is all being screened. Apple is installing glass film on the windows for additional
privacy for its employees and screening for the neighbors. There is a creekside easement that
the Water District controls, but a cooperative agreement is in place regarding the trees in that
area. The Hearing Officer asked staff about the building permitting process. She stated that the
Building Official meets on a weekly basis with the Apple construction team to discuss required
permits and code standards. This weekly dialog goes over construction standards,
complaints/concerns and enforcement. This team has been working together for years and
works well together. Conversations have occurred between Apple and individual
homeowners regarding property damage. Those conversations will continue.
The Hearing Officer closed the comment period.
The Hearing Officer thanked everyone for coming and for participating in the meeting. The
Hearing Officer thanked the Apple representative for attending the meeting and being
available to answer questions. The Hearing Officer supports the project and concurs that the
proposed modifications fall within the original approval of the development agreement.
DECISION: The application was approved by the Hearing Officer per the draft resolutions.
ADJOURNMENT
Respectfully submitted:
&1(7L
Beth Ebben
Deputy Board Clerk
i