HomeMy WebLinkAboutAH 06-25-2015 Administrative Hearing
June 25,2015
Cupertino, CA 95014
(408) 777-3308
APPROVED MINUTES OF THE REGULAR MEETING OF
THE ADMINISTRATIVE HEARING HELD ON June 25, 2015
ROLL CALL
Hearing Officer present: Gary Chao, Assist. Director of Community Development
Staff present: Gian Martire, Assistant Planner
Applicant(s) present: Jacki Horton, Project Manager, Apple Inc.
APPROVAL OF MINUTES:
1. June 11, 2015
The minutes of June 11, 2015 were approved as written
POSTPONEMENTS/REMOVAL FROM CALENDAR:
None
ORAL COMMUNICATION:
A resident, Kathy Helgerson, addressed the Hearing Officer to say that Apple Computers
still has a very large HVAC system on top of the building on Bandley Drive that blows
emissions from prototype products being baked in thermotron ovens. She wanted to know if
the building will be vacated and production moved into the new facility. She wants the
activities in that building to stop. She feels that the industrial nature of the work is
inappropriate next to a residential neighborhood. She and her neighbors suffer from the
affects of the pollution.
A resident, Efrin Linares, addressed the Hearing Officer to say he lives behind the Apple
Campus located at Infinite Loop on Larry Way. He spoke about noise and traffic concerns
which have become increasingly worse in the area in the past several years. Apple
employees, their contractors, and trash collectors are parking on Larry Way. Parents have to
block driveways when picking up or dropping off children at school as there is no street
parking available. He has called and complained, but the person he spoke to at Apple was
indifferent. He also complained that the Apple employees are smoking on the corner in front
of the school. He feels the amount of traffic in the area has become a safety hazard for the
school children. He said that Apple has become so large that they don't care about what they
are doing to the neighborhoods around their buildings.
A resident, Mark Chan, addressed the Hearing Officer. He also lives on Larry Way and is
concerned about the parking issues. He shared the same feelings about the traffic becoming a
safety hazard for the seniors and school children. One of the neighbors on the street has a
2 Administrative Hearing
June 25,2015
debris box in her back yard and there have been port-a-potties and construction noise and
debris going on for some time now. It is not safe. The trucks delivering food to the Campus
Cafe arrive at 4am and are very noisy. There were trees along the wall line between Larry
Way and the Apple parking lot that were-removed last year. These trees helped to cut down
on the noise and they have not been replanted. And when they were removed, it was done
early and when the wind was blowing, making a big mess everywhere.
WRITTEN COMMUNICATIONS:
None
PUBLIC MEETING:
2. Application No.(s): ASA-2015-12
Applicant: Jacki Horton (Apple, Inc.)
Location: 1 Infinite Loop
Architectural and Site approval to allow landscaping improvements at an existing
office complex
Administrative Hearing decision final unless appealed.
Staff Member Martire explained that the applicant is proposing to make these landscaping
improvements in conjunction with (previously approved) fagade improvements on the Apple
Campus at the Apple Store. These improvements will include planting drought tolerant,
native, plants and trees, ADA improvements for compliance and relocation of and new
signage for the store.
The Hearing Officer clarified for the audience that the landscaping improvements are for the
parking strip area directly in front of the Apple Store and are not in any public right of ways
or driveways. He also mentioned that this application does not have a tree removal
component because a Master Tree Removal Plan has already been approved for the Infinite
Loop campus as a whole. This application is just for the site improvements (the landscape
design and ADA upgrades).
The applicant, Jacki Horton, said that the store has not been remodeled in over 20 years. The
remodel is being done to make the store more accessible and attractive to the public it serves.
The Hearing Officer added that the traffic flow has been redesigned and the accessible ramp
has been relocated. Both of these changes will make getting into and out of the store much
better and more efficient.
The Hearing Officer opened meeting for public comments:
A resident, Kathy Helgerson, spoke directly to the Apple representative about tree removals.
She did not like all the tree cuttings all over town. She felt Apple should be using all the
money it is spending to cut down trees and then replant them in better service to the
community. They should be donating the money to homeless shelters, the YMCA, schools
and other such charitable organizations. Apple should have more consideration for the
community and stop wasting so much money.
3 Administrative Hearing
June 25,2015
A resident, Efrin-Linares, echoed the same sentiment as the prior speaker. He said that Apple
is not a good neighbor and that they don't care about anything. He wanted the higher up,
decision makers, to attend these meeting to hear what people have to say.
The Hearing Officer reminded the speakers that this meeting was to discuss the current item
on the agenda. He would be happy to meet with the speakers after the meeting, but the
Public Comment period was open to. discuss the proposed parking strip modifications in
front of the store.
Mr. Linares continued to say that people should be more involved and that Apple does not
care what they are doing to the neighborhoods.
A resident, Mike Chan, said he spoke to 10 of his neighbors on Larry Way. He said they all
felt that there was a lack of notification to the public about this project because no one can see
the ground sign in front of the campus. The residents are concerned about the noise and air
pollution. He also felt that the site improvements are being done outside of construction
hours, very early in the morning. He wanted to see signage on the site reminding Apple
employees and contractors that they are in a noise sensitive area. He wanted to know why
the trees along the wall were removed. He received notice about the prior project for the store
and last year's landscape plan, but the public didn't know because there were no ground
signs. He wanted to make sure that the issues with the excessive noise were not repeated
with this project.
The Hearing Officer closed the Comment Period. He thanked the speakers for their time.
The Hearing Officer clarified the City's public noticing requirements for this meeting per the
City's Municipal Code and mentioned that Apple was only required to post one sign, but
because they are on a corner, they posted two. He reiterated that he needs to focus on the
terms and conditions of approval of the application on the agenda today. He will take into
consideration the concerns raised regarding traffic and noise. The Construction Management
Plan will be designed to minimize impacts on the neighborhood. Repeated violators of the
construction conditions are subject to sanctions and code enforcement actions including fines.
The Hearing Officer suggested that Apple hold a pre-construction meeting with their
contractors to go over the permitted hours of construction, to remind them to be mindful of
excessive noise and to be aware of the sensitivities and concerns of the residents nearby.
Apple will provide a contact person to the City to forward complaints to from the residents.
DECISION: The application was approved by the Hearing Officer per the draft resolution
with the following revisions/additions:
The applicant will prepare a Construction Management Plan that incorporates; Construction
activities need to occur within the City's published construction hours; Construction noise
levels must remain below the decibel limits allowed per the City's Noise Ordinance;
Contractors will be encouraged to park as far away as possible from the residential
neighborhoods;The site will comply with the requirements for clean air as set by BAAQMD.
4 Administrative Hearing
June 25,2015
ADJOURNMENT
Respectfully submitted:
&Iqu 9"
Beth Ebben
Administrative Clerk
g.-planning/AH CommitteelMinutes062515