Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutAH 09-12-2013 Administrative Hearing September 12,2013 Cupertino, CA 95014 (408) 777-3308 APPROVED MINUTES OF THE REGULAR MEETING OF THE ADMINISTRATIVE HEARING GHELD ON September 12, 2013 ROLL CALL Hearing Officer-present: Gary Chao, City Planner Staff present: Stephen Rose George Schroeder Applicant(s) present: Jose Garcia (Oakmont Produce Market) Terry Brown (Long residence/Stanley Square) APPROVAL OF MINUTES: August'22,,2013 The minutesof August 22, 2013 were approved WRITTEN COMMUNICATIONS: Two desk items were received for item #2 & #3. They are emails°concerning the Tree Removal applications POSTPONEMENTS/REMOVAL FROM CALENDAR: None ORAL COMMUNICATION: None PUBLIC HEARING: 1. ApplicationNo.(s): U-2012-06 Applicant: Federico Diaz;(Oakmont Produce Market) Location: 19948'Homestead Rd Administrative Use Permit to,allow the.outdoor display of merchandise and to allow a bakery operation that does not involveahe direct.retailing of goods to the general public Administrative Hearing decision final unless appealed. Staff Member Rose reported that application is a retroactive Use Permit for an existing outdoor display. The bread is made in an adjoining tenant space and is sold at the Oakmont Produce Market. The application will address a complaint that was received concerning the display bins blocking parking spaces .at the front of the store. The application will require the installation of new trash enclosure covers,,a shopping,cart corral, to bring the display bins in at night and the area will be kept 2 Administrative Hearing September 12,.2013' clean. The bakery operation has been in operation since early 2012 without a use permit or business license. The Applicant has obtained a business license for the bakery operation and because the business,is conjunction,with the produce market, is unobtrusive to the rest of the shopping center and already functional, Staff supports the limited retail use in this location where it otherwise would not. Once the tenant space becomes vacated, the space will be re-evaluated to a return of strictly general commercial uses. The Hearing Officer confirmed that the Building Department had reviewed the parking lot area for the changes necessitated by the cart corral. Staff member Rose stated that they had looked at the design to ensure accessibility and that the.minimum widths for travel have been met. The applicant, Jose Garcia,-spoke to state'that the application process was initiated because they were seeking to expand their space at the shopping center. They had outgrown their original location. The Hearing Officer asked the "applicant for confirmation that there are no retail sales of bread from the bakery site. The applicant confirmed that if a person was to inquire about a bread purchase, they would be directed to the.Market. The Hearing Officer reminded 'the applicant get back in touch with the City to complete the permitting process for the trash enclosure. He commented that the site,changes would be,enhancing the market location and help business. He thanked the applicant for coming in and working hard with the City to address;all the concerns on site and obtain the proper permits. DECISION: The application was approved by the Hearing Officer per the draft resolution 2. Application No.(s): DP=2013-01, ASA-2013-03,TR-2013-12 Applicant: Terry Brown (Long residence) Location: 10049 Imperial Ave Development Permit to allow the demolition of a single family, residence with a detached garage and to allow the construction of a new two-story mixed use building with a commercial space-and medical space.and one residential apartment; Architectural and Site ,approval to allow the construction of a new two-story mixed use building with associated site improvements; Tree Removal Permit to, allow the transportation of an 18:2" Coast Live Oak tree and the removal and replacement of a 24' diameter Pittosporum tree and two multi-trunk California Peppertreeson the site,of a proposed mixed use building Heard in conjunction with: 3. Application No.(s): ASA-2013-04, TR-2013-32 Applicant: Terry Brown (Stanley Square) Location: 21666—21686 Stevens Creek;Blvd Architectural and Site approval to allow modifications to the parking lot layout to facilitate a reciprocal ingress and egress at an existing shopping ,center (Stanley Square) in the Monta Vista Special Planning District; Tree Removal Permit to allow the removal and replacement of four Flowering Pear trees as part of the.modifications to the parking lot layout Administrative Hearing decision final unlessappealed. 3 Administrative Hearing September 12,2013 Staff Member Schroeder explained that the applications are adjacent to each other. The single family residence will be demolished and replaced with a new 3,800 square foot mixed use commercial building. The application for the Stanley Square shopping center is basically for parking lot modifications to share the travel pathways with the new mixed use building on the:neighboring lot. On the Imperial site, the applications involve a new two-way driveway connection between the two sites, a maintenance agreement, sidewalks and landscaping enhancements along the frontage, a new trash enclosure and rear parking lot. On the Stevens Creek site, the applications will change the parking space layout;, widening the driveways and fence removal for connectivity to the adjacent lot, landscaping and lighting improvements. The sites will be required to record ingress/egress right covenants for use during future development applications. The onsite and street ,parking is in conformance with the Parking Ordinance and the General Plan for the Monta Vista area. The tree removals for the parking lot modifications involve a total of 7 trees on both sites. The trees are,not specimen 'trees but are protected. An Arborist has evaluated the trees on site. He concurs with the removal request. There is an Oak tree on site.which will be transplanted. The arborist will be retained by the applicant to ensure the tree is moved properly. The applicant will be required to replant 10 replacement trees throughout the site. Staff supports the development requests as the site modifications conform to the Monta Vista design guidelines and the General Plan, will offer better pedestrian and bicycle access, the mixed use building will have a "storefront" appearance and the building architecture will fit in with the neighborhood. Staff member Schroeder stated thatthe emails received were from neighbors in the area and were about the tree removals. They are mainly questions regarding the transplantation of the Oak tree and the specie selection of the replacement trees. He said that the consulting arborist will be on hand to make sure the transplantation is done correctly and thatth&appropriate kinds of trees•are replanted to grow and thrive in the space. The Hearing Officer asked for clarification of the laontage enhancements. Staff member Schroeder explained that the existing sidewalks are detached. The applicant will be asked to shift the sidewalks and connect them, install landscaping, bike racks,benches and trash receptacles and lighting. The applicant, Terry Brown, addressed the Hearing Officer on behalf of the Longs. He thanked Staff member,Schroeder for his report and assistance with the project. He assured the Hearing Officer that the project would be an asset to the Monte Vista area. The HearingOfficer asked the'applicantis they were working with the Public Works department to be able to meet their requirements'for handling rain runoff on the 'site. He said that he was familiar with their requirements and that the design elements of the parking lot will provide the compliance they need. Peter Yesni, from the Monte.Vista Market, addressed the Hearing Officer. He asked what the City's lighting requirements are for parking lots. He feels that the parking lot is"under-lighted. He claims that the lot is very busy and is not always safe. Customers and employees have to carry out their groceries or the trash across the parking lot in the dark during the.winter months.He would like it if the applicants could be required to install more lighting in the parking lot. Staff member Schroeder replied that the City does have.standards for lighting-in parking lots. There is a condition of approval for these applications which includes a lighting plan for the site. The lighting plan will show where the light poles are and where the illumination will be. The plan will need to be reviewed and approved before the issuance of the building permits. His comments will certainly be taken into consideration upon review of the plan. The Hearing Officer stated that the lighting is a balancing act in thatthe neighbors to the rear of the property don't want lights shining into their yards but the employees and.customers need to feel safe. Re asked that the lighting plan condition of approval be included in both applications. Staff member Schroeder 'also stated that other components of the project include a traffic circulation and a safety plan. 4 Administrative Hearing September 12,2013 The Hearing Officer said that the.supports the application as"it follows the Monte Vista Plan intent of providing connectivity and the architectural design is consistent-with the neighborhood. DECISION: The applications were approved by the.Hearing Officer per the draft resolutions with the modification of Resolution for ASA-2013-04 to include a lighting plan,requirement ADJOURNMENT Respectfully submitted: &L Beth_Ebben, Administrative'Clerk g:planning/AH CommitteelMinutes091213