HomeMy WebLinkAboutAH 11-13-2014 Administrative Hearing
November 13,2014
Cupertino, CA 95014
(408) 777-3308
APPROVED MINUTES OF THE REGULAR MEETING OF
THE ADMINISTRATIVE HEARING HELD ON November 13,2014
ROLL CALL
Hearing Officer present: Gary Chao, Assist.Director of Community Development
Staff present: Piu Ghosh
Rebecca Tolentino
Applicant(s) present: Apple Campus II development team
APPROVAL OF MINUTES:
October 9,2014
The minutes of October 9, 2014 were approved as written
WRITTEN COMMUNICATIONS:
None
POSTPONEMENTS/REMOVAL FROM CALENDAR:
None
ORAL COMMUNICATION:
None
PUBLIC HEARING:
1. Application No.(s): ASA-2014-08,TR-2014-59 (EA-2011-12)
Applicant: Wolfgang Wagener(Apple Campus 2)
Location: properties located east and west of N Tantau bounded by Calabasas
Creek to the north and west, City of Santa Clara limits to the east and
1-280 to the south
Architectural and Site approval to review office, research and development facilities in three
buildings, associated parking structure, restaurant and site improvements for Phase 2 of a
previously approved office, research and development campus;
Tree Removal Permit to refine a previously approved Master Tree Removal Permit (TR-2011-
39) for an office, research and development campus
Administrative Hearing decision final unless appealed.
Staff Member Ghosh reported that the applications are to define the architectural details for Phase 2A
(5 buildings on sites C & D) of the new Apple Campus 2 project. The project was approved by the
2 Administrative Hearing
November 13,2014
City Council in 2013 and Phase 1 is currently under construction. The proposed design of the 5
buildings on sites C & D is consistent with the prior approvals. The proposed square footage in these
sites has been slightly reduced from what was originally approved. The building heights are at or
below the approved limit. The proposed setbacks, parking and bicycle spaces are within the original
prescribed amounts, including the setbacks along Calabasas Creek. There will be less grading than
originally proposed as some of the parking will now be in a structure rather than all underground as
originally proposed. The applicant is requesting to remove additional trees. These trees are in poor
health or are within the building envelope of the project sites. However, even with the increased
number of removed trees, the overall trees to be removed is still within the prior approved limit. The
applicant will be retaining and transplanting some of the trees that were originally marked for
removal. The proposed architectural design complements the design of the new campus building
with glass facades, metal awnings and energy efficient components. Three of the buildings will be
very similar in appearance. All of the rooftop mechanical systems will be screened from view. The
sites can only be accessed by one continued intersection which will provide good traffic flow off of
Tantau Avenue. A condition has been added to allow Staff to review and approve the lighting plan to
ensure there is no light spillage or light pollution onto the adjacent neighbors. The site is required to
have water efficient landscaping. A portion of the existing fence will be being replaced at the shared
property line and a sound wall will be added along the freeway. A condition has been added to have
the new sound walls screened to 'soften' their appearance along the freeway. The environmental
consultant reviewed the proposed design and prepared an addendum to the original EIR stating that
there are no new concerns or impacts. Staff has received one comment regarding the proposed height
of one of the new testing facility buildings (from an existing single to a two story), a comment
regarding noticing of the project and a comment relating to the overall operation of the campus
(noise, light, traffic, hazardous materials, privacy, etc.). Staff member Ghosh stated that these items
had been addressed in the original approval process and that the applicant's proposals adhere to the
requirements of the prior approval. The City has also met its obligations according to the Municipal
Code and Ordinances. The Environmental Impact Report outlines mitigations designed to reduce the
impacts of the campus operations to the surrounding areas.
The Hearing Officer asked for clarification about the reduced square footage; the restaurant and
satellite plant buildings have been reduced in size. The Hearing Officer asked Staff Member Ghosh to
explain more about the light plan requirement. She explained that prior to the issuance of the
building permit, the applicant is required to submit photometric plans drawn up by certified electrical
engineers. These plans will show what the light levels are at different distances from the various light
sources. At the property line, the light level should be at zero. There should be no light spillage onto
the neighboring properties. The Hearing Officer asked about the procedures when an applicant asks
to remove additional trees. Staff Member Ghosh stated that a certified arborist needs to do an audit on
the trees to confirm that the request for removal is valid. The audit revealed that the additional trees
are in poor health and would not survive the construction or transplanting process. She emphasized
that there are no trees between the creek and the residences slated for removal. And that the same
number of trees being replanted on the site is in accordance with the Protected Tree Ordinance. The
Hearing Officer clarified for the public in attendance that the purview of this meeting was to outline
the architectural style of the buildings and landscaping plans for sites C and D. The overall scope and
scale of the project has already been approved by the City Council. The Hearing Officer asked about
the proposed design change to the parking structure. Staff Member Ghosh said that the main parking
structure, which is adjacent to the Hamptons Apartment complex, has architectural features that will
screen the glare from the headlights of the cars in that parking structure onto the complex. She is
suggesting that this parking structure have the same sort of features along the north east corner.
3 Administrative Hearing
November 13,2014
The applicant's agent, Dan Whisman, addressed the Hearing Officer. He spoke about the timeline for
the other construction projects taking place on the site. The demolition of the existing structures for
Phase 2B (areas north of Pruneridge) should start in summer 2015 with new construction progressing
after that and into 2016. Construction in the areas south of Pruneridge and north of Calabasas Creek
will start later in 2016. He stated that they would be willing to reduce the light levels in the parking
garage according to employee usage and daylight hours. Apple employees have flexible schedules,
but generally the buildings would be occupied from gam to 6pm.
The Hearing Officer opened the public hearing session:
Jennifer Griffin, Cupertino resident; asked about the potential removal of one row of Ash trees near
the crossing of Stevens Creek and Tantau and about what road improvements will be done around
the development site.
Richard Wentz, Santa Clara resident; asked about the old concrete wall. He wanted to know if it
would be extended. He also asked for clarification about the tree removals. He wanted to make sure
that the existing setbacks between Apple and the abutting residential homes would be the same. He
also wanted to make sure that contact information would be provided to the neighbors so concerns,
questions or complaints could be addressed promptly by someone at Apple.
The concrete wall will be extended, the Redwood trees will not be removed, the setbacks will be the same;
contact information will be provided
Carol Cherry, Santa Clara resident; she stated that she has been having trouble reaching anyone at
Apple. She is concerned about noise as her bedroom is along the construction site. She complained
that construction is sometimes starting at 4:30 am.
Contact information will be provided
Janice Wentz, Santa Clara resident; wanted to know why the parking garage is going to be located
next to a park where children play. The children would be exposed to exhaust fumes.
The garage is 'open air' so the fumes will dissipate; the placement of the parking structure is by design
to have it as far away from the residences as possible
(unknown) Mary, San Jose resident; said she thought that all the parking was to be underground. She
also was concerned that the employee shuttle routes would be through neighborhoods.
There is underground parking for Phase 1 part of the project; the shuttle routes have been designed so
that the buses will not run through neighborhoods
Tamara Rodriguez, San Jose resident; stated her concerns about privacy with all the big glass
windows and the light spillover onto her property, especially at night. She also wanted to have a
number to call to report bad shuttle bus drivers.
Rob Wagner, Santa Clara resident, he feels the buildings are too tall and expressed privacy concerns
similar to the prior speaker. He also says he has a problem with Apple's employees who smoke. They
all congregate near the building close to his house at the south end of the creek. He is hoping that the
replanted trees will be shorter than Redwoods so to have low canopies.
Patrick Robbins, Santa Clara resident; shared privacy concerns from all of the large glass windows
proposed along his property line. He said the site elevations of the plan set didn't appear to be very
factual in depiction of the sight line measurements of the residential fence line to the proposed
windows.
The public hearing session was closed.
The Hearing Officer thanked the members of the public for their input and encouraged them to talk to
the Apple Representative or to the City's Staff to help get issues or concerns addressed promptly. Dan
Whisman said he would instruct his Staff to be better neighbors and to do what he could to get a
better response when calls come in about the new construction and ongoing operations.
The Hearing Officer reminded the speakers that some of the issues brought up today are outside the
scope of the authority of this meeting. Setbacks,building envelopes and building heights had already
4 Administrative Hearing
November 13,2014
been approved by the City Council. He would be able to address concerns regarding light spillage.
The office buildings will have occupancy sensors on all the lighting so that if a space doesn t have any
activity for some length of time, the lights in that space will go off. The discussion continued
regarding the possibility of installing opaque glass or opaque window treatments on higher floors
rather than just on the first floor to help with the privacy concerns. Staff and the applicant will explore
options to mitigate the privacy concerns of the neighbors pertaining to window treatments. The
applicant did state that all the homes are all single story so the proposed designs with the trees and
high wall did take their privacy concerns into consideration. Just as the residents don't want Apple
staff to be able to look into their homes, Apple doesn't want the residents to be able to look into their
office buildings. The hearing officer said that a Condition of Approval will be added to include
privacy treatments for the glass and that these privacy treatments will need to be maintained. The
Hearing Officer spoke regarding the existing perimeter Redwood trees. The original approval calls for
those trees to remain in place. He said he would be willing to talk to the applicant about enhancing
the landscape plan where there may be gaps. Staff member Ghosh wanted to make a note that the
language in the Staff Report of one the findings of the project will be slightly re-written for better
clarity.
DECISION: The applications were approved by the Hearing Officer per the draft resolutions with the
following modifications:
Modify the existing condition regarding light screening for the light concerns on the parking garage
near the north east corner that sits on a angle facing the residences to include wording such that prior
to the issuance of the building permit, the applicant shall work out a screening solution with Staff.
Screening options shall include,but not limited to a timed or sensory device or a physical barrier;
Add a condition to require the applicant to work with Staff prior to the issuance of the building
permit to establish a strategy to mitigate privacy issues for the second story glass panes along the east
and northeast sections of the buildings facing the neighboring residences. Such mitigations shall
include,but not limited to, opaque glass or other window treatments starting at the 5 foot level;
Make minor revisions to conditions for better clarity.
ADJOURNMENT
Respectfully submitted:
. &&-� u4t-p—
Beth
Ebben
Administrative Clerk
gplanning/AH Committee/Minutes111314