HomeMy WebLinkAboutAH 04-09-2015 Administrative Hearing
April 9,2015
Cupertino, CA 95014
(408) 777-3308
APPROVED MINUTES OF THE REGULAR MEETING OF
THE ADMINISTRATIVE HEARING HELD ON April 9, 2015
ROLL CALL
Hearing Officer present: Gary Chao, Assist. Director of Community Development
Staff present: Gian Martire, Assistant Planner.
Applicant(s) present: Saher Stephan
APPROVAL OF MINUTES:
March 12, 2015
The minutes of March 12, 2015 were approved as written
WRITTEN COMMUNICATIONS:
Four emails were received regarding the item on the agenda. The Hearing Officer has
reviewed them. Concerns mentioned in the emails will be addressed in the discussion of the
agenda item.
POSTPONEMENTS/REMOVAL FROM CALENDAR:
None
ORAL COMMUNICATION:
None
PUBLIC HEARING:
1. Application No.(s): CUP-2015-02
Applicant: Saher Stephan (The Tea Zone &Fruit Bar)
Location: 19505 Stevens Creek Blvd #102
Conditional Use Permit to allow the operation of specialty food stores that
cumulatively occupy more than 50% of the building
Administrative Hearing decision final unless appealed.
Staff Member Martire stated that the proposed specialty food stores are planning to occupy a
space in the Metropolitan mixed use development center. There are five retail spaces in the
center. Each space has about the same square footage. There are already two other specialty
food services located in the Metropolitan center. These stores occupy 40% of the retail space.
The Tea Zone &Fruit Bar will bring the cumulative total of specialty food stores to 60% of the
2 Administrative Hearing
April 9,2015
retail space, which triggers the need for a Conditional or Administrative Use Permit. One of
the main concerns expressed by the neighbors is the affect this new store will have on the
parking. There are 24 above-ground spaces designated for use by the retail center's patrons
and seven underground spaces designated for employee parking. Staff has placed a
condition on the approval that limits the amount of seating so that only five parking spaces
will be required for operation. The trash management concern will be addressed through a
condition requiring that the applicant provide "trash-trio" receptacles. These are designed to
accommodate compost, recyclable and trash debris and must be installed prior to the final
building permit inspections. Staff supports the application and recommends approval per the
draft resolution.
Hearing Officer Chao asked what the hours of operation were and if those hours were in
compliance with the Ordinance. Staff member Martire said that the hours were within the
required times. The Hearing Officer asked about the number of expected employees. It was
stated that there would be 2 employees in the store during business hours. There will be
outdoor seating (8 seats) used during the summer months.
The applicant, Saher Stephen, thanked Staff for their work and hopes the application gets
approved.
A resident and HOA Board member of the Metropolitan, Doug Harris, asked for clarification
of where the trash containers would be installed. He said that one of the other retail tenants
there does not keep a clean frontage nor do they enforce the no smoking rules. He had
spoken to the representatives of The Tea Zone and they have assured him that they will abide
by the rules and keep the area free from trash.
The owner/landlord of the retail spaces, Jenny Cheung, said that she was very happy to be
having The Tea Zone & Fruit Bar as her tenant. She went to their other location and spoke to
the landlord. All of the references and referrals she has received have been positive.
Ronnie Mamarian, spoke in support of the new business. And thanked Staff for their help
through the application process.
Hearing Officer Chao asked Mr. Harris as a Board member, if the Board had had any
discussion about this new tenant coming in. He said that they had not because they hadn't
heard about it. And when they did hear about it, they were under the assumption that the
City had already approved the application. He said that the Board was surprised that another
food place was coming in,but thought that since it was already decided, they didn't have any
say in the matter. He has no objection and is glad to hear that they will be running a
responsible establishment. He did have some concerns about the driveway coming into the
center. There is no "keep clear", so during peak hours the driveway is blocked so cars coming
into and leaving the center have long waits. The Hearing Officer said he would pass those
comments along to the Public Works Department.
The Hearing Officer mentioned the emails that had received from the Metropolitan residents.
He reiterated that the application has not been approved and that the Business License has
not been signed off on. The approval is being decided now, at thi's hearing. That is why
everyone is here. He apologized to Mr. Harris and said that whomever had told the Board
that the City had already approved the application was mistaken. The emails also expressed
concerns about additional litter on the site. The Hearing Officer proposed an additional
condition of approval whereby a 'sweep' needs to be conducted of the store perimeter and
3 Administrative Hearing
April 9,2015
parking lot areas to ensure that litter is cleared away daily. He also asked that a schedule of
clean up times be provided to the City and to incorporate a method for encouraging their
patrons to be responsible for the proper disposal of trash. The Hearing officer let the
applicant know that the City has a Code Enforcement department to help enforce the rules
when it comes to smoking regulations, loitering and noise issues. The tenants and residents
should avail themselves of this resource if they feel they need to. The Hearing Officer said he
feels that the parking regulations are adequate for the uses at the site.
The applicant thanked the Hearing Officer for the suggestions to help keep the site clean and
free from complaints. He said he would definitely implement some of the ideas but would
really appreciate it the City could find a way to have another set of trash-trios installed at the
other end of the retail center in front of the other store that seems to be causing a lot of
problems. The Hearing Officer said he would have a conversation with the other property
owner but could not promise that another trash trio would be installed.
The Hearing Officer did state that Use Permits are subject to recall and review if a problem
cannot be fixed by other means. The property owner or business would have to apply for a
new Use Permit. A new hearing would be scheduled where new conditions and permissions
could be decided and/or imposed.
The applicant and all the speakers at the meeting expressed tremendous thanks to the Staff
for all their help and said that they really enjoyed the working with Gian and Alex (Wykoff)
and feeling like they were being heard and respected.
DECISION: The application was approved by the Hearing Officer per the draft resolution
with the following additional condition:
The applicant shall work with Staff to submit a plan that addresses litter, illegal smoking, and
education of patrons to reduce the potential of such complaints.
ADJOURNMENT
Respectfully submitted:
?• �
Beth Ebben
Administrative Clerk
g:planning/AH CommitteelMinutes040915