HomeMy WebLinkAboutAH 07-14-2016 Cupertino, CA 95014
(408) 777-3308
APPROVED MINUTES OF THE REGULAR MEETING OF
THE ADMINISTRATIVE HEARING HELD ON July 14,2016
ROLL CALL
Hearing Officer present: Benjamin Fu, Assist. Director of Community Development
Staff present: Erick Serrano, Associate Planner
Sarah Filipe, Planning Intern
Ellen Yau, Assistant Planner
Applicant(s) present: Seyavash Zohoori, agent for Starbucks
Gianni Chiloiro, agent for Doppio Zero Pizzeria
Aditi Mukherjee, agent for DV Alhambra Ave, LLC
APPROVAL OF MINUTES:
1. Minutes of June 9, 2016
The minutes of June 9, 2016 were approved as written
POSTPONEMENTS/REMOVAL FROM CALENDAR:
None
ORAL COMMUNICATION:
None
WRITTEN COMMUNICATIONS:
An email was received from a neighbor regarding item #4.
PUBLIC MEETING:
2. Application No.(s): ASA-2016-03
Applicant: Diane Hanamoto(Mardesich Company/Crossroads Shopping Center)
Location: 20520 Stevens Creek Boulevard APN#s: 359-08-018
Architectural and Site approval to allow exterior facade improvements, improvements of an
existing outdoor seating area, and new trash enclosure at a coffee shop (Starbucks)
Continued from the June 9, 2016 meeting
2 Administrative Hearing
July 14,2016
Administrative Hearing decision final unless appealed.
Staff Member Serrano stated that he had provided the applicant with the questions that the
Hearing Officer had from the last meeting. The applicant has provided answers and was in
attendance today to provide further clarifications.
The White Oak facade material would be treated with two coats of sealant which will protect it
from the weather elements. The facade will be installed similar to a rain screen, so there will be
no pooling of rainwater to cause discoloration of the facade. The siding will run along the
northeast corner beginning at the east elevation storefront window and continue to the second
storefront window on the north elevation. The only changes to the exterior materials of the
building will be addition of the facade. The existing building materials (stucco, finish and
paint) will remain. The trash enclosure shown on the plans is not existing, but new with this
project. The balustrades surrounding the seating area will be 3', 6" and will be painted black
other railing will be treated wood to match the facade. The Hearing Officer asked the applicant
what the maintenance plans are for keeping the new construction up kept and in good repair.
The applicant explained that there is a corporate facilities team whose job is to keep all the
exteriors and interiors of the Starbucks locations in good repair. The business owners are
responsible for their stores.
The Hearing Officer opened the item for Public Comment. There were no speakers, so the
Public Comment period was closed.
The Hearing Officer thanked the applicant for responding to the questions. He did suggest
that the applicant consider the installation of a visual feature of some kind in the front (solid
wooden) door to help with safety in carrying hot beverages through it. He asked that the
applicant work with Staff to come up with a resolution.
The Hearing Officer asked to include a condition in the resolution to clarify that the business
owner was responsible for the proper maintenance and repair of the store's exterior
treatments; and that the applicant would work with Staff for minor design refinements.
DECISION: The application was approved per the draft resolution with the above mentioned
additional language
3. Application No.(s): ASA-2016-04
Applicant: Gianni Chiloiro(Doppio Zero Pizzeria)
Location: 10088 N Wolfe Rd #120 APN#: 316-20-108
Architectural and Site review to allow for a new.patio at a proposed new restaurant (Doppio
Zero Pizzeria) in a mixed use development project (Nineteen800)
Administrative Hearing decision final unless appealed.
3 Administrative Hearing
July 14,2016
Staff Member Filipe explained that the restaurant received an approval from the Planning
Commission in February for a separate bar use. The application today was for an outdoor
patio seating area. The additional seating does not change the parking requirements for the
site. The project was reviewed by other city departments and supporting agencies and noticed
to the public for comments and concerns. No comments were received. Staff supports the
application and recommends approval per the draft resolution.
The Hearing Officer asked for clarification that the five foot clearance between the seating and
the fence met the Building Code's accessibility requirements. Staff member Filipe stated that it
does.
The Hearing Officer opened the item for Public Comment. There were no speakers, so the
Public Comment period was closed.
The Hearing Officer supported the project and thanked the applicant for the additional
outdoor seating and well thought site design
DECISION: The application was approved per the draft resolution
4. Application No.(s): ASA-2016-01
Applicant: Aditi Mukherjee (Murali Narasimhan/DV Alhambra Ave,LLC)
Location: 10131 Alhambra Ave APN#: 326-23-027
r t@Ft ral�n�Sltp, roi imy to al19w for the consttiction of a 7 5iR1 Square f98t, two story
single family residence with a front facing second story balcony located in a Planned
Development Zone (PRes).
Administrative Hearing decision final unless appealed.
Staff Member Yau explained that since the proposed development is in a Planned
Development Zone, the approval requirement is at an Administrative Hearing. The lot has a
unique shape and as such are requesting reduced setbacks and parking from the standard R1
requirements. In exchange, they are proposing a new home design featuring craftsman details.
The majority of the setback encroachment is the second floor stairway and the 20x20 garage off
the first floor. The landscape plan as submitted is not consistent with the existing fencing
heights and materials and the design of the home. A condition of approval has been included
in the draft resolution to ensure conformity prior to issuance of the building permit. While the
proposed residence is not in the R1 Zone, these guidelines were used to determine floor area
allowances and the need for privacy planting along the northern setback due to the second
story balcony. The proposed driveway is shallower than the R1 regulation, so a condition has
been added to the resolution for on-street parking. The proposed home is harmonious in
design and scale with the neighborhood and staff recommends approval of the application.
4 Administrative Hearing
July 14,2016
The Hearing officer asked about the existing driveway curb cut. The project architect stated
that the existing curb cut would be filled and a new one created.
The Hearing Officer opened the item for Public Comment. There were no speakers, but Staff
member Yau reviewed the email received. A neighbor is concerned about the on-street
parking. They are concerned that the orientation of the home will increase parking on Empire
Avenue. The Hearing Officer stated that the existing curb cut is already on Empire, and the
new cut will also be on Empire, so there would no additional parking impact.
The Public Comment period was closed.
The Hearing Officer agreed that the reduced rear yard setback would not impact the
neighborhood. He made sure that the applicant knew that they could be cited for a vehicle
code violation if they parked a long car in the shallow driveway. He felt that the plan
adequately addressed the unique challenges of the shape of the lot. He liked that the
landscaping on the corner would be preserved and that the landscaping overall was an
enhancement to the site.
DECISION:The application was approved per the draft resolution
ADJOURNMENT
Respectfully submitted:
4w6� gb�
Beth Ebben
Administrative Assistant
gplanning/AH Committee/Minutes071416