HomeMy WebLinkAboutAH 09-24-2015 Cupertino, CA 95014
(408) 777-3308
APPROVED MINUTES OF THE REGULAR MEETING OF
THE ADMINISTRATIVE HEARING HELD ON September 24, 2015
ROLL CALL
Hearing Officer present: Gary Chao, Assist. Director of Community Development
Staff present: Erick Serrano, Assistant Planner
Applicant(s) present: Lexi Moriarty (Sand Hill), Property Owner
Mike Rohde (Sand Hill), Property Owner
Cliff Chang, the Project Architect
John--, Target Express representative
APPROVAL OF MINUTES:
Minutes of August 13, 2015
The minutes of August 13, 2015 were approved as written
Minutes of August 27, 2015
The minutes of August 27, 2015 were approved as written
POSTPONEMENTS/REMOVAL FROM CALENDAR:
None
ORAL COMMUNICATION:
A resident, Jennifer Griffin, commented on the enormous amount of construction happening
in her area of the City. She wanted to know when the infrastructure of the City would be being
"put back together" in terms of road closures, median repairs and sidewalks so that the area
would begin to feel normal again. She said the residents have been patient with the upgrades
for long enough.
WRITTEN COMMUNICATIONS:
Emails have been received regarding the public meeting item
PUBLIC MEETING:
i
2 Administrative Hearing
September 24,2015
1. Application No.(s): ASA-2015-23
Applicant: Dean Isaacs(Main Street Cupertino, LLC)
Location: 19499 Stevens Creek Blvd
Architectural and Site approval for final refinements to the previously approved Architectural
and Site application (ASA-2014-11) for the Major Retail building and patio at Main Street
Cupertino
Administrative Hearing decision final unless appealed.
Staff Member Serrano explained that the Main Street Cupertino mixed use development was
approved by the City Council and is currently under construction. As tenants of the new retail
locations come on board, they are applying to the City for Architectural and Site approvals to
"customize" their locations for their specific business/customer needs. The application today
does not change or modify any of the uses previously approved for the site, does not change
the square footage or parking count of the site. This application is to make changes to the
Major Retail building such as the relocation of the entry doors at the southwest corner and
northwest corners, the removal and replacement and color changes of the canopies over the
entries and exits. The patio along Stevens Creek Boulevard will be modified to allow grade
level entries, buffering of the outdoor seating, accessibility enhancement features and
landscaping changes to provide better pedestrian access. Staff recommended that that
application be approved per the draft resolution.
The Hearing Officer asked the applicants if they had any comments to add to the Staff report.
Mike Rohde, spoke to on behalf of the tenant, Target Stores. They like the proposed changes to
the entries as it will help 'activate' the streetscape and make for a better shopping experience.
The Hearing Officer opened the Public Hearing:
Kathy Sander, Stern Ave.; Asked about the signage. She mentioned that the proposed patio
was similar to the one at Panera Bread. She thought that the street is too busy and too noisy to
have the outdoor patio seating be located on Stevens Creek Boulevard. She also had concerns
about the path of travel the trucks would be using to unload goods for the store. It was
explained to her that the signage would be addressed as a separate application for the entire
Main Street site in a Master Sign Program.
Jennifer Griffin, Calvert Ave.; Asked what the square footage of the Major Retail building and
asked about the loading bays and paths of travel of the commercial trucks. She didn't
understand the need for a patio outside of a retail store. She also wanted to know about the
use of cart corrals.
Lisa Warren, a resident; She stated that she was unhappy that Sandhill Properties agreed to
have Target Express as a tenant. She didn't feel that they were the kind of retail establishment
the developer had promised for the site. She wanted to make sure that the glass for the store
front obscured what the store looked like on the inside. She thought that with the other fast
food places in the area, the visual (with clear glass) as someone walked along Stevens Creek
3 Administrative Hearing
September 24,2015
Boulevard, would be terrible. She also asked for clarification about the proposed color
changes.
The Hearing Officer closed the Public Hearing.
The project architect, Cliff Chang, addressed the Hearing Officer. He went over the general
scope of the tenant improvements. On one corner, Starbucks will open onto an open, stepped
patio, so some seating will be at grade level and some will be below. As required by the
Building Code, there will be a physical barrier between Stevens Creek and the patio.
Landscaping will be installed to help soften the look of the barrier and the sidewalk and act as
a buffer in other areas. The approved colors and materials being used on the exterior of the
building have not changed. The entries and entry features to the building have been shifted
some to provide functionality for the tenant.
The Hearing Officer asked the Target Express representative if there would be shopping cart
corrals in the parking lot. He replied that there would not be any as the small carts used inside
the store are designed to not be able to leave the store. The Hearing Officer addressed the
concern about the truck loading bays. He explained that the site has a Master Use Permit and
the truck traffic patterns and bay widths are not changing. The size of the trucks, delivery
hours and noise were all studied and the conditions of approval were written to provide
restrictions. The Target Express representative stated that the store location at this site would
not be serviced by the large 18-wheel type trucks. He said, smaller ones, larger than box trucks,
but smaller than the large commercial trucks, are all that is necessary.
The Hearing Officer addressed the members of the audience regarding having a patio next to
Stevens Creek Boulevard. He said that the patio at Panera is an example of a working patio.
The materials and finishes proposed by Target Express were specifically chosen to soften the
look and provide screening for the utility equipment there in order to make their patio area
inviting. He hopes it succeeds and that patio becomes a place where people will want to hang
out. He reminded the audience that the square footage of the building was not changing, that
the truck routes and trash receptacles were governed by the conditions of the master Use
Permit. The Building Code has requirements for the number of restrooms in a building and for
accessibility. Those items are addressed during the plan review prior to issuance of the Tenant
Improvement Building Permit. A Master Sign Program is currently under review by the
project planner, Tiffany Brown. The sign program is approved in the Planning Department
and does not have to go to a hearing. Staff member Brown will make sure that the Sign
Program conforms to the City's Sign Ordinance before approval. Photometric plans will also
be submitted to the City for Staff approval of the site lighting prior to the issuance of the
building permit. Staff member Brown has the plans, but has not approved them as yet. The
Hearing Officer spoke about the transparency of glass along the store frontage on Stevens
Creek Boulevard. He said that the City's preference is to have clear glass so that people can see
inside and be engaged with the business rather than having clouded or spandrel glass. That, in
essence, serves a similar visual as a wall. Members of the audience interrupted the Hearing
Officer to voice concerns about the glass. They cited other instances of stores that do not have
4 Administrative Hearing
September 24,2015
any glass in front, including the larger Target store further down on Stevens Creek. The
Applicant addressed the audience to state that the part of the store that would be visible from
the sidewalk would be the sales area and would be attractive to the passersby.
The Hearing Officer concluded the discussion by concurring that the application was in
conformance with the City's Municipal and Building Codes. The store will be a welcome
addition to the new retail center.
DECISION: The application was approved by the Hearing Officer per the draft resolution with
the following additions/modifications:
Prior to granting final occupancy of the building, the style and design of the patio furniture
needs approval; A Director's approval would need to be obtained if the store decided that a
change needed to be made (in the future) to allow shopping carts outside and into the parking
lot; The colors of the metal features are to be a matte finish; Prior to issuance of the building
permit, the applicant shall work with the City to ensure that the street level view of the store
would be "desirable" and not cause lighting or glare issues to the pedestrians or motor
vehicles going past.
ADJOURNMENT
Respectfully submitted:
Beth Ebben
Administrative Clerk
g:planning/AH CommitteelMinutes092415