HomeMy WebLinkAboutAH 11-12-2015 Cupertino, CA 95014
(408) 777-3308
APPROVED MINUTES OF THE REGULAR MEETING OF
THE ADMINISTRATIVE HEARING HELD ON November 12, 2015
ROLL CALL
Hearing Officer present: Piu Ghosh, Senior Planner
Staff present: Gian Martire, Assistant Planner
Applicant(s) present: Jackson Derler (HMH Architects), Agent for the Property
Owner
APPROVAL OF MINUTES:
None
POSTPONEMENTS/REMOVAL FROM CALENDAR:
None
ORAL COMMUNICATION:
None
WRITTEN COMMUNICATIONS:
None
PUBLIC MEETING:
1. Application No.(s): ASA-2015-19, TR-2015-40
Applicant: Bob Farman (I&G Direct Real Estate)
Location: 10050 N Wolfe Rd APN#316-20-086
Architectural and Site approval to allow landscape and site improvements to the
common area of an office building;
Tree Removal Permit to allow the removal and replacement of 21 protected trees to
facilitate landscape improvements in the common area of an office building
Administrative Hearing decision final unless appealed.
2 Administrative Hearing
November 12,2015
Staff Member Martire explained that the applicant, the Cupertino Financial Center, would like
to make some much needed updates to the common areas of the center. In the courtyard of the
center, they are proposing architectural changes that include the addition of two large seating
areas comprised of wooden decks with planters, the fountain will be replaced with a smaller
water feature and a 1,000 square foot trellis-type structure with a built in multi-media feature
to be used by employees and guests of the center. There 3,700 square feet of landscaping will
be revamped for the installation of drought and water efficient plants and trees. At the front of
the building, the applicant is proposing to replace 6,875 square feet of landscaping along the
corner of the building where the art structure is currently located. The lawn area will be
replaced with drought tolerant and native plantings. The Tree Removal Permit is to allow the
removal of 21 ornamental trees in the courtyard area. They are not typically protected trees,
but as they were installed as part of an approved landscape plan, they are considered
protected. The trees proposed to be removed are 13 Honey Locust trees and 8 Kwanzan
Cherry trees, all are small, ranging in size from 2.2 inches to 11 inches in diameter. The
applicant has proposed 18 replacement trees consisting of 36 inch box fruitless olives trees. The
Tree Ordinance requires replacements at a 2 to 1 ratio with 24" box trees. The applicant is
replanting larger size trees than are required (which will count towards 15 replacement trees)
and will be paying an in-lieu replacement fee for the remaining 3 trees. The draft resolution,
condition 5, leaves room to approve the proposed tree replacement plan or require the
applicant to replant the 3 remaining trees.
The Hearing Officer asked if the parking podium was below ground or at grade. The
applicant's architect replied that it was at grade. He went on to explain that the courtyard
redesign was undertaken to keep the existing tenants happy and give the employees more
flexibility with their work environment. The existing trees on site are mostly along the
perimeter, so don't provide shaded areas in which to sit. Currently there is a lot of concrete so
walking between the buildings is like walking in a parking lot. The applicant wants to bring in
the larger trees and landscaping along with the seating features to create a more park-like
setting.
The Hearing Officer asked Staff member Martire about the public comments that had been
received. He stated that the comments were by phone and that he had not received anything in
writing. One person who commented was in attendance at the meeting.
The Hearing Officer opened the public hearing to the resident in attendance. The resident,
Jennifer Griffin, said that her initial concern about the removal of the Ash trees along the
perimeter was in error. She walked the site and agrees that the courtyard area is in need of
upgrading. She did have a concern about the grass being removed along the sidewalk by the
inner row of Ash trees and in front of the building as people sit on the grass and wait for the
bus and the corner has historically been viewed by the public as a park. She wanted this item
continued for further evaluation.
The Hearing Officer closed the public hearing.
3 Administrative Hearing
November 12,2015
She then asked the applicant for clarification about where exactly the grass was proposed to be
removed. The applicant reviewed the site plan. The grass and ivy along the front (in a small
strip) and back to the bridge and the flowers near and around the art feature will be replanted.
The grass in the park strip will remain. It was pointed out that the area is not all grass
currently and people are cutting through the grass and flower beds to pick up the sidewalk on
the other side. This is creating a maintenance issue for the property owners. The applicant has
designed an extension of the sidewalk to alleviate that problem. Along the north side, the grass
in the front park strip is staying. The uphill area for about 60 feet will be replanted. The
existing planters near the wall will be replanted with native and drought tolerant plants. He
explained that the new irrigation methods will better water the existing perimeter trees
ensuring that they remain healthy. The arborist's report states that the trees in the courtyard
are in decline due to where they are planted and/or because they are in planter boxes. The
landscaping for the corner near the bridge will be native evergreen and deciduous grasses.
The Hearing Officer asked if the applicant would consider keeping some of the grass along the
frontage and add some plants around the public art feature to add some color. He said he was
open to the ideas and would ask the property owners if they would also be willing to revise
the landscaping plan. The Hearing Officer also asked that they clarify on the plans the minor
sidewalk extension.
DECISION: The application was approved by the Hearing Officer per the draft resolution with
the following additions/modifications:
The turf area at the corner of N. Wolfe Road and Stevens Creek Boulevard shall be maintained
in a width at least to match the width of the park strip. The area in front of the public art shall
have native and/or drought tolerant plant additions that will add color; Condition 5 should be
revised for the tree replacements to replace as many trees as possible as confirmed by the
City's Arborist.
The indemnification clauses need to be updated with the current language.
ADJOURNMENT
Respectfully submitted:
A",
hAJ41"
Beth Ebben
Administrative Clerk
g:planning/AH Committee/Minutes111215