HomeMy WebLinkAboutAH 07-09-2015 Cupertino, CA 95014
(408) 777-3308
APPROVED MINUTES OF THE REGULAR MEETING OF
THE ADMINISTRATIVE HEARING HELD ON July 9, 2015
ROLL CALL
Hearing Officer present: Aarti Shrivastava, Director of Community Development
Staff present: Piu Ghosh, Senior Planner
Applicant(s) present: Bernard Baker, Project Manager, Apple Inc.
APPROVAL OF MINUTES:
1. June 25, 2015
The minutes of June 25, 2015 were approved as written
POSTPONEMENTS/REMOVAL FROM CALENDAR:
None
ORAL COMMUNICATION:
None
WRITTEN COMMUNICATIONS:
Three emails were received by Staff regarding the item on the agenda: One pertained to
screening of the proposed roof deck; one spoke to the degradation of the neighborhood due to
the Apple Campus expansion; one spoke about privacy concerns with the visitor center being
so close to the residences
PUBLIC MEETING:
2. Application No.(s): ASA-2015-15
Applicant: Bernard Baker (Apple, Inc.)
Location: 10700 N Tantau Ave
Architectural and Site application to review a parking structure and visitor reception
area as part of a previously approved office research and development campus
Administrative Hearing decision final unless appealed.
2 Administrative Hearing
July 9,2015
Staff Member Ghosh explained that the applicant is proposing to finalize the architectural
design of the structures located in the northeastern corner (Tantau and Pruneridge) of the
Apple Campus 2 construction site. The applicant had previously envisioned 2 story structures
on this site. However, with the final design, the size of the reception building, including a cafe,
reception area and small retail sales has reduced from 22,500 sq. ft. to 12,500 sq. ft. and the
office component has been eliminated. A previously envisioned above ground 2-story parking
garage has now been moved below grade with 684 parking spaces. There will be 116 surface
parking spaces. With this design change, the number of parking spaces approved for Phase 1,
have been exceeded by 12. Staff is recommending that these spaces be mitigated with the use
of future cross access easements covenants with the property owner to the north. However,
this is only a reduction of 4 spaces. The other 8 spaces can be eliminated with modification of
plans prior to issuance of building permits. The previous application called for an observation
area on the second story of the building, but as this modification reduces the building to a
single story, the applicant will be creating a rooftop deck. The deck will have appropriate
screening for the neighbors along the eastern side. The City of Cupertino has an agreement
with the City of Santa Clara that limits building heights in this area to 16' within 150 feet of the
shared property line. The height of the elevator lobbies shown on the plans will need to be
reduced to accommodate this requirement. The scope of the project changes were evaluated by
the environmental consultant. They deemed the changes to be insignificant, which the scope of
the previously prepared EIR, no new impacts have been identified and therefore, no changes
are necessary to the Final EIR.
The Hearing Officer asked for clarification of the traffic flow to the parking areas. It was
clarified that the project has been designed to direct cars to enter the site off of Tantau Avenue
to get to the parking garage and valet area and then will exit back onto Tantau Avenue.
The Hearing Officer asked if the proposed changes were consistent with what had originally
been approved by the City Council. Staff member Ghosh said that the applicant is still in
conformance with the approved program.
The Hearing Officer opened the meeting for Public Comments:
Pat Robbins, Pruneridge Ave, voiced concerns about how Apple plans to manage tourists
coming to the site. He spoke of privacy concerns from people on the roof deck. He doesn't feel
there is adequate screening. He also doesn t like the location of auto exhaust vents. The
concern here is that after an event is over, everyone will starting their cars and exhaust will be
blown all over the neighborhood.
Rob Wagner, Pruneridge Ave. Santa Clara, asked about privacy for the residences on the south
side of Pruneridge.
3 Administrative Hearing
July 9,2015
Nancy Wagner, Pruneridge Ave. Santa Clara, also voiced concerns about tourists and
additional traffic coming into the area. She said she has already had a very large tour bus park
in front of her house as she lives directly across from the construction site.
Tom Blasick (sp), Hancock Dr, Santa Clara, stated that his major concern is the increased traffic
on Pruneridge. He asked if a traffic study was available.
The Hearing Officer closed the Public Comment period.
The Hearing Officer clarified for the audience that the discussion for today was the scope of
the item on the agenda. She needed to make sure that the proposed modifications being
requested still met all the rules and stayed within the confines of the original approval made
by the City Council. Some of the comments were outside the scope of the project being heard
and so she could not speak directly about some of the concerns raised.
The Hearing Officer reiterated that with the proposed applications, the project scope has been
reduced. The building footprint has been reduced from 22,500 to 12,500. Offices and retail uses
have been reduced or eliminated. On the original approval the maximum building height
allowed was 35' and 16'. The current building proposal is 23' with elevator shafts extending
another 12'. The elevator lobbies located in the parking plaza (within 150' from the shared
property line) are 18'6" in height. The elevator shafts will be reduced to 16' in accordance with
the agreement made for buildings in this area of the project site. The originally approved 2
story parking garage has been removed and replaced with underground and surface parking.
The Hearing Officer asked for clarification about the exhaust vents. Staff member Ghosh stated
that the environmental review did not indicate that the proposed vents created any significant
environmental impacts. The Hearing Officer stated that in regards to the traffic concerns, the
reduction in building size usually translates to a reduction in traffic. She directed further traffic
concerns be addressed to the project planner for additional assistance. She stated that the City
was here to help the residents and would partner with them to resolve issues and concerns
about the construction noise, dust, traffic, etc. with Apple.
In respect to the concerns mentioned about tourists, the representative from Apple said that
the visitor's center will only be open during from 7am to 7pm as indicated in the originally
approved plans. There are no plans to change those hours. Special events at the corporate
auditorium will be monitored and managed.
There was a brief discussion about the design of the roof deck to clarify in which direction
someone using the space would be able to see.
The Hearing Officer asked the representative from Apple to continue to work with the
neighbors.
4 Administrative Hearing
July 9,2015
DECISION: The application was approved by the Hearing Officer per the draft resolution with
the following additions/modifications:
Screening at the back of the roof top deck would be reviewed and approved by Staff;
photometric study would be reviewed to make sure that there is no offsite glare/light onto the
neighbors; approve the parking stall count to a maximum of 788, for a total of 9240 for Phase 1.
The changes will be reviewed and approved before issuance of the building permits.
ADJOURNMENT
Respectfully submitted:
Beth Ebben
Administrative Clerk
g:planning/AH CommitteelMinutes070915