Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutAH 02-23-2017 Cupertino, CA 95014 (408) 777-3308 APPROVED MINUTES OF THE REGULAR MEETING OF THE ADMINISTRATIVE HEARING HELD ON February 23, 2017 ROLL CALL Hearing Officer present: Benjamin Fu, Assist. Director of Community Development Staff present: Erick Serrano, Associate Planner Applicant(s) present: Diane Hsu, representative, Christian Light and Salt Foundation APPROVAL OF MINUTES: 1. Minutes of February 9, 2017 The minutes of February 9, 2017 were approved as written POSTPONEMENTS/REMOVAL FROM CALENDAR: None ORAL COMMUNICATION: None WRITTEN COMMUNICATIONS: Several emails have been received in regards to Item #2 PUBLIC HEARING ITEMS: 2. Application No.(s): U-2016-02, DIR-2016-34 Applicant: Dian Hsu (Christian Light&Salt Foundation) Location: 940 S Stellling Road APN#: 359-25-041 Amendment to an existing Use Permit to allow a private school/daycare center to expand their hours of operation to 7:OOam to 6:OOpm; Director's Minor Modification to allow modifications to the site including installation of an outdoor play structure. Administrative Hearing decision final unless appealed. 2 Administrative Hearing February 23,2017 Staff Member Serrano presented the Staff Report to the Hearing Officer. The applicant would like to modify their existing current after school day care operations from 12 (noon) to 6:30 pm with a maximum of 90 students, as per Planning Commission approval in 2009, to an all-day i private daycare/afterschool care program with a maximum 70 students, aged 2 to 6 years, and 8 Staff members. They would also like to add a play area and a play structure. The daycare operations require 11 parking spaces and parents are required to use the on-site spaces when dropping off or picking up their children. The church operations require 57 spaces, so there is ample parking on site to allow for both daycare and church office operations should both activities be occurring at the same time. The site is Zoned Quasi-Pubic (BQ). It is surrounded on the east, west and north by single family residences and on the south by Jollyman Park. The City's traffic Engineer reviewed the project and believes that the traffic added during morning or afternoon peak traffic commute hour is minimal. Additionally, with the reduction in students, no traffic mitigation measures are required. The proposed play structure is 14' in height and will be set back 55' from the nearest residential property, located to the east. A Noise Study was prepared by the City's Acoustic Consultant. This study determined that the decibel levels were expected to be intermittent and between 50 to 60 decibels at 30 to 40 feet within the play yard. Due to the wooden fences, the decibel level would drop 12 to 13 decibels in the yards of the closest residences. This noise level does not require mitigation measures. The project was properly noticed for a public hearing and in addition the property owner conducted two outreach meetings to help explain the project to their neighbors. Staff has received questions regarding the project concerning; permitted uses, expiration of permitted uses, noise and parking and traffic and safety. The Sheriff's office was informed of the safety concerns. They stated that the Church property has not been a safety issue in the past. The other concerns have been addressed in the Staff Report. Staff supports approval of the project as it meets all of the City's Municipal Code requirements and the conditions of approval addresses and/or mitigates other concerns raised. The Hearing Officer confirmed that the prior approval was for 90 students to be on site from 12 (noon) to 6:30pm and that the new proposal is to have 70 students on site from 7:OOam to 6:30pm. He clarified the number of parking spaces and the distance from the play structure to the nearest home. Dian Hsu, the representative for the Christian Light and Salt Foundation, addressed the Hearing Officer. She thanked Staff for their hard work on the proposed project. She stated that parents will be required, as part of the enrollment packet, to park in the on-site parking spaces and may not park on the public street. Further, she stated that the classroom and the church office is closer to the parking lot than the street. The church was made aware of the traffic concerns from the driveway onto Stelling Road at their public meeting. [-NOTE - these plans are not part of the project proposed at this hearing. The item at this hearing is a proposal to extend the existing daycare hours of operation and install playground equipment. -] She wanted to address the two main concerns of the neighbors; traffic and noise: They have 3 Administrative Hearing February 23,2017 consulted with City Staff, traffic engineers, Public Works and other private consultants to see what they can do, maybe add another driveway. They are working on a plan to help the situation. The church has offered to raise the fence heights to help with noise reduction. She reminded the Hearing Officer that the drop off and pick up times of the children will be staggered so the traffic impacts should not be great. All of the cars will not be there at one time. The State Department of Child Care Licensing says that the church cannot reduce its hours of operation and still be a licensed day care location. They also must provide their own play area/structure in an enclosed area and cannot use the City's facilities at Jollyman Park. Parents and church members will be required to use the church's parking lot. If the neighborhood wishes to pursue permit parking for the street, they should keep in mind that they may inconvenience their guests who would not have a permit and they may want to park in the Church lot. The Church would not be responsible for people's cars in their lot. The Church has developed some alternate plans to help the neighborhood. [—NOTE — these plans are not part of the project proposed at this hearing. The item at this hearing is a proposal to extend the existing daycare hours of operation and install playground equipment. —] The applicant went on to state that the church and school uses are appropriate for the site and the neighborhood. They want to work together and be good neighbors. The Hearing Officer asked the applicant about the current traffic circulation on site and if this proposal would change it. The applicant said the traffic would not change other than parents now will only have 10 minutes to drop off and pick their children. They come from Stelling onto Jollyman and into the parking lot and back out the same way, turning left or right onto Jollyman depending on which way they need to go to get to work. The Hearing Officer asked how the church was going to enforce/monitor the traffic situation. She said that the daycare teachers and church office employees would be able to see what was happening on the parking lot and that parents would be made aware of the rules and of the consequences. He asked about the prospect of adding another driveway. She said the thoughts are to open a driveway onto Stelling. This will provide another access point to help relieve traffic on Jollyman. They are looking into the feasibility of that. The Hearing Officer opened the item for Public Comment: A Cupertino City resident, Munir Vora, he said that the prior childcare operations were not managed well and the neighbors were not informed of it. He has major concerns that this day care will cause the same issues as the prior one. He wants to see the traffic report and see what it is based on. A Cupertino City resident, Raj Avasarala, he asked about the noise study. He wanted to know if the City would be responsible if he noise report was found to be in error. The neighborhood does not consider a full time private daycare center a minor change to the Use permit. He called into question the original approval being suspect. He thought that the number of students on site would be more than 70 and that traffic would be increased by the additional staff not taken into account by the Church, volunteers or teacher helpers as an example. He 4 Administrative Hearing February 23,2017 continued to read the email sent to Staff member Serrano by resident, Munir Vora. (This email is located in Public Records, attached to this meeting) A Cupertino City resident, Daniel Lee, asked how the enforcement of the parking and drop off, asked if the operation is not a commercial one, is there a charge for the daycare service? And how was the noise level determined? Was the test taken while children were outside playing? A Cupertino City resident, Raja Kommula, he has lived in his house for a long time and there was no prior notification of a daycare. He is heavily impacted by the churcWs day care operations. The traffic in the area is a safety concern in that his children cannot cross the street to go to the park. He also says there are privacy concerns with that many cars being in front of his house in the morning. He house was broken into in 2015 and no noticed a thing because there are cars parked all around. He has witnessed people parking on the street and entering the church. The cars are parking on the street for hours. He feels certain that the situation will only get worse. A Santa Clara City resident, Kelly Kucic, spoke in support of the project. She thought that having a daycare center in the neighborhood is a nice amenity. She felt an early education program is a benefit to the school system at large. She felt that the traffic situation could be managed such that it would not be a problem. Her experience indicates that good preschools increase property values as well. A Cupertino City resident, Ernest Lin, he feels that the Christian values passed along to the children through the day care operators is good. He is a member of the Church and knows that these are good people who will manage and provide a beneficial service to the neighborhood and community. He knows that the traffic is bad, it is bad all over town. However, he is asking for the neighbors to trust the church when they say that they want to be good neighbors and will monitor the traffic and parking. A Sunnyvale City resident, Mei Wang, she spoke of her experience very similar to this where there was a church operated day care and then they leased the church space to a private organization to operate with expanded hours in a densely populated area. Unfortunately, they had to cease operations. She stated that there is a real need for preschool care/church run daycare and asked that they be given a chance. A Fremont City resident, Janice Fong, she stated that she is an active member of the church congregation as well as in church management. She is very excited to be able to offer day care services to the Community. The day care center will not only teach early academics but also teach strong Christian values. A Cupertino City resident, Bhavini Kamarshi, she also said that the prior day care operated outside of the Use Permit rules and that the public was not part of the permitting process. She is concerned that the proposed new day care use will also not be monitored and it will flaunt the rules as well. She does not feel that a new day care use should be allowed since a prior day care use was in violation of the rules. She also stated that the traffic study was not done based on the actual traffic patterns in the area. She wanted to know how the school was going to deal 5 Administrative Hearing February 23,2017 with the parking when the preschool has events. She asked that with the stated decline in elementary school enrollment was there even a need for another preschool in the area? She said that the traffic hazards aren't just with the school but with people going to and from the park. A Cupertino City resident, Jane Chiu, advised the Hearing Office that she is the owner of the current after school program. She was the pastor wife and helped cleanup church exterior and interior. Angela Le asked her to run preschool. She works in the office so hears the noise. She has lived in the area for a long time, loves children and the community. She says that there is a demand for Christian preschools and children are on wait lists. She said the traffic is everyone's problem to solve. She wants to be a good neighbor and wants to work to earn the trust of the neighborhood. A Cupertino City resident, Scott Hughes, said he is not opposed to having a day care center as long as the concerns of the neighborhood are addressed. He is also concerned about what would happen if the day care center operations were transferred to a new entity. He asked about how the early 7 am start time originated. He feels that it is too early. He wanted to see the traffic report as there is congestion on surrounding streets and not just Jollyman and Stelling. He also stated that since the possible addition of a new driveway changes the entire scope of the project, the project should've been re-noticed to the residents with this information. He felt that disclosure of this information now was not proper. He asked that in the future, there should be a dialogue between the residents, the applicant and the City prior to a formal hearing. A Cupertino City resident, Li Qin Zhou, she has small children so would benefit from the preschool, but echoes the neighbors' concerns. She wanted to know if the City or school would take responsibility for any events. A Cupertino City resident, Penny Peng, she thought that only local persons should be able to comment on the project. She felt that the project was a good one, but it has to work with the neighbors. She thinks the driveway off of Stelling is a good idea. She doesn't think that that the project should be approved without this additional driveway. She also said that a decision should not be made today because of all the things that need worked out. A Cupertino City resident, Weiming Zhou, asked if his written communications were taken into consideration and if they were part of the record. He said he is worried about the traffic. In the morning the traffic on Stelling is bad. It is hard to get in and out. The Hearing Officer closed the Public Comment period. The Hearing Officer asked to the applicant to confirm that the day care operations were just from Monday to Friday. No weekend hours. She confirmed, no weekends. The Hearing Officer asked her to clarify if the Church was running the school or if a private entity was. She clarified that the preschool/daycare was being run by the Church. He asked Staff if he had received any documents from the Sheriff's Officer specifically relating to complaints about the church operations or the prior day care uses. Staff member Serrano said he had received no documentation from the Sheriff specifically related to the Church or the prior uses on site. 6 Administrative Hearing February 23,2017 There have been complaints as mentioned by the neighbors but nothing that could be tied back to the Church or that the Church directly caused. He asked Staff what the City's ability was, and the methodology used, to enforce the Use Permit Conditions of Approval. Staff member Serrano stated that there are different ways, but that if the City became aware that the applicant was in violation of the Use Permit, the permissions could be revoked. The Code Enforcement Department would receive and investigate claims and complaints. They would work with the applicants to rectify them. If no resolution is achieved, fines can be levied and ultimately, permissions revoked. The Hearing Officer asked Staff to explain how the noise levels determined, changed between the current use and the proposed use. A third party Noise Consultant conducted the study. They used 'best practices' to measure the noise, they looked at the programming and the location of the play area. The Consultant determined that given the distance from the play area and the residents to the South, the decibel levels would be within the City's noise standards of 55 to 60 during the day. There is a 55' foot clearance including fences and vegetation, so decibel levels of 48 to 50 at a maximum could be expected at the property lines. The Hearing Officer asked the applicant and Staff to talk about how the research was coming for the feasibility of adding another driveway on Stelling Road. Staff member Serrano said that they had some preliminary conversations regarding at that option. It would be at an existing 3-way stop. The applicant looked at the cost and the issues with the utility junctions on site. The applicant has done some more research with engineers and if it were possible to add a driveway, it would be a 2 way, in-and-out at that intersection. The Hearing Officer asked if the City's traffic engineer had looked at the design, Staff said they had looked at the preliminary design and had no concerns. The stop would become a 4 way stop with the new driveway. The 41h stop would be unused some of the time as it would only be accessed when persons were entering or exiting the church property. He said that would be the preferred way for traffic to enter the church lot and would alleviate traffic on Jollyman. He asked Staff about the noticing that had been done for the hearing item on tonight's agenda. Staff member Serrano said that the proper noticing has been done. The noticing for the prior application was a 500' noticing radius. That project was heard by the Planning Commission. The Hearing Officer asked the applicant about the 7:OOam start time. She said that only one or two children would be being dropped off at 7. The 7 start time is mostly for their staff time arrival to be able to get ready for the day, but that the pre-school starts its day at 7. He asked if there would be any impacts if the school opened later. She said they could think about that. The Hearing Officer re-opened the item for Public Comment: A Cupertino City resident, Munir Vora, stated that it would be very nice to delay the approval of this application until they had a chance to work collaboratively with each other. He did not like the new information brought in at the last minute without any prior notice. The traffic is a real safety concern. He disputed methodology of the traffic report and noise study. He also said that the prior application (2008) was not noticed properly and he wants proof that it was. He wants to know what the City will do to be responsible to the property owners on this street. 7 Administrative Hearing February 23,2017 A Cupertino City resident, Bhavini Kamarshi, she thought that the idea that the preschool teacher would be watching the traffic was not reasonable. They should be watching the children not the traffic. She also felt that the 10 minute drop off and pick up rule was also not reasonable. People stop and talk. She mentioned that recently changes were made at the intersection of Stelling and McClellan which has cause huge back up to the 85 bridge. She suggested that any more changes to the traffic would flow would only add to the wait times. She also said that there was not site signage on the property for the prior application. She didn't think that a decibel level could be determined without measuring the noise of actual children at play. The Hearing Officer re-closed the Public Comment period. The Hearing officer asked Staff to elaborate on how the Noise Study was conducted. The Noise Study was conducted by the City's Noise Consultant. They conducted their study in September. They look at the project description, they then measure decibels from the "receptor" areas. As there is no play structure on the site, they found that the most noise was generated from the traffic. The ambient traffic noise on Jollyman Road was not loud enough to cause concern to the residents. Based upon the City's existing Noise Ordinance base line decibel level, the intermittent noise from children at play would not create a situation where the noise allowances were continuously violated. However if the City receives complaints that he noise to so loud all the time, then it would be investigated. Persons in the audience again questioned the validity of the report and suggested that the study be conduct at different times of the year to ensure compliance, not just when there is a complaint. The Hearing Officer clarified that the noise study that was done in this case was done per "standard" conditions for the City, no special consideration were incurred or included, Staff member Serrano confirmed. The Hearing Officer asked Staff to clarify the permitted uses at the site. Staff member Serrano explained that daycare uses are a conditional use in the BQ (Quasi Public) Zoning designation. A daycare center at a church is not classified as a commercial use. The Hearing Officer asked if Staff was aware of situation of were noise studies were conducted on a routine basis and not as part of a complaint or enforcement action. He then sked the applicant if they were alright with a periodic check up on the noise level to ensure that the noise level would stay within the City's Noise Ordinance. Diane Hsu stated that the children would only be outside from 9- 11:30am and from 3-5:30pm per classroom. She felt that additional studies may place an undue hardship in the operations, especially if they had to pay for additional studies. . The Hearing Officer asked Staff what the process was when a noise complaint is received. Staff explained that a Code Enforcement Officer would go to the site with a decibel meter and record the noise level at the property line. And then would report back to the complainant and the City. The City does not charge for this kind of testing. The Hearing Officer asked Staff to explain the Permit Parking process. Staff member Serrano said that the Public Works department issues On-Street Parking Permits. He would check and see what information he could find. The Hearing Officer asked the applicant about how they plan on managing the traffic for drop off and pick up. Diane Hsu thanked the Hearing Officer as she wanted to clarify the procedure. I I g Administrative Hearing February 23,2017 They have enough parking on site that there should be no back up on the streets from parents dropping off or picking up their children. Their staff would go out and escort children in only if they see a congestion problem during peak times, as an example. But generally, they have plenty of parking so that there should be no delays on the neighborhood streets. The church is lucky in that respect since other preschools do not have enough parking. She said that if a teacher sees that a parent is not following the rules, that teacher will report it to the Director for enforcement. The Hearing Officer asked if the Director could be in charge of the drop off/pick up process to ensure that the parents adhere to the rules. Staff member Serrano reported on the On-Street Parking Permit process; the neighborhood would have to submit a petition to the City, 2/3 of the property owners would have to sign the petition. He did not have the fee amount, but the City's Fee Schedule is available on-line. The Public Works Staff would receive the application/petition and submit it to the City Council for approval. [- NOTE - these plans are not part of the project proposed at this hearing. The item at this hearing is a proposal to extend the existing daycare hours of operation and install playground equipment. -] The Hearing Officer confirmed with Staff that the City's Engineer's response to the possibility of a driveway off of Stelling would help alleviate some of the circulation traffic issues in the area. He confirmed. The Hearing Officer then asked the applicant if they had had a chance to further explore that option. She said they are reviewing on it. [- NOTE - these plans are not part of the project proposed at this hearing. The item at this hearing is a proposal to extend the existing daycare hours of operation and install playground equipment. _] The Hearing Officer clarified for the audience that the application being heard today was for the extension of an approved day care use (with a reduction in students) and the installation of a play structure. He thanked everyone for attending the meeting and voicing their questions and concerns. He thanked Staff for their hard work and research into the project. The let the Community Members know that their noise concerns, traffic safety and 'livability' are important to the City. He reiterated that the project before him today needed to be the focus of the approval. The proposed use is an allowed use for the space. He asked Staff member Serrano to explain the hearing date process. The State requires that a project of this kind be deemed complete and then needs to have a decision made within 60 days of that date. He said that the project was deemed complete on January 20 and so needed to have a determination by March 21. Additionally, there are required noticing requirements that. The Hearing Officer's decision could be appealed and would then be scheduled to be heard by the Planning Commission. An appeal would need to be filed in the Clerk's office within 14 days of the Hearing Officer's decision. The Hearing Officer said that he felt that the play structure is a fair distance from the neighboring houses. However, he wanted to have some additional noise monitoring. He added that condition of approval that there be additional noise monitoring of the play structure during its use to ensure that the decibel levels remain within the City's Noise Ordinance threshold. He also felt that the since the number of children being dropped off and 9 Administrative Hearing February 23,2017 picked up is reduced and staggered with a two hour time window, it would be appropriate to have a later start time to help with traffic in the area. He wanted to make sure the church did not have a queing issue with cars and that there is someone on-site (designated) to assist with traffic concerns. Staff is also available to receive complaints/concerns from the neighborhood. He encouraged the applicant to work with City Staff concerning the addition of another driveway in that the preliminary review of this idea indicates that this would help the traffic situation on Jollyman. This is a topic that the applicant would have to work with the Public Works Department to make sure an additional driveway would meet the City's traffic/engineering requirements. Several members of the audience interrupted the Hearing Officer. DECISION: The application was approved by the Hearing Officer per the draft resolutions with the following additions/modifications: 1) That there be additional noise monitoring of the play structure during its use to ensure that the decibel levels remain within the City's Noise Ordinance threshold 2) The start time for drop of students be at 8:00am, teachers and staff can arrive earlier 3) The be a designated on-site person to assist and monitor the drop off/pick up activities 4) Continue to work with the City's Public Works' Staff regarding the study of the feasibility and implementation of adding an additional driveway off of Stelling Road to reduce traffic on Jollyman Road ADJOURNMENT Respectfully submitted: 1` b jAj Beth Ebben Administrative Assistant g:planninglAH CommitteelMinutesO22317