HomeMy WebLinkAboutAH 11-10-2016 Cupertino, CA 95014
(408) 777-3308
APPROVED MINUTES OF THE REGULAR MEETING OF
THE ADMINISTRATIVE HEARING HELD ON November 10, 2016
ROLL CALL
Hearing Officer present: Benjamin Fu, Assist. Director of Community Development
Staff present: Gian Paolo Martire, Associate Planner
Applicant(s) present: Sal Caruso, representative for Legionnaires of Christ
Jeff Oparowski, representative for 19900 Stevens Creek Blvd, LLC
APPROVAL OF MINUTES:
1. Minutes of October 13, 2016
The minutes of October 13, 2016 were approved as written
POSTPONEMENTS/REMOVAL FROM CALENDAR:
None
ORAL COMMUNICATION:
None
WRITTEN COMMUNICATIONS:
None
PUBLIC MEETING:
2. Application No.(s): ASA-2016-08, TR-2016-43
Applicant: Salvatore Caruso (Ramona Blvd, Inc.)
Location: 22840 Mercedes Rd (Legionnaires of Christ) APN#s: 342-22-109
Architectural and Site Approval for retrofit of an existing retaining wall at the parking lot and
stairs to the lower level, and new concrete decks. Tree Removal Permit to allow the removal
and replacement of one (1) protected tree
Administrative Hearing decision final unless appealed.
2 Administrative Hearing
November 10,2016
Staff Member Martire explained how the applicant is proposing minor parking lot
enhancements to bring the parking lot up to current parking and seismic standards. They will
also be extending an existing wooden deck out about 5 feet and adding stairs. The
improvements will require some site grading the removal of 19 trees. One of the trees is a
protected Coast Live Oak. The applicant has proposed to replace the 19 trees one-for-one and
will preplace the protected tree two-for one. The Hearing Officer asked the applicant about
the grading. The applicant explained that their geologist has determined that the existing dirt
fill on site should be replaced and compacted to provide appropriate shoring for the parking
lot on the hillside above it.
The Hearing Officer opened the item for Public Comment:
A resident spoke about the original approval of this site. She was glad that the old fill was
being replaced as this is a very steep hillside.
The Hearing Officer closed the Public Comment period.
He thanked the applicant for taking the voluntary, necessary steps to improve the site and to
correct the hillside deficiencies to help prevent a slide.
DECISION: The application was approved per the draft resolutions
2. Application No.(s): ASA-2016-13, TR-2016-35
Applicant: Jeff Oparowski (19900 Stevens Creek Blvd, LLC.)
Location: 19900 Stevens Creek Blvd APN#s: 369-05-038
Architectural and Site approval for parking lot modifications to improve landscaping and
increase the parking count to conform to retail standards; Tree Removal Permit to allow the
removal and replacement of 21 development trees in conjunction with the parking lot and site
upgrades at an existing retail location (Scandinavian Designs).
Administrative Hearing decision final unless appealed.
Staff Member Martire explained that the project site has been operating with a deficient
number of parking spaces for a very long time. The applicant is proposing to add 30 spaces to
bring the parking lot into conformance. The trees to be removed on site have been evaluated
by the City's consulting arborist. He concurs that the trees are not the best type for parking lot
shade uses. The trees will be replaced with 27 trees of various sizes (above the Ordinance
requirement) and with water efficient plantings. The other City departments have reviewed
the application and have made recommendations which have been incorporated into the Draft
Resolution. Staff member Martire said that the Planning Department is recommending that the
applicant install a landscape island along the southern most parking isle to allow for 10
3 Administrative Hearing
November 10,2016
parking spaces on each side. This will break up the mass of the parking and add shade to those
spaces.
The Hearing Officer asked why the prior Use Permits allowed a parking deficiency. Staff
member Martire said that the retail site is deed restricted to retail furniture uses only and at
the time of this decision (1984-1985), the City felt that retail furniture uses generally don't
generate a lot of parking demand. The Hearing Officer asked if the new space count would be
in conformance with other retail uses should the retail use change in the future. He stated that
it would. The Hearing Officer asked what size the trees are that are proposed for removal. He
said that they range in size from 10" to 26" in diameter.
The Hearing Officer opened the item for Public Comment:
A resident commented on the project. She asked about the street trees along Stevens Creek
Boulevard and the trees along both sides. The applicant, Jeff Oparowski, said that the street
trees would not be removed. He said the 6 or 7 Redwood trees on the western side would also
be retained as is. Some trees along the eastern side will be removed, but will be replaced. The
resident asked if the HOA had been notified about the tree removals as they might be sensitive
about that. Staff explained that the proper notices did go out and that site signage regarding
the proposed development had been in place for nearly three weeks. No comments have been
received.
The Hearing Officer closed the Public Comment period.
The Hearing Officer said that he liked the project and thanked the applicant for replacing the
trees above the requirement of the Tree Ordinance. He felt that bringing the parking count up
to current standards was a good idea to be able to better accommodate current and future
retail uses on the site.
DECISION: The application was approved per the draft resolutions
ADJOURNMENT
Respectfully submitted:
19
Beth Ebben
Administrative Assistant
gplanning/AH Committee/Minutes111016