TR-2015-61b DEPARTMENT OF COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT
,;,
CIT'Y HALL
10300 TORRE AVENUE • CUPERTINO,CA 95014-3255
C U P E RT 11�I C3 (408)777-3308 • FAX(408)777-3333 •planning@cupertino.org
October 28, 2015
Meg Thomas
Apple,Inc.
1 Infinite Loop,MS 21-1AC2
Cupertino, CA 95014
SUBJECT: TREE REMOVAL PERMIT ACTION LETTER—Application TR-2015-61
This letter confirms the decision of the Director of Community Development, given on October 27, 2015
approvi_ng a Tree Removal Permit to allow the removal and replacement of 2 dead Pinus radiata trees at
an office,research, and development campus,located at 19050 Pruneridge Avenue.
Staff has made the finding that the protected trees are dead and cannot be controlled or remedied
through reasonable relocation or modification. The proposed replacement plan is consistent with
the Protected Tree Ordinance since the applicant is replacing the trees on site, and the number of
replacements is consistent with the ordinance. The finding is necessary to grant the tree removal
permit in accordance with section 14.18.180 (A) (1) and (3).
The application is approved with the following conditions:
1. APPROVED PROTECT '
This approval is based on the arborist report prepared by Michael Bench (#WE-1897A), dated
September 29, 2015, consisting of four pages including a tree removal and replacement site plan,
except as may be amended by conditions in this resolution.
2. TREE REPLACEMENT
The required replacement trees are four 36-inch box Columnar Blue Atlas Cedar (Cedrus atlantica)
and one 72-inch box Shumard Oak (Quercus shumardii), as per replacement plan. The applicant
shall provide the Department of Community Development adequate documentation, including but
not limited to photographs, receipts or invoices, to verify that the replacement trees have been
planted prior to final occupancy of the main office building at the Apple 2 campus.
3. PROTECTED T'REES
The applicant understands that replacement trees are protected trees and may not be removed
without a Tree Removal Permit and that they shall be responsible for ensuring the proper
maintenance and care of the trees. The applicant shall also disclose the location and species of all
replacements trees on site upon sale of the property.
If � �/�;
/
4. NOTICE OF FEES,DEDICATIONS,RESERVATIONS OR OTHER EXACTIONS
The conditions of Project Approval set forth herein may include certain fees, dedication
requirements, reservation requirements, and other exactions. I'ursuant to Government Code
Section 66020(d) (1), these Conditions constitute written notice of a statement of the amount of such
fees, and a description of the dedications, reservations, and other exactions.You are hereby notified
that the 90-day approval period in which you may protest these fees, dedications, reservations, and
other exaction, pursuant to Government Code Section 66020(a), has begun. If you fail to file a
protest within this 90-day period complying with all of the requirements of Section 66020, you will
be legally barred from later challenging such exactions.
Sincerely,
. �
Piu Ghosh
Senior Planner
(408) 777-3277
piug@cupertino.org
'"""' �/ �1i�
•29�
44
6 ---.—. �.
. Existing tree #2g83
' to be removed due
° " ' ' � to poor health
.
' � ' (dead).
• � � To be replaced by 3
' � 36" box Cedrus
P1836 atlantica columnar
. as shown in green.
P 1850 ; � ��.�
• ,, � .f�_��s_ � /
• � � . �-�.�� i'vumber
. � l�. c ,
. � �n __�S -�5
3 �u
-.��
�'.
�' �no tac � i . ,
� • � ./� =---
, �
P 1825
. �
P 1837
.
P 1824
.
s
P 1823 ' Existing tree #2977
.
to be removed due
to poor health
� (dead).
1846 � � To be replaced by 1
P , 72 box Quercus
�
shumardii and 1 36"
i �6 �° box Cedrus atlantica
� ` - columnar as shown .
�� in green.
�
: -�---- --- --_..�._ _
.
29 2974 c
.�2 40 36
. 956 • '
_10 ' ��`�� :
LSK- 073 -TREE REMOVAL SKETCH
O`t N TREES#2977, #2983
PUBLIC LEDGER BUILDING,SUITE 1123 � 0' 30' 60'
150 SOUTH INDEPENDENCE MALL WEST
PHILADELPHIA,PA 19106 �
TEL 215.440.0030 I FAX 215.440.0041 �''__. SCALE:1"=30'-0" Oct 15,2015
OLIN PARTNERSHIP,LTD.
..__..��---..,__�.�__. .....�,��._..,�___..... .,.,_�._._
� � � ,
Michael L.Bench ������,q� ��.�/$'_ (� /
� Consulting Arborist
Application ftlurnbar
(831) 594-5151 -
— /o '��8 -_/v'
7327 Langley Canyon Road . Da4e
Prunedale,California 93907 �j��g���y-�
� . -.�. Cas� iVlanag�r
A Review of Pine Trees
Located on Tantau Avenue
Apple Campus 2 Project
Cupertino, California
Assignment
I was asked by Meg Thotnas and Dave Muffly, Apple Arborist, to make an.
inspection of the perimeter trees.
Observations
I inspected the subject trees on September 29, 2015.
Concerning the transplanted trees, the current loss rate is 1 Coast Redwood Tree (I do not
have its number), which is 1%. The olive trees around the o�ce building located at the
corner of Pruneridge and Tantau Avenues are currently being boxed for transplant. These
will be stored in a parking lot across the street on Tantau off of Forge Drive. Once these
olive trees are boxed and moved to this storage area, there will have been 99 trees boxed
for transplant. Many of the trees have already been transplanted into the new landscape.
Thus, the current loss rate is slightly less than 1%, which is remarkable. I think this may
be the lowest loss rate of any large project that I have been associated. _
However, a few other transplanted trees are showing signs of stress and are still
- struggling. Time will tell whether or not these other transplanted trees will survive. It
appears that all of the transplanted trees are adequately irrigated at this time.
The majority of the perimeter trees are in good condition. However, the Monterey Pine
(Pinus radiata) Trees #2977 and 2983, both on Tantau Avenue have suddenly died this
past month. I inspected the trunks of these trees and I discovered that each of these trees
has an infestation of Red turpentine beetle (Dendroctonus valens), an insect which
commonly attacks pine trees in stress, especially drought stress.
Prepared by Michael L. Bench, Site Observations: 1
Consulting Arborist September 29, 2015
/��i.
�+�./ ���� ,
Wolfe Road
At Cupertino Village
Cupertino, California
Also, in the same area of Tantau Avenue, I inspected the trunks of two other Monterey
pine Trees#2988 an 2974. These trees are alive but are showing a moderate level of
stress at this point. These two trees (2988 and 2974) are also under attack by the Red
turpentine beetle (Dendroctonus valens). I found 6-8 active exit holes on Tree# 2988
and 2 active exit holes on Tree#2974. There is nearby irrigation for transplanted Coast
redwood trees. I asked Dave Muffly to extend the irrigation to include both 2988 and
2974. Irrigation is the common treatment for Red Turpentine beetle.
I expect that Tree# 2974 will survive the beetle attack as a result of the supplemental
irrigation. It appears that the survival of Tree#2988 is questionable.
I have seen Red Turpentine beetle in prolific numbers this past year and the year before.
In my opinion,the attack by this insect on pine the trees at this site appears to be
primarily a result of the severe drought and likely very little to do with construction.
,
Respectfully submitted,
---��s1_�\��_
Michael L. Bench, Consulting Arborist
International Society of Arboriculture Certification#WE 1897A
American Society of Consulting Arborists Member
Prepaxed by Michael L. Bench, Site Observations: 2
Consulting Arborist September 29, 2015
. f s �A
� �
� ��.�ra.1�� ��h.: �
J� ��� `r� .
� � � � �
:°��Y�.-: �, �.
. t � .�,� '��,�^._
Y ..c � a, �s
1 �`�t- . ;� � � .�r � � ' :
'� y �_ >, '; l.qr ,a,�.?t
� �t}" Y. k, r
�cij�r�t��-�,�,'��: ���.
��+ ��,, ��-�5���t
t. ..
A �!, • ^i� I � t��M
�'.`n '�i'.,�� i'i+� s .N �i�')� .
.�x f''�n' � . ., .��yO?1
. ����,�.�~,,� �` 'iA
� �', � '"��•� �`�s
� Y4 }�� .
��` /�
� � , �
3�+ �•�
� �M�'� 'r����
v �. . ,<.. �\�.. ���, ��s� �
1�. if�`.i !. � h � ;' _.� �4�� ,J
� �•� t'� j� � + .'�.�" � �
•i_ ��.�� �y.A� �.�..� t.Yt;y {�� w���
� � �
.t � +p.�*��'/k ".�n"�'��`�.','T.{, �[. �'F'�''�'.y�b � -� �Y's
` � ` � ` t ;
� Y��:i3.w��y� ♦,'.�c ` ���Ay "•�f . . � .y t a `�' �"`�'Y..`�H �:{ i `:���s�•�,r .
' 'i.: �"�... +. ,t. , • !,�. .'��� 4�4�`' ' ,f �+,19
,� '"' r, ���'`'��,��, ��, �t` w� .� � - r
�' � ��� � ��. , i�' '� 4� �
. . _����� � �'�' ��
:� _ � � `�_�� �
- �-�-,� . t �. � > � - "�,,,��t i . � �� ;��'����%
'� �,`.._E 1 ���`tr ."� 7�"' t�'►���� ;� ��.�r���,-
"}. "�'• ,"- � 4�ti C � ,.�a �.::y,y ,�� �'��..,- , ` '.'� ,i. _ ..f �`�"
_ ,;, _ xe� +�'� ..OS x� ��., �,+��j �<;�t, ,,,Q ,� ti. ;�� .�
T � A� �p
t� . 1 . -._ ��1'� y T!� ..�,.�i �
LL� � �t '�tt � � � � � �(-� � , 4`� ��tl�
� h 4 �" '� �z.$�t� � . .. :�
a ,'� 1.:� �"-+-,���� � � '` ' `�e � .� ;�.-m'�"^ ' �
����'•.. ,` ...5 �.� .'hq\< . � .'.�' i� � �. 'µr. 'd I�Bo�� .. 4��� F�� ►
, _Y-� �.* .�' , Y . w�':., ��, � � f:{ .Si 41{�, �
u�; �� �y�:. }v" �. y �; RMy� � �
, .
,y.
.
�':. ��h� ��y rs i�... � , ( �.. � _�'.? �'��.._�� ", �1!'
��- �1�� t'i'XV� '� ��`� 14d. R,:. � w T... � ���-x, 11
� ? r.l' �:'S� -'^ . 4r '*�'Y� �" �'-�d; �.:7.
� }f.'S1��\���" , `FI'Fl �.�T� .�x. . ,. . .. . .I�� I y�� ".�;
f 'u., .F . > l w ;� ' :. � � . � ..
� "O�"�.y'r�'"' <�S� 1� ��e��� y��k�'�� {� W• �! ' ' �,��;,�/��� �y� .. sl�-������:,
.:�. 9�N ..Y' 1
�{y �
ar!'. �
r.-Y[3-�'3� _./� >s� 7_, Y� �'r•'�,�" �'F�.- ��r �•�� J;.. a���...
r� �. i .
�J+,s�}�' /' �W� � T. : '..+F� -�. • ;._. y.a} '« '
��� ,+ ,4 ti �' �, _ �, -+ s '� * ; +��, � j
%,� � '' � "�' ♦ � x '�
_ s.��,7 �,�'�.♦ J ��',: Z; � �. .f `�,t �;° .� .
# J' ,� �� � � �`,,,�.'�t
. -~ i:. � b -rT'�' �'=�'aY ,,, "�
� ���C' � ,a.` . �� � k�. .++.�
,, �-d_ ,� �,bg � �� �. � :
,g' ,'n�p+'` -+`f• ; ) ,, "�y ,�,g «, a ''� �,�_` ��"
1' f ��= ,����� s ��', ��� ��,
._�� � ���a �.-� � S^,9l`
�
y ar� I +''`1
; ,
� .. --- ,.:. :� ,.
, , ;�., �<�.. ,_ -_. _ .
� , _ _ _:: —
�-�, ,. -
��-.H "�.. . . , � . '�v.- � y "�
- "`"rv"4'1'A"r� t 4�� � � '�uG
F.' a
_ . .- "" ..�y.;.�.'�-.� . �_._ - �"'r� ., -rt�%ir's�e� ICG.:� �- —
. _
. , _r�rri--
._. :..a��s-�,� . � .-r.„ � :�a .A, ,� . --
._� _._'�: _ ''4",�..a"e .,, �.w.,r�._�� �
, �: w•�--. _ _ . �+c .,z.. s � �.s::` � --�-'-r'_.'_ _—' .. y , . --
� :��.,: ���Y - "
. _ ,^ -
' ' _ '
. � .�� -
,�.�. _ �.- �,,,.....�.
." ..'.�" `aa°�'..'.__. _ _..--.—' a'*.' .
_...
;�r�.�.. . �, ... ... . . .._ �_,...---._�..--�-- .......,., '�`" � . ..� r',. ,�"''��''�yx"s."r+
� _.._. .» �.__._.. ..._....-----"- . � . �:x o..,. .. ^�"r
, ,.�
,.�..��-.._----"""",� .. M-=--y".�
_.
�"'-- � � � _ _
� ,'��
._.Yra!!�'.�'� '
��.,,�...+^�`�" ."�""�`.......� .,�,,,._.... �... ' a .
..�. ...�..si*'P" . _,�..�:*°%"x��_. . ._ _._
g��� �
. �,< .
.. ��, ��: '�t�-� ._,_.
; r f��'�i i .✓:
3� -..��y ,��. .�.;A�;.. �,� . �
5 � . rr�e. �� rt.
- � � �i+�Y' ��.�,, -.�
ti . �. +�r;' R *.
- , #^'e F ,�..
t'Q'+ +,
e . � v.r r+ � �` ~''r:. . ,�
? . �-Z �"!'' 7.: 1• .�. _ �,
, .` � .�,�
�� �� :�s�1;w�' .r F� '� ��y���e,:. �� vY,.'�+'��.. .✓_
✓ 'r� �•r 4 '�, �� �y'{(�,i' � 1�'� t
� ��v 4 .;l 11 ��%,5 5��� '�r.f ' L � � �I
�j `� . .� .y"'�
'�'i�, . � ��r' .. . � _
� R Y\ t,.�;'�i ��t,�, �y `..
s ' rr� � ,t�,��� -,-
ex�` � � "�,'��'31 ,r �
�
y� � � ��"i �- � �.�1'1���µ.�'�L'��`y r 4=x .'/�,��':: .i/'
` : �� � _ r` 5i��t'
t.�� . � �'r �=•, l� �'� +s�
�a`:' .- . : - �`- � i:i� i ... �� �� I
'.�^-�► .�� a]'� c;� alr ��.i'! �
'��. � • . _ �.T' ��` /�.' ./ " i�
� ' '"1� y a.' ��`.� 0- �`
��_ �. . �F. � ...r) c � `F � .4.��,+w,�"'�y _
.:`� . .. �•-t�' '/
r�_ .Y ���t � �.. J�, �
�� �j�'''�"
. :.��'ll�t.-i �_ -a.i.- �:j���'*Rt_
` .
:�� .,9 . �'.a��� �.� d`*, ,.-aC - "^. {�!-""
, _ 1.' ` �y ,� .
. 1'-� .�y e��:i,,-. '� s L � .t' ',fr..:.._i�. y"�,,� ' .s� ..'
. �� �� � v��'� i .. �� � .S'
i� ��`.
t '1 l�
�
^ . �.• .n . � V +�� � �t, w. / .
� � ir•
f_, r e i i . ,�R
f 4' -%Fz� �r. ' �1 � � ,
�, �"•� .. � f���t �• �
.*" �` � a
. �.�' S�� ' � r, p �'.rr, `�� �' •�.�`�- �., ..
.,;a; > �,a� ���
-'.,>. ,k �. �' �'�,'. y!i':- �
�L►� "'.�^ 1 �,'4 ,,t'�;'/� � �+ ,
�'
-�.� ; •%
�� �� �
.-; � � - -:.'� -<
r � • ��.
.,�,y i �+n 'r,���� i
���� � �
. . � `.a,�, r: �
, ' ,� '�� �'S::'�3�,a 2~�
. a .. �. � . . � - y v�.,�' __._""�'-.__.._. _ . .. . � " '
� " 1
,
{�� �' " - ' �'fy.. -
� � �_
,��.�::� :''� �'::,,}'� .�'�<i��- � ,�;.�' _;�.,
� ���,�Y.
..� .