HomeMy WebLinkAboutAH 05-28-2015 Administrative Hearing
May 28,2015
Cupertino, CA 95014
(408) 777-3308
APROVED MINUTES OF THE REGULAR MEETING OF
THE ADMINISTRATIVE HEARING HELD ON May 28,2015
ROLL CALL
Hearing Officer present: Gary Chao, Assist. Director of Community Development
Staff present: Kaitie Groeneweg, Assistant Planner
Erick Serrano, Assistant Planner
Applicant(s) present: Brian Carrera, Agent (NTerra for Apple, Inc.)
Neil Woolner, Arborist (Arborwell)
Susan Cutler, Project Manager (Apple, Inc.)
APPROVAL OF MINUTES:
May 14, 2015
The minutes of May 14, 2015 were approved as written
POSTPONEMENTS/REMOVAL FROM CALENDAR:
None
ORAL COMMUNICATION:
None
WRITTEN COMMUNICATIONS:
None
PUBLIC HEARING:
1. Application No.(s): ASA-2015-04, TR-2015-09
Applicant: John Noori (Apple, Inc)
Location: 19191 Vallco Parkway
Architectural and Site approval to allow parking lot improvements and the
construction of private, on-site,bus shelters at an office complex;
Tree Removal permit to allow the removal and replacement of 102 protected trees to
allow for parking lot improvements at an office complex
Administrative Hearing decision final unless appealed.
2 Administrative Hearing
May 28,2015
Staff Member Groeneweg explained that Apple, Inc. has proposed parking lot improvements
which include the construction of a bus shelter, pedestrian pathways, re-orienting the
parking stalls, ADA upgrades, EV charging stations, trash "trios", bicycle racks and lockers
and new parking lot lighting. The existing tennis court will be demolished and replaced with
an outdoor seating area for employees. 35 new_parking spaces will be created for a site total
of 500 parking stalls at the completion of the project, which meets exceeds the Parking
Ordinance requirements. The custom built bus shelters are outside of setback areas and are
meeting the height requirements. The applicant proposes to remove 101 trees and transplant
1 tree on the site. They will be replaced with 112 trees, ranging in size from 24" to 60" box.
They will be a mixture of young and mature trees which are native and drought tolerant. The
trees need removed as they fall within the proposed construction site or are in poor health.
Some of the removed trees will be re-purposed on site as benches. The project will be
increasing the overall landscaping on site by approximately 4000 square feet. Staff has
received an inquiry regarding the trees on the perimeter of the property on Tantau Avenue.
Those trees are included in the removal and replanting plan. Staff recommends approval of
the project as it conforms to the Parking and Tree Ordinances.
Hearing Officer Chao clarified the size of the replanted trees and asked what species of trees
would be used. The project Arborist Neil Woolner, stated that the replacement trees would
mostly be Oak and native Sycamore trees. They are drought tolerant and generally long
lasting. The Hearing Officer confirmed with him that most of the existing trees are in poor
health.
A resident, Jennifer Griffin, spoke to her concerns about the proposed replacement Sycamore
tree. The Sycamore tree that was on the property years ago (and had been removed prior to
this application) had been a heritage tree and she would like the new tree to be one too. She
wanted assurance that the Oak trees along the Calabasas Creek would be remaining and
wanted clarification about the Ash trees along Tantau Avenue.
The Hearing Officer asked Staff member Groeneweg if she could reply in response to the
concerns raised about the Sycamore and Oak trees. She stated that the Oak trees are located"
on land belonging to the Santa Clara Valley Water District and as such they are not part of
the proposed project. The trees located along Tantau are Oak and Redwood trees and are not
included in the removal plan as part of this project either. A majority of the Ash trees located
along Vallco Parkway will also be retained. The Hearing Officer asked the project Arborist to
talk about the strengths of the proposed replanting plan. He stated that the trees are going to
be large and are a nice mixture of species that are native and hearty.
The Hearing Officer explained to the resident that the proposed bus shelters are within the
project site and are private shelters for the employees. There are no frontage improvements
being made to accommodate the public transit system.
The Hearing Officer stated that he liked the plan. The site modifications are towards the
interior, rear of the building and will make the site much better. The trees will provide
appropriate shading. The parking lot and site improvements will greatly enhance the space.
DECISION: The applications were approved by the Hearing Officer per the draft resolutions
3 Administrative Hearing
May 28,2015
2. Application No.(s): ASA-2015-09
Applicant: Susan Cutler (Apple, Inc)
Location: 1 Infinite Loop
Architectural and Site approval to allow fagade improvements of approximately 102
linear feet on an office building
Administrative Hearing decision final unless appealed.
Staff Member Serrano explained Apple, Inc. has proposed fagade improvements to the
frontage of building 1 (the public Apple Store) at the Infinite Loop campus. The application
also includes a replacement of the existing ground sign. As project meets all of the current
Municipal Codes, Staff recommends approval of the project per the draft resolution.
The Hearing Officer did not have any questions for staff. The proposed project is pretty
straightforward. The applicant also did not have anything to add.
A resident, Jennifer Griffin, asked if this application also included any tree removals.
The Hearing Officer told her that it did not. He also let her know that all public hearing items
— staff reports, conditions of approvals and decisions are available to the public on the City's
website.
DECISION: The application was approved by the Hearing Officer per the draft resolution
ADJOURNMENT
Respectfully submitted:
&tk ZMA4
Beth Ebben
Administrative Clerk
gplanning/AH Committeexinutes052815