HomeMy WebLinkAboutAH 01-09-2020 Cupertino, CA 95014
(408) 777-3308
APPROVED MINUTES OF THE REGULAR MEETING OF
THE ADMINISTRATIVE HEARING HELD ON January 9, 2020
ROLL CALL
Hearing Officer present: Albert Salvador, Assistant Director of Community Development
Staff present: Ellen Yau, Associate Planner
Applicant(s) present: Nathan Ung, 19900 Stevens Creek Blvd, LLC
Scott Stotler, Dutchins Development, LLC
APPROVAL OF MINUTES:
1. August 22, 2019
The minutes of August 22, 2019 were approved as written
POSTPONEMENTS/REMOVAL FROM CALENDAR:
None
ORAL COMMUNICATIONS:
None
WRITTEN COMMUNICATIONS:
None
PUBLIC MEETING ITEMS:
2. Application No.(s): DP-2019-001,ASA-2019-006,TR-2019-032
Applicant: Nathan Ng(19900 Stevens Creek Blvd,LLC)
Location: 19900 Stevens Creek Blvd APN# 369-05-038
Development Permit to allow the construction of 2,235 square feet of new commercial use space to an
existing retail building (Scandinavian Design);an Architectural and Site Approval to allow facade,
parking, landscaping and site improvements; and a Tree Removal Permit to allow the removal and
replacement of twenty-five(25) development trees.
i
Administrative Hearing Officer's decision final unless appealed.
1
Staff member Yau addressed the Hearing Officer. She explained that the property owners are
proposing to remodel the former Scandinavian Design furniture store. They will be enclosing
two walkways, making facade changes, creating an interior courtyard, and re-designing the
building to allow for multiple tenant spaces. They have worked with Staff to meet the I
landscape easement requirements for the Heart of the City Plan. There will be 114 parking
2 Administrative Hearing
January 9,2020
spaces where 112 are required. There will also be a bicycle parking area. The applicants are
voluntarily participating in the City's Public Art program by having a mural painted on the
northwestern corner of the building. Other City Department Staff have reviewed the proposed
project and have no concerns. The applicant, Nathan Ung, addressed the Hearing Officer. He
feels that due to the location of the building, large store retail is not the best use for this space.
The traffic flow is not convenient for customers as there is no left-hand turn entrance. The
smaller retail, service based (insurance sales, real estate agency, etc.) shops are a better fit for
this site. These types of business are quiet and usually do not have a lot of customers in at one
time. The architectural upgrades and other site improvements should make the building much
more inviting for future tenants.
The Hearing Officer opened the public comment period.
Alan Roth
King Wah and Wei Wei
The Hearing Officer closed the comment period.
The Hearing Officer asked for clarification that the proposed project meets the parking
requirements and that the proposed service retail uses are permitted for the site. Staff member
Yau confirmed. He asked if the existing landscaping was going to be removed to
accommodate the parking. She said that a small area was going to be removed, but it was far
away from the frontage so was not in conflict with the Heart of the City landscaping
requirements. The Hearing officer asked about the number of accessible and EV parking
spaces. The applicant stated that they are in compliance with the number of accessible spaces
required and have planned to add two EV spaces in the future. He also stated that tenants
coming into the site will not be grocery, entertainment or restaurant as the site does not meet
the parking requirements for those types of uses. A new trash enclosure will be installed on
site.
The Hearing officer concurred with Staff's findings. Since the building envelope was not
changing, the uses of the site are in conformance and the overall design will be an
improvement, the application was approved. He informed the applicant that if the uses of the
building were to change to conditional uses in the future, a new hearing would be required.
DECISION: The applications were approved by the Hearing Officer per the draft resolution(s).
3. Application No.(s): ASA-2019-005
Applicant: Scott Stotler(Dutchints Development,LLC)
Location: 10100 Bubb Rd APN#357-20-024
Architectural and Site Approval Permit to allow for architectural and site improvements to an existing
13,250 square foot industrial building.
Administrative Hearing Officer's decision final unless appealed.
Staff member Yau addressed the Hearing Officer. She explained that the property most
recently has been used for a repair shop. The current owner would like to use the space for a
real estate development firm. The site is located in a Light Industrial Zone, so this is a
3 Administrative Hearing
January 9,2020
permitted use. The application will slightly reduce the building shell by approximately 400
square feet to create a courtyard entrance. The building will undergo architectural changes
that will reduce the look of the mass and scale through a new roof design and glass storefront
elements where entrances used to be. A new sidewalk will be installed along the front and the
parking lot will be re-striped to provide 47 spaces. None of the trees on site will be removed as
part of these upgrades. A variety of new trees and shrubs will be planted as is required by the
City's Municipal Code. The proposed project has been reviewed by other City departments.
They had no concerns about the proposed changes to the site. The applicant, Scott Stotler, said
he was available to answer any questions. His team has worked with Staff to create a new
fagade to this building that he hopes will inspire the adjacent property owners and other
others in the area to want to make changes to their spaces too. The Hearing Officer clarified
that the space will just have one tenant in it. The applicant said that they have no plans to
subdivide the space to house multiple tenants. The Hearing Officer reminded the applicant
about the requirements for accessible parking spaces and asked for clarification regarding the
'path of travel' from the parking lot to the building entrances. The Hearing Officer said the
applicant will need to work on these issues with the Building Department during the building
permit issuance process.
The Hearing Officer opened the public comment period.
There were no speakers.
The Hearing Officer closed the comment period.
The Hearing Officer reviewed the presentation from Staff and the Applicants. He concurred
that the project is in conformance with the City's Municipal Code and that the proposed
building upgrades will not be detrimental to the surrounding businesses.
DECISION: The applications were approved by the Hearing Officer per the draft resolution(s).
ADJOURNMENT
Respectfully submitted:
Beth Ebben
Deputy Board Clerk
I