Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutAH 10-26-2017 Cupertino, CA 95014 (408) 777-3308 APPROVED MINUTES OF THE REGULAR MEETING OF THE ADMINISTRATIVE HEARING HELD ON October 26, 2017 ROLL CALL Hearing Officer present: Benjamin Fu, Assist. Director of Community Development Staff present: Ellen Yau, Assistant Planner Applicant(s) present: Tracy Gessner, Project Manager,Jones, Lang &LaSalle for Bank of America Whitney Marr, Architect, Gensler APPROVAL OF MINUTES: 1. June 8, 2017 The minutes of June 8, 2017 were approved as written POSTPONEMENTS/REMOVAL FROM CALENDAR: Item #2 -Architectural and Site approval to allow exterior building and site modifications to an existing Jack in the Box restaurant. Application No(s): ASA-2017-07; Applicant(s): Greg Borchardt (Albert Tung); Location: 1451 S De Anza Boulevard APN#366-19-044-The applicant has requested a postponement to November 9, 2017 ORAL COMMUNICATIONS: None WRITTEN COMMUNICATIONS: Emails and a letter from IntraHealth were received regarding item #3 PUBLIC MEETING ITEMS: 2. Application No.(s): ASA-2017-07 Applicant: Greg Borchardt(Albert Tung) Location: 1451 S De Anza Boulevard APN#366-19-044 Architectural and Site approval to allow exterior building and site modifications to an existing Jack in the Box restaurant 2 Administrative Hearing October 26,2017 Administrative Hearing decision final unless appealed. DECISION: The Hearing Officer approved the applicant's request for a postponement to the November 9, 2017 meeting. 3. Application No.(s): ASA-2017-05,TR-2017-39 Applicant: Whitney Marr(C&L Investments, LLC) Location: 21020 Homestead Road APN#326-07-020 Major Architectural and Site Approval to allow for the demolition of an existing single-story 6,000 square feet multi-tenant commercial building and to allow for the construction of a new single-story 4,178 square feet Bank of America branch building and ancillary parking lot improvements, landscaping, and frontage and street improvements including a paved plaza area at the intersection of Homestead and North Stelling Roads; Tree Removal Permit to allow the removal and replacement of fourteen(14)protected trees Administrative Hearing decision final unless appealed. Staff Member Yau addressed the Hearing Officer. The proposed project will remove an existing 5,265 square foot commercial building housing 3 different tenants. The new commercial building will be 4,000 square feet and will house a bank branch. Site improvements are included in the proposal; re-striping of the parking lot, sidewalk and driveway modifications and the construction of a public plaza space. The lot is zoned for commercial use, so the change in tenancy does not require a change to the Zoning. The proposed changes are in conformance with the City's Parking Ordinance and General Plan requirements. The site improvements will result in an increase of 16 spaces above what is required, there will be 4 additional bicycle spaces, the new building will be constructed closer to the street to allow for better pedestrian access and the driveway cuts will be reduced to enhance pedestrian and cyclist safety. The new plaza will serve as a City amenity, providing shade and seating. A consulting Arborist has reviewed the trees and recommends the removal and replacement of the Palm trees in the parking lot as they will not survive transplanting and other trees on site need removed to facilitate the sidewalk improvements. All trees will be removed and replaced in accordance with the City Tree Ordinance. The City's Public Works, Environmental Services and Building Departments have reviewed the application as well as the affected outside agencies. The proposed building design meets the height and elevation requirements and incorporates decorative and architectural features. Staff has received comments and concerns about the project relating to traffic, tenancy and the tree removals. Staff recommends approval of the project as it meets all the Zoning and General Plan requirements. 3 Administrative Hearing October 26,2017 The Hearing Officer asked for clarification about the comments received. Staff member Yau said correspondence had been received regarding the proposed change in the tenancy of the site. She has responded that the City cannot make tenant decisions and does not have the authority to dictate whom a landlord leases space to as long as the proposed use of the space meets the Zoning Code for the parcel. In this case, people are concerned that the personal service providers (hair salon, chiropractor and physical therapist) are being replaced by a Bank of America branch. She also received correspondence asking why so many trees need to be removed. The trees were evaluated by an arborist. Based on the scope of the work, the arborist recommended that the trees be removed. The trees will be replaced with 14, 24" or 36" box trees depending on the species of the trees. The final landscape plan will need to be approved by Staff before the issuance of any building permits. Staff member Yau said that inquiries were also received relating to parking and traffic. She said that because the size of the building is being reduced, the applicant will have 33 on-site parking spaces, which is 16 spaces more than what is required by the Parking Ordinance. The driveway is being reduced, but the traffic pattern will remain the same. The reduced driveway allows more space for pedestrians and bicyclists to be away from the busy street. A traffic study indicated that the new commercial use would only generate 14 more trips during the peak pm times. The Hearing Officer asked about the required building setbacks. The proposed new construction is located in the City's Stelling Gateway/Homestead Special Area. Buildings in this area need to have a 1 to 1 ratio for building height to front setback. The proposed building will be 22' in height (where 30' is allowed). The proposed front setback is also 22'. The applicant, Tracy Gessner, Project Manager for Bank of America, addressed the Hearing Officer. She said that Bank of America will be installing a full service branch in this new location to provide a full range of banking services to their Cupertino and Sunnyvale customers. The site improvements they would like to make will be an enhancement to the corner. Whitney Marr, Architect for Gensler, addressed the Hearing Officer. He said that banks are an essential service for people. Bank of America wants to have a full service bank available to its customers in a beautiful new building located on a prominent corner in the City. He said that the current building height is 15' and they are going up to 22' in order to be able to screen the mechanical equipment on the roof. He has worked very closely with City Staff to design a special space that better meets the needs of the public and is aesthetically pleasing. The Hearing Officer asked Staff member Yau about the discussions concerning the traffic circulation. The applicant has agreed to work with the Public Works Department to limit the turning to right turn only when exiting the site onto Stelling. The Hearing Officer opened the item for Public Comment: Brian Rainie; He currently walks to the chiropractor who is a tenant in the existing building. He said that there are two other Bank of America within walking distance and does not feel the need for another branch. He feels that the City would be better served by keeping the chiropractic offices. 4 Administrative Hearing October 26,2017 Doctor of Chiropractic Medicine and Physical Therapy, Petra Eggert, DC, PT; She is the owner of the chiropractic office, IntraHealth, located in the current building. She read from a prepared statement. (The statement is has been included in the public record for this meeting) A Sunnyvale resident, Karl Schmidt;He is a patient of IntraHealth. He values and supports the work that they do. He does not want their offices replaced by a bank. A San Jose resident, Marcie Griffin; She is a patient at IntraHealth. She prefers to see Dr. Eggert for physical therapy rather than use the service through her health care provider. She does not want the chiropractic office replaced by a bank. It would be a disservice to the Community. Roshan Bedi; She is a long time patient of IntraHealth. She says the services she has received over the years has been extremely beneficial to her. There are no other chiropractors in the area, but lots of Bank of America branches. She wanted to know if the other branches were going to be closed or was Bank of America planning on having branches on every corner? A Mountain View resident, Marisa Oranfill; She is a patient and teacher at IntraHealth. She has been in the area for 2 years. She is also a Bank of America customer. She is very happy with the bank and has visited lots of the local branches. But her relationship with IntraHealth is means much more to her. Dr. Eggert reached out to her and welcomed her when she was new to the Community. She has referred many people to IntraHealth for treatment. A Cupertino resident, Jennifer Griffin; She expressed her concerned about the traffic flow in the area. She said a U Turn should be allowed on Stelling at Homestead because you cannot make a left and go to the bank from that direction. You have to go all the way down to Mary and make a U Turn there. The Sunnyvale side of that intersection has been remarked and you cannot turn there now. She asked about the ATM locations on the bank building and where are people supposed to stand? A Sunnyvale resident, Tim Williams; He is not a patient of Dr. Eggert, but his chiropractor is. He feels that Dr. Eggert is a valuable member of Cupertino's community and to lose her and her practice would be unfair to the community. Marie Jacobson; She is an Acupuncturist and Herbalist at IntraHealth. She also takes classes there. She has spent a lot of time growing her business and does not want to move. Susan Gable; She is a patient at IntraHealth. She spoke very highly of Dr. Egger, about how she really cares for her patients and the work that she does. She also feels that killing 14 trees to beautify the corner is sacrilege. She that compared to the other businesses fronting the intersection, this corner is already the nicest. She also feels that narrowing the driveway will cause problems. A Cupertino resident, Linda Lee; She is the owner of the hair salon. She has been at her current site for 5 years, but was across the street for almost 25. She likes where she is and would like to stay. One of the male speakers additionally commented that the IntraHealth is also a benefit to the community on the weekends and evenings on a regular basis. He wanted to make sure this was taken into consideration 5 Administrative Hearing October 26,2017 One of the female speakers further commented that it would be tremendous loss to the community. Bank of America would not be a benefit to the community in the way that Dr. Eggert is. The Hearing Officer closed the Public Comment period. The Hearing Officer asked Staff where the ATMs would be located. Staff member Yau said that they would be located on the southeast corner of the building and visible from the public right-of-way. There will be parking stalls directly in front of them as well. The Hearing Officer asked Staff about the mitigations to the concerns about the traffic flow that was brought up. Staff member Yau said that left turns are permitted into and out of the driveways (per the California State Vehicle Code) as the road is striped with double yellow lines, a U Turn is not necessary. A traffic impact analysis was not required by the Public Works Department as the impact was well less than an increase of 100 trips per the guidelines set by VTA (Valley Transportation Authority of Santa Clara County). The Hearing Officer asked staff about the necessity to remove the trees. Staff member Yau restated that the Palm trees will not survive the replanting process so need to be replaced and that with the sidewalk modifications - moving the sidewalk such that there is street, trees and then the sidewalk, several trees will need removed and replaced to accommodate the new design. The City's consulting arborist reviewed the site and identified necessary removals and recommended a replanting solution. The final landscape plan will be further reviewed and approved by the arborist prior to permit issuance and then again before final occupancy. The Hearing Officer was asked about the City's tax revenue change from the current tenancy use to the proposed tenancy use. He replied that the change of the usage and the financial implications of the change was not something the Community Development Department was privy to as it is not a factor in the development application process. The inquiry would be better directed to the Finance Department. Staff member Yau was asked to explain the definition of protected trees to the audience. "Protected Trees" is a term that applied to trees planted as part of the approval of a development project. So trees of all sizes and species fall into the 'protected tree category' depending on when and why they were planted. The Hearing Officer thanked everyone for coming to speak on behalf of Dr. Eggert. He appreciated the passion and understood her place in the service to the community. He explained that it is the Department's role to ensure that permitted uses are allowed in areas according to the zoning permissions per parcel as defined by the City's Municipal Code. The requested use change is permitted by Code, so the City cannot deny the application upon that fact. The City will process the application to ensure that public and traffic safety concerns are met. DECISION: The application was approved by the Hearing Officer per the draft resolution with the following additions/modifications: 1) Site signage speaking to allow traffic to turn onto the site will be incorporated into the resolution 6 Administrative Hearing October 26,2017 ADJOURNMENT Respectfully submitted: & Ck" Beth Ebben Administrative Assistant