HomeMy WebLinkAboutAH 04-12-2018 Cupertino, CA 95014
(408) 777-3308
APPROVED MINUTES OF THE REGULAR MEETING OF
THE ADMINISTRATIVE HEARING HELD ON April 12, 2018
ROLL CALL
Hearing Officer present: Benjamin Fu, Assistant Director of Community Development
Staff present: Gian Martire, Associate Planner
Applicant(s) present: Cindy Hsu (Greenleaf Group, LLC), property owner/developer
Mike Chen, Architect for the property owner
APPROVAL OF MINUTES:
1. February 8, 2018
The minutes of February 8, 2018 were approved as written
POSTPONEMENTS/REMOVAL FROM CALENDAR:
None
ORAL COMMUNICATIONS:
None
WRITTEN COMMUNICATIONS:
None
PUBLIC MEETING ITEMS:
2. Application No.(s): TM-2017-02,R-2018-08,R-2018-09,TR-2018-05 (EA-2017-02)
Applicant: Cindy Hsu(Greenleaf Group, LLC)
Location: 22561 Alcalde Road APN#(s): 342-29-063
Tentative Map application to allow the subdivision of a 19,562 square foot lot into 2 residential lots of
approximately 8,892 square feet each; and to allow the construction of 2, new two-story single family
residences on the newly created lots; and a Tree Removal Permit to allow the removal and replacement
of trees to facilitate the residential construction; A Mitigated Negative Declaration
Administrative Hearing decision final unless appealed.
2 Administrative Hearing
February 12,2018
Staff Member Martire addressed the Hearing Officer. The subject lot is located in the R1-7.5
Zone. The applicant is proposing to subdivide the parcel into 2 equal size lots of
approximately 8900 square feet each. The new lots will be 89 feet wide, far exceeding the
minimum lot width of 60 feet. Each lot will also have a 10 foot public works easement to allow
for new sidewalks, curbs and gutters. The lots will then be developed with one two-story
home on each lot. The homes meet all the R1 Zone requirements for setbacks, parking and
FAR. There is a 37" diameter Coast Live oak tree located in the middle of Lot B. This tree will
be removed and replaced in accordance with the City's Tree Ordinance. Although it is not
required, the applicant will plant privacy trees along the North property line, towards the
residential duplex to mitigate any privacy concerns the neighbors there may have. This project
was heard buy the Environmental Review Committee at their regular meeting on March 1,
2018. The Committee recommended approval of a Mitigated Negative Declaration. Mitigations
include, a nesting bird survey, a soil remediation plan and lead and asbestos study prior to the
demolition of the existing home on the site. During the comment period for the Environmental
Review Committee meeting and the Administrative Hearing meeting, comments were
received from neighbors. Staff has addressed those comments in the Staff report. The
comments were primarily regarding the disruption of the neighborhood during the
construction process and the widening of the street. .Staff member Martire conceded that
construction is a disruption that there is not much that can be done about, however, he
explained that the City and other Regulatory Agencies have rules and guidelines that the
applicant will be required to follow during construction. A violation of these rules will
constitute a Code Violation. Neighbors were also concerned that the street would become too
wide so as to have the potential of becoming a safety hazard. He explained that the road will
not be any wider that is current. A good example is the road in front of 22539 and 22159
Alcalde Road. The public works easement will not widen the road it will be along the road for
sidewalk improvements and street trees. Another comment suggested that the homes be
limited to single story. Staff member Martire stated that two story homes are allowed in the R1
Zone.
The Hearing Officer asked for clarification about how the lots are exempt from the privacy tree
planting requirement. Staff Member Martire explained that per the Code, second story
windows with a 5' (or lower) sill from the floor, needs to have trees planted in order to
obstruct views into neighboring back and side yards. The second story of the home does not
have these low sills. The lower floor does, but first floor windows do not trigger the privacy
planting requirement. However, the applicant is willing to plant the trees anyway. The
Hearing Officer asked how many protected trees are on site. There is one. There are other
trees on site that will be removed and replaced. The Hearing Officer noted that the lots have
different side setbacks. Staff member Martire stated that the proposed home on Lot A will
have an additional onsite parking area, so the setback on that side was reduced for the carport.
The Hearing Officer asked for clarification about one of the Findings mentioned in the Draft
Resolution for the Two-Story Residences, stating that the homes are "harmonious in scale and
design with the neighborhood". Staff member Martire stated that the proposed homes are not
3 Administrative Hearing
February 12,2018
the first two-story homes in the area. There are several other examples of two-story or single-
story additions creating a second story in the neighborhood.
The Hearing Officer asked the Architect to explain how his design supports the finding of the
homes being "harmonious in scale and design with the neighborhood". Architect, Mike Chen,
said that the homes were designed based on the shape of the lots, such that they would fit on
the lots nicely. The design of the homes is a Tuscany style similar to many homes in the City.
He mentioned that the houses are proposed to be built lower than what is allowed.
The Hearing Officer opened the public comment period.
A neighbor, John Kolski, addressed the Hearing Officer. He has submitted several comments
regarding the project. He is very concerned about the construction process as there is another
development happening in the area. It has been going on for a very long time and has been
very disruptive to the neighborhood.
Staff member Martire explained how the construction permitting process works. Once the
Building Permit has been applied for, the Public Works department imposes conditions on the
contractor. These conditions will need to be satisfied before the construction permits will be
issued. These conditions will include grading, compaction of the infill and an approved bio-
swale design to meet the C-3 requirements for runoff water control and the street
improvements. The Hearing Officer is approving conceptual designs at this meeting. The
Planning Department will also review the construction drawings to make sure that the homes
are built within the allowed setbacks, at the proper heights and with approved landscape and
site improvements. Staff member Martire then read from the Conditions of Approval from the
Draft Resolution for the R-2018-08 and R-2018-09 applications and the terms in the Best
Construction Management Plan. He stated that the contractor and developer are responsible
for knowing and following the rules and are subject to sanctions if they don't.
The Hearing Officer admonished the developer to be aware of the sensitivities of the
neighbors. He asked that Staff let Mr. Kolski know when the building permit has been applied
for so he can review the Construction Management Plan.
The Hearing Officer closed the comment period.
The Hearing Officer supports the project. The homes meet the Zoning Code requirements and
the design is cohesive with the neighborhood. He again asked the developer to work with the
neighbors to ensure a smooth process.
DECISION: The application was approved by the Hearing Officer per the draft resolutions.
ADJOURNMENT
Respectfully submitted:
LflIt-, 2"I/yu
Beth Ebben
Deputy Board Clerk