HomeMy WebLinkAboutAH 12-08-2016 Cupertino, CA 95014
(408) 777-3308
APPROVED MINUTES OF THE REGULAR MEETING OF
THE ADMINISTRATIVE HEARING HELD ON December 8, 2016
ROLL CALL
Hearing Officer present: Benjamin Fu, Assist. Director of Community Development
Staff present: Ellen Yau, Assistant Planner
Applicant(s) present: Kevin Jung, homeowner
Raymond Chiu, property owner
Eiki Tanaka, Architect for Mr. Chiu
APPROVAL OF MINUTES:
1. Minutes of November 10, 2016
The minutes of November 10, 2016 were approved as written
POSTPONEMENTS/REMOVAL FROM CALENDAR:
None
ORAL COMMUNICATION:
None
WRITTEN COMMUNICATIONS:
An email was received regarding Item 3. The Hearing Officer would respond to the email
during the presentation of that item.
PUBLIC MEETING:
2. Application No.(s): ASA-2016-09
Applicant: Kevin and Aileen Jung/Nathaniel and Michelle Dunn
Location: 10658 and 10660 Hale Place APN#: 326-40-012
Architectural and Site Approval for a 766 square foot addition to an existing single story
duplex
Administrative Hearing decision final unless appealed.
2 Administrative Hearing
December 8,2016
Staff Member Yau explained that the application is being heard at this meeting due to its R-3
zoning designation. The property owner would like to add 388 square feet to each of the units.
The addition would increase the total square footage of the duplex to 4,003 square feet. The
existing height and building materials will be carried over into the new construction. The
addition is at the rear, so there will be no visual impact from the front and no privacy issues
since the addition is a single story.
The hearing Officer asked about the lot's setback requirements and how they are impacted if at
all by the increased square footage. Staff member Yau explained that the required side setback
is 6 feet and that the current homes are situated centrally on the lot. The side walls of the
addition will result in side yard setbacks more than 18' on both sides which exceeds the
minimum requirement.
The Hearing Officer opened the item for Public Comment:
Dr. Rahnemoon, a property owner of a duplex on the same street, asked about the Code
Section relating to the R-3 Zone. He stated that since the overall lot coverage with the addition
was far less than what has been determined to be the maximum in the Code, why a meeting
needed to be held. He felt that is was a waste of time and resources.
A City resident, Jennifer Griffin, asked for clarification of what the current yard size is for the
families and what it will be after the addition.
Staff member Yau explained that the Administration section of the Municipal Code requires
that any proposed changes to lots with zoning designations Planned Development, R-3 and R-
2, these proposed changes need to be approved with a hearing and not at Staff Level. Mr.
Kevin Jung, property owner, addressed the resident's comments regarding his yard space. He
told her that they were made aware of what the requirement was for yard space. He said that
they have ample space even with the addition for the children to play. The Hearing Officer
confirmed that from the rear wall of the new addition to the rear property line was 24' and that
the side setbacks were 24' by 24' on each side.
The Hearing Officer closed the Public Comment period.
The Hearing Officer concurred with Staff's findings that the new addition would not be
detrimental or impactful to the neighborhood in any way.
DECISION: The application was approved per the draft resolution
PUBLIC HEARING:
3. Application No.(s): TM-2016-01, R-2016-27, R-2016-30, TR-2016-27
Applicant: Raymond and Adeline Chiu
Location: 20030 Forest Avenue APN#: 316-23-107
Tentative Map application to allow a 0.47 single family lot to be subdivided into two lots of
11,099 and 9,776 square feet; Two-Story Permit to allow the construction of a 4,507 square foot
3 Administrative Hearing
December 8,2016
single family residence with an attached 475 square foot accessory dwelling unit; Two-Story
Permit to allow the construction of a 4,027 square foot single family residence with an attached
366 square foot accessory dwelling unit; Tree Removal Permit to allow the removal and
replacement of 3 protected trees to facilitate the construction of two new single family
residences on the newly subdivided lots.
Administrative Hearing decision final unless appealed.
Staff Member Yau gave a brief description of the areas surrounding the subject lot. She
explained that this lot is one of the largest properties in its neighborhood. The proposed
subdivision meets the General Plan requirement for Density thresholds. The lot access and lot
sizes were closely evaluated. The access to Lot B will be off of Toni Court and Lot A will use
roughly the same driveway access off of Forest (as is for the current structure). The applicant
submitted a complete packet showing the proposed footprints of the new houses even though
not required, so that a discussion could occur regarding access and street improvements. The
new home designs meet all the required aspects of the R-1 Ordinance including design, height
and setbacks. The property owner is required to meet State mandated landscaping design
guidelines for water efficiency. This landscape plan will be reviewed by Staff as part of the
building permit approval process. Three trees will be removed and replaced by 3, 36" box Oak
trees. The project has been reviewed by the Sanitary District, the Public Works and Building
Departments. Their comments have been incorporated into the resolution for TM-2016-01. The
Public Works department has requirements for the off-site improvements. Staff recommends
approval of the applications as they are in conformance with all applicable Codes and
Ordinances.
The Hearing Officer confirmed that there are no special exceptions requested and that the
project meets all of the Zoning requirements. He asked what the maximum allowed density
allowed is and what the proposal is asking for. Staff member Yau stated that the maximum
allowed lot coverage is 45% and the proposed lot coverage is at 44.8%, which is typical for new
home development in the City. The maximum height for a two-story residence is 28', the
prosed height for house A is 27' and house B is 26', 6". The Hearing Officer asked about the
proposed tree removals. Staff Member Yau said that there are 10 un-protected trees and 3
protected trees scheduled for removal. The 3 protected trees consist of a Buckeye and 2 Oaks.
They will be removed and replaced in accordance with the Tree Ordinance. The Property
Owner spoke about the trees. He said that the protected trees had been evaluated by an
arborist and needed to be removed as they fell into the construction envelopes. The
unprotected trees were mostly old fruit trees and that they, too are in the building envelope.
They will be able to save one (protected) tree in the rear and one (protected) tree on the side.
The Hearing Officer asked Staff member Yau to address the concerns raised in the Written
Communications email. The neighbor had issues regarding the construction hours and noise
impacts to the neighborhood. Staff member Yau said that the applicant has been made aware
4 Administrative Hearing
December 8,2016
of the City's Ordinances regarding construction and that they would be required to submit a
Construction Management Plan as part of their Building Permit application. This plan would
need to detail where construction vehicles will be parked and where construction materials
will be stored on site. The plan will be evaluated by the City's Building Official.
The Hearing Officer opened the item for Public Comment:
A neighbor, Tony White, addressed the Hearing Officer to speak with his concerns about the
setbacks on Forest Avenue. He lives across the street from the subject property.
A City resident, Jennifer Griffin, spoke about the traffic and construction impacts to the
children walking to and home from school. She also expressed a concern for the removal of the
22" Oak tree from the site. She felt that there was enough room on the site, that it was far
enough away from the construction that it could be saved. In her opinion, the tree was big
enough that it probably had to be planted there, so it should be kept.
The Hearing Officer closed the Public Comment period
The Hearing Officer asked the applicant of he had the setback information for Mr. White. He
said that the setback along Forest Avenue is 13'. He said he was trying to maximize the
southern exposure which is why he moved the house closer to that side of the lot. Mr. White
asked for clarification of the trees along the frontage. Mr. Chiu showed him the plan set and
explained tree locations and the house layout.
The Hearing Officer asked about the 22"tree. He asked if there was a way to move it or save it.
Staff member Yau said that there no records dictating that tree had to be planted there. It is
possible that in the past someone just planted it. The City has no regulations regarding the
planting of standalone trees. The concern with leaving the tree where it is, is that the Public
Works is requiring a detached sidewalk to continue the sidewalk off of Forest to Tony Court.
Since the tree is right along property line, the new sidewalk will be right at the root of the tree.
The City's arborist reviewed the tree and stated that it is co-dominant and may be suffering
from beetle bark disease. Staff looked at lots of potential options to see if re-working the
development was feasible so the tree could be retained. However, there is a possibility that the
5' Oak tree can be retained. The Hearing Officer encouraged the applicant to work with Staff to
see if that could be done. He also mentioned that the City's "Safe Walks to School" program
encourages the installation of sidewalks.
The Hearing Officer said that he wanted the applicant to work with Staff to see about retaining
the 5" Oak tree unless a new arborist report indicates a problem with health of the tree. Staff
member Yau pointed out an error in the Resolution for TM-2016-01 where the expiration
period states 24 months when it should say 36. The Hearing Officer concurred with Staffs
findings that the proposed applications meet all of the current Codes and Ordinances and the
project would not be an undue burden to the neighborhood. The required off-site
improvements would be an enhancement to the existing conditions.
DECISION: The applications were approved per the draft resolutions
5 Administrative Hearing
December 8,2016
ADJOURNMENT
Respectfully submitted:
&U.
Beth Ebben
Administrative Assistant
6 Administrative Hearing
December 8,2016
g:planning/AH CommitteelMinutes120816