Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutAH 08-09-2012 Administrative Hearing August 9,2012 Cupertino, CA 95014 (408) 777-3308 APPROVED MINUTES OF THE REGULAR MEETING OF THE ADMINISTRATIVE HEARING HELD ON August 9,2012 ROLL CALL 5:08pm Hearing Officer present: Aarti Shrivastava,Director of Community Development Staff present: George Schroeder, Project Planner Applicant present: Efrain Corona, McDonald's USA, LLC. Jack Rittenhouse,Stantec Architecture APPROVAL OF MINUTES: May 24,2012 The minutes of May 24,2012 were approved WRITTEN COMMUNICATIONS: A letter was received from Mr. Faber. It will be reviewed during the application discussion. POSTPONEMENTS/REMOVAL FROM CALENDAR: None ORAL COMMUNICATION: None PUBLIC HEARING: 1. Application No.(s): DP-2012-03,ASA-2012-08,TR-2012-24 Applicant: Hala Ibrahim(McDonald's) Location: 10990 N Stelling Rd Development Permit to allow a 761 square foot addition to an existing 3,595 square foot drive- thru restaurant; Architectural and Site Permit to allow facade modifications for the expansion of an existing drive- thru restaurant and associated site improvements; Tree Removal Permit to allow the removal and replacement of four trees in the parking lot of an existing drive-thru restaurant in conjunction with site improvements to facilitate the restaurant expansion Administrative Hearing decision final unless appealed. Staff Member Schroeder explained that the application is to approve an addition to an existing drive- thru restaurant and as the addition is less than 10.000 square feet, the application needs to be approved through an Administrative Hearing. The McDonald's Corporation would like to update the look of the existing restaurant, revise the pedestrian pathways, sidewalks and parking lot. The application includes a proposal to reduce the number of parking spaces in the center from 305 to 294. This will improve traffic circulation and meet ADA requirements. A parking study was done to determine if the reduction will negatively impact to the center. The parking study deemed that even if all the vacant store fronts were 2 Administrative Hearing August 9,2012 leased, there would be sufficient parking spaces to accommodate customers. The parking lot enhancement includes the removal of four trees. The applicant is proposing to replant thirteen trees in the parking lot and along the street frontage. The project design is compatible with shopping center, has good onsite improvements, bicycle and pedestrian amenities and has adequate parking. For these reasons, Staff recommends approval of the project. Hearing Officer Shrivastava asked for clarification of where the trees are (on the site) that are scheduled for removal. She asked if the replanted trees would be in one row or two along Homestead Road. She commented that the drive-thru is not ideal, but is the best that can be done with the site and she liked the design of the safe pathways for pedestrians to use while walking through the parking lot. The applicant asked for clarifications on the conditions of approval relating to the parking lot walkways, screening of the mechanical equipment,need for drainage calculations, power transformers and the fire sprinkler requirement. The Hearing Officer reviewed the conditions in question with the applicant. Most of the conditions of approval are standard conditions and are applied "as needed" for specific projects and that wording provides options to applicants to meet the conditions (ie; screening or underground placement). Legal Counsel for the neighboring shopping center owner, Ginger Slotello, spoke that some of the proposed work on the site would violate the CC&R's for the center. She referred to Mr. Faber's letter. She asked for a continuance of the approval of the project until such time as all of the property owners have reached an agreement regarding the proposed off-site changes. Hearing Officer Shrivastava was sympathetic to the concerns of the other property owners of the shopping center, but advised that the off-site improvement requirement for the restaurant were site improvements that would be required by any property owner in the shopping center when/should they propose changes to their parcel. She strongly encouraged both parties to work together to make sure the off-site improvements were installed. The applicant wanted to remove the condition for the off-site improvements in case an agreement could not be reached. The Hearing Officer said that for minor changes they should work together to achieve them and for major changes to the proposal, they would need to apply for a modification to the approval, but that the condition for off-site improvements would remain. The Hearing Officer re-capped that the project is in as good a design as it can be, helps to bring the parcels into conformance with the City's Ordinances, is consistent with the public right-of way improvement requirements and that the number of replacement trees will add a lot to the site. She encouraged the property owners to work together. The application was approved per the draft resolutions. DECISION: The application was approved by the Hearing Officer ADJOURNMENT 5:30pm Respectfully submitted: & 'LPL Beth Ebben Administrative Clerk g:planning/AH Committee/Minutes080912