Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutAH 08-08-2013 Administrative Hearing August 8,2013 Cupertino, CA 95014 (408) 777-3308 APPROVED MINUTES OF THE REGULAR MEETING OF THE ADMINISTRATIVE HEARING HELD ON August 8,2013 ROLL CALL Hearing Officer present: Gary Chao, City Planner Staff present: Simon Vuong,Project Planner Applicant present: Todd Dewell(Kimco Realty) Bill Brown(Kimco Realty) David Jameson(Kimco Realty) Deanna Henry (Kimco Realty) Rob Anderson(Field Paoli) APPROVAL OF MINUTES: June 27,2013 The minutes of June 27, 2013 were approved WRITTEN COMMUNICATIONS: Several desk items were submitted in regards to Item �1 The Hearing Officer stated that all of the materials submitted have been reviewed by the City. Most of the comments received were in relation to the prior approvals issued for the re-development of the shopping center and could not be addressed at this hearing as they are outside the scope of the current project POSTPONEMENTS/REMOVAL FROM CALENDAR: U-2012-06, Federico Diaz (Oakmont Produce Market), 19948 Homestead Rd, Applicant requested a postponement to the August 22, 2013 meeting At the meeting, the application was postponed to the September 12, 2013 meeting ORAL COMMUNICATION: None PUBLIC HEARING: 1. Application No.(s): ASA-2013-05 Applicant: Todd Dewell (Kimco Realty) Location: 10825-10983 N Wolfe Road (Cupertino Village) Architectural and Site approval for modifications to a previously approved two-story parking garage and two retail buildings at an existing shopping center Administrative Hearing decision final unless appealed. 2 Administrative Hearing August 8,2013 Staff Member Vuong explained the shopping center received prior approvals for redevelopment by the City Council in 2008, extension applications were granted in 2010 and minor site modifications were approved in 2011. The applicant is submitting refinements to the site design for discussion and approval today. These minor design refinements include changes to the color of the siding, changing the awnings and canopy materials from wood and stucco to metal and steel, posts, roof screens and stucco wall to concrete and wood. The application also includes landscaping refinements to the pedestrian walkways and to the landscaping features in the courtyard and plaza areas. The application also includes revisions to the loading areas and trash enclosure facilities. The application does not pose any substantive changes to the original approvals. Staff recommends the application be approved, since the proposed enhancements bring a more modern look and feel to the site in keeping with the original design as well as provide better pedestrian features. Th e Hearing Officer asked if the Public Works Department reviewed the proposed site changes. Staff member Vuong stated that they had and did not have additional concerns. The applicant, Todd Dewell, addressed the Hearing Officer to introduce his associates also in attendance. He thanks staff for the time spent working with them on the project. He stated that the architectural changes in the site details stem from the modern, contemporary look of the new Apple Campus to be constructed on the neighboring site. They are working on parking management plans, construction management plans, construction drawing for the parking structure, security maintenance plan and a photometric study all of which are required per the conditions of approval. The Hearing Officer opened the meeting for Public Comments: There were several members of the public in attendance to voice concerns. (Each person is allowed three minutes to address the Hearing Officer.) Holly Lofgren, 1655 Martin Ave, spoke to say that the application had not been properly noticed in the past and stated that the changes proposed should trigger an Environmental Impact Report (EIR). She specifically made mention of a former dry cleaning site and requested that all future development applications be noticed to the public within a quarter of a mile. (Mrs. Lofgren also made two attempts to object to the proceeding prior to the public commenting period. The Hearing Officer ensured her that her prior written concerns have been reviewed and responded to by the City. The Hearing officer also asked her to hold her comments until the appropriate public commenting period during the meeting. Mrs. Lofgren cited concerns with when she will be able to voice her objections.) May Huang, 1725 Linnet Lane, said that she was not notified of the modification application in 2011. Sally Beaupre, 1662 Grospeak, said that there is too much building in Cupertino that borders Sunnyvale. She would like to see more of a partnership between the two Cities. She is fearful that the changes in her community are turning her part of Sunnyvale into an urban area and it's not a neighborly thing for Cupertino to do. Dean Fujiwara, 1725 Linnet Lane, he stated a comparison of the proposed entitled plan to the old plan and with the conditions of use from the 2008 approval. He stated that the 2011 applications do not have any conditions of use in them. He stated that there is a change to sheet 4 which demonstrate that the scope of the project has changed beyond minor architectural and site modifications. He specified changes to the traffic pattern for truck turn lanes for deliveries to the Ranch 99 Market grocery store. He had concerns that the turning area was too tight within the center and the traffic on Homestead would be impacted by trucks waiting to get into the shopping center. He also perceived a discrepancy in the count of available parking spaces from the original approval and the current proposal. David Lee, Ranch 99 Market, he stated his concerns with the proposed site plan. He cited the truck access area on Homestead is not a good idea and would like the truck to have access from Pruneridge. He said their delivery trucks are too long for the allotted turn area. He has concerns about the public safety with the modified traffic lanes. He liked the 2008 site plan better. He also said that the compost compactors 3 Administrative Hearing August 8,2013 and dumpsters are not adequate for the volume generated. He stated concerns regarding the lack of an elevator and shopping cart corrals in the parking structure. Dean Fujiwara, 1725 Linnet Lane, he spoke again to state that the new trash enclosures were closer to residences than in the original plan and that he would like to have cameras installed to make sure the allowable delivery times are adhered to. Bharat Chandrasekhar, 824 Lark Lane, he shared concerns regarding the roof screen, wall height and noise. He says the roof screen original contained noisE' control measures,but the new plan does not. The wall is only 6 feet tall so people can look over the wall down into the yards of the abutting homes. He feels this is a loss of privacy and security as all the second stories of the homes on Linnet Lane can be seen into. Additionally he has concerns about the noise levels during the night for deliveries and during construction. Sue Rosado, 1725 Kinglet Ct, she expressed concern that the original plan did not call for access from Linnet Lane except for emergency vehicles. She does riot want access to the shopping center from Linnet Lane as this will cause a tremendous increase in traffic on her street. The Hearing Officer clarified that this driveway will not be open to the public and the applicant stated that the driveway she was looking at was on the interior side of the project. He reiterated that there would be no public driveway access through Linnet Lane to the shopping center. Rao Mohan, 835 E Homestead Road, he shared the concerns of prior speakers regarding the parking and traffic. He said there are a lot of accidents from people existing left onto Homestead Road. He expressed concerns about the demolition of the dry cleaners site. Tap Merrick, 1091 Firth Ct, he also said the exit out of the shopping center onto Homestead Road is very bad, especially turning left. Darrel Lum, Concerned Citizens of Cupertino, echoed the concerns of the prior speakers regarding making left hand turns onto Homestead Road. He also expressed a concern that the draft Apple Campus EIR suggested that the southern most driveway into Cupertino Village be closed or made into a right hand turn only. He asked for clarification which driveway was being discussed. The Hearing Officer said he would speak to him separately as the Apple Campus project was not part of the discussion today. Dale Witherspoon, pastor, Good Samaritan United Methodist Church, shared his concerns to make sure the dry cleaning site is properly cleaned to ensure the health and safety of the children at the church's pre-school. He also wanted to make sure the 8 foot screening wall between the church and shopping center would be installed. The wall will protect the children from vagrants and other undesirable people that have been seen in the area recently. He also said they have a problem with shopping center patrons parking in their parking lot. Robert Reid, member, Good Samaritan Church, says there has been always an agreement that parishioners are allowed to park in the shopping center parking lot to walk across the street to Sunday services and traffic has become so bad that is had become a hazard especially for the elderly. James Garrison, 825 Lark Lane, expressed concerns regarding the noticing of the prior applications in 2011. He said that their neighborhood is used for overflow parking. On the weekends it is particularly bad and feels that with the proposed increased size in the retail buildings, the situation will get worse. Since there will still be two pedestrian entrances off Linnet, this will further encourage shopping lot parking in their neighborhoods. He also that the left turn out of the parking lot is hazardous and there are long delays to get out. Shankar Ponnekanti, 1713 Linnet Lane, he also expressed concerns about the parking and turning situation onto Homestead. Dan, Linnet Lane, he stated that on weekends the trash piled up next to the Ranch 99 Market is bad. He also reiterated the traffic concerns in the area along Wolfe Road. 4 Administrative Hearing August 8,2013 Andy Frazier, 1624 Nightingale Ave,he has concerns regarding the parking structure and thinks that the poor design will cause people to use the north exit onto Homestead Road causing the already bad situation to become worse Zou Chenfang, 807 Parnell PI, he stated the making a left turn onto Homestead is very bad and wanted to know if traffic signal could be installed. All of the new development in the area will increase traffic. Sandeep Namrata, 1626 Heron Lane, expressed the same concerns regarding turning left onto Homestead and wanted Cupertino and Sunnyvale to work together to fix the situation. Dan, Linnet Lane, he asked if the access way from Wolfe Road to Highway 280 has been addressed. He says there is a large back up getting onto the freeway from Wolfe Road and is dangerous to pedestrians. Dean Fujiwara, 1725 Linnet Lane, said that the City of Sunnyvale and the City of Cupertino do not want to do anything about the traffic issues. Gerri, Lark Way, she said that she is a pedestrian and her walk to work takes her past the Ranch 99 Market driveway entrance. She says it is the most dangerous part of her walk. The Hearing Officer closed the public comment period. He appreciated the comments that have been conveyed and received. He stated the City Council addressed these comments during the original approval process in 2008. The applications in 2011 were only for extensions of the approvals received in 2008. Prior to the issuance of building permits, all of the Conditions of Approval for the development will need to be met as prescribed by the City Council and the City's Municipal Code. This includes, but is not limited to a photometric plan to address lighting concerns, a noise analysis, a trash management plan and a parking management plan which will include customer parking as well as delivery trucks. The scope of the current project is for minor changes in the colors and building materials. The original required conditions have not changed. The architectural changes in the scope of this project do not warrant that an EIR be done. The cumulative environmental impacts from all of the development in the area are being addressed in the Apple Campus EIR. He suggested that these traffic concerns along the Homestead Road area be brought up during the public process for that project. The Hearing Officer reminded everyone that he could not address the comments made which are outside of the scope to the application being heard today. In 2008, an environmental review was conducted, reviewed and mitigations approved. According to the CEQA guidelines, the color and material changes being requested today are not significant nor do they create any new impacts warranting a new environmental report. The prior identified impacts have not changed and their mitigations are still required. The applicant, Bill Brown, spoke regarding the site cleanup of the former dry cleaning site. A soil remediation plan has been in effect for the past several years. The EPA provides soil reports on a quarterly basis. The ground will be encapsulated by asphalt. They will not be building a habitable space on that site. They anticipate the soils remediation equipment will be on site for another 18 months before they receive final clearance. He also said that the wall between the church and the shopping center will remain. The Hearing Officer asked the applicant to talk about the roof screening on the garage. He stated that in the original design in 2008,had a 4 foot wall with a 45 degree cant wall above it. The way the wall moved across, there became a gap between the two wall sections. The new design is still 14 feet, 6 inches above grade. The wall goes up 6 feet above and a screen has been added along with landscaping. All of the elements should help reduce the scale of the wall frontage while still being able to provide noise and lighting reductions. They are planting two rows of trees, a drainage swale and green screens to help soften the look of the garage. The applicant is available to speak to anyone to answer concerns about the redevelopment of the shopping center. The Hearing Officer spoke to address the noticing concerns. He explained that not all development projects are required by the City's Ordinances to be noticed in the same way. The City also has 5 Administrative Hearing August 8,2013 attempted to go above and beyond the minimum noticing radius. As an example, this current project is only required to be noticed 300 feet, but the City decided to widen the noticing for this application in deference to the original 2008 noticing. The City uses a database service to generate its mailing labels. Sometimes the database's information is imperfect, but the City has done its best to provide the appropriate noticing. The Hearing Officer stated the project changes are a nice improvement and that the minor site modifications are within the scope of the original approval. The applicant's modified rear loading areas have been reviewed and approved by the Public Works department. As a condition from the prior approval, the final parking plan will be reviewed and approved by the City prior to issuance of building permits. He encouraged Kimco and Ranch 99 Market to get together for further refinements to the delivery and loading areas. This application is approved per the draft resolution. The prior 2008 resolutions' conditions remain unchanged and in effect. DECISION: Application ASA-2013-05 was approved by the Hearing Officer ADJOURNMENT Respectfully submitted: Beth Ebb Administrative Clerk g:planning/AH CommitteelMinutes080813