Loading...
TR-2011-53 to TR-2011-63b OFFlCE OF C�MMUNITY DEVELOPMENT CITY HALL 10300 TORRE AVENUE•CUPERTINO, CA 95014-3255 C U P E RT 1 N O (408) 777-3308• FAX(408)777-3333•planning @cupertino.orq February 10, 2012 Seven Springs HOA Attn: Luis Heredia c/o 1935 Dry Creek Rd#203 Campbell,Ca 95008 , SUBJECT: TIZEE REMOVAL PERMIT ACTION LETTER-Application TR-2011-53 through TR-2011-62: This letter confirms the decision of the Director of Community Development, given on February 10, 2012, approving a tree removal permit to allow the removal and replacement of ten trees, including six (6) Redwood trees (with trunk diameters ran�ing from 21 inches to 32 inches), three (3) Tulip trees (with trunk diameters ran7ing from 15 inches to 17 inches) and one 8-inch diameter Birch tree. The addresses for the tree removal applications are: 11638 Birch Spring Court (TR-2011-62), 11637 Cedar Spring Court (TR-2011-58), 11656 Cedar Spring Court (TR-2011-5�, 11636 Cedar Sprin� Court (TR- 2011-56), 11633 Bridge Park Court (TR-2011-59), 11632 Bridge Park Court (TR-2011-60), 11652 Brid�e Park Court (TR-2011-61), 11627 Cedar Spring Court (TR-2011-55), 11596 Cedar Spring Court (TR-2011- 53) and 11606 Cedar Sprulg Court(TR-2011-54) �vith the following conditions: 1. APPROVED PROTECT This approval is based on the arborist report prepared by David Babby (Certified Master Arborist WE-4001B), dated June 6, 2011, consisting of 24 pages and entitled: Tree Removal Report, A�2 Arborist Review of 16 Trees Proposed for Removal fi•om tlie Seve�i Springs HOA, Cuperti�zo, Califor�7ia, and the tree removal and tree replacement plans submitted by the applicants, except as may be amended by conditions in this resolution. 2. TREE REPLACEMENT The applicants shall plant replacement trees on the properties in accordance with the Tree Replacement Plan submitted by the applicants and the City's Protected Tree Ordinance. The required replacement trees shall be planted within 60 days of the effective approval date of this tree removal permit. 3. PROTECTED TREE COVENANT The applicants shall be required to record covenants recording the replacement trees as protected trees �vithin 30 days of planting the replacement trees in accordance with the City's Protected Trees Ordinance. Failure to do so may result in code enforcement and/or administrative citations. 4. NOTICE OF FEES,DEDICATIONS,RESERVATIONS OR OTHER EXACTIONS The Conditions of Project Approval set forth herein may include certain fees, dedication requirements, reservation requirements, and other exactions. Pursuant to Government Code Section 66020(d) (1), these Conditions constitute written notice of a statement of the amount of such fees, and a description of the dedications, reservations, and other exactions. You are hereby further notified that the 90-day approval period in which you may protest these fees, dedications, reservations, and other exactions, pursuant to Government Code Section 66020(a), has bewn. If you fail to file a protesf tvithin this 90-day period complying with all of the requirements of Section 66020,you will be legally barred from later challengin�such exactions. Staff has made the findings necessary to grant the tree removal permit in accordance with Section 14.18.180 of the Protected Trees Ordinance. Please note, however, that an appeal of this decision can be made within 14 calendar days from the date of the mailing of this decision. If this happens,you s�vill be notified of a public hearing,which will be scheduled before the Planning Commission and the trees cannot be removed until a final decision on the appeal has been made. If no appeal is made svithin the appeal period, the tree(s) may be removed after Friday, February 24,2012. Sincerely, l Aki Honda Snelling,AICP Senior Planner (408) 777-3313 akisQcupertino.org cc: Dilip Venkatachari, 11596 Cedar Spring Ct,Cupertino CA 95014 Hsiou-Chuzg or Jean Long, 11606 Cedar Spring Ct,Cupertino CA 95014 D'unitry Vyshetsky, 11627 Cedar Spring Ct,Cupertino CA 95014 Sze-Jin Tan, 11636 Cedar Spring Ct,Cupertino CA 95014 Seong or Jin Soo Shin, 11656 Cedar Spring Ct,Cupertino CA 95014 Sam Hung, 11637 Cedar Spring Ct,Cupertino CA 95014 Migdat or Alma Hodzic, 11633 Bridge Park Ct,Cupertino CA 95014 Susan Chiu, 11642 Bridge Park Ct,Cupertino CA 95014 Eli or Pnina Engelman, 11652 Bridge Park Ct,Cupertino CA 95014 Howie or Teresa Wang, 11638 Birch Spring Ct,Cupertino CA 95014 Seven Springs Tree Plan See Replacement Tree Map#1 � Pase� Species Repiacement "� v �. �� �-� �� # House No. Dia. Street �-'. ' F �Y ReplaG,ment Tree �°` Removed Size �" �� �"� 2 11638 Birch Spring Ct. Birch 8 1-24"Box in proximaty to removal area Owner's Lot#205 1 Lagerstroemia-Pink C�ape Mirtle Easter Redbud in proximaty to removal area Owner's Lot#208 and Crape Mirtle in Common Area between units 11911/11912 Placer Spring Ct. (#3& 3 11637 Cedar Spring Ct. Redwood 30 2-24"Box #17) 1 Cercis Canadensis-Easter Redbud/1 Lagerstroemia-Pink Crape Mirtle Easter Redbud in proximaty to removal area Owner's Lot#219 and Puple 4 11656 Cedar Spring Ct. Redwood 29 2-24"Box Plum between units 11562/11672 Morning Spring Ct.(#4 8#19) 1 Cercis Canadensis-Easter Redbud/1 Punnus Ceraciofera-Purple Plum Easter Redbud in proximaty 10 removal area Owner's Lot#217 and Crape 5 11636 Cedar Spring Ct. Redwood 31 2-24"Box Mirtle in the common area island at Woodhill Court.(#5&#16) 1 Cercis Canadensis-Easter Redbud/1 Lagerstroemia-Pink Crape Mirtle One in proximaty to removal area Owner's Lot#178 and one one in between 6 11633 Bridge Park Ct. Tulp Tree 16 2-24"Box 11633/11633 Bridge Park Ct:(#6 8#20) 2 Pistacia-Chinese Pistache In proximaty to removal area)Owner's Lot#182 and Crape Mirtle in the 7 11632 Bridge Park Ct. Tulp Tree 17 2-24"Box common area island at Woodhill Court.(#7&#16) 1 Pistacia-Chinese Pistache/1 Lagerstroemia-Pink Crape Mirtle In proximaty to removal area)Owner's Lot#180 and Crape Mirtle in the 8 11652 Bridge Park Ct. Tulp Tree 15 2-24"Box common area island at Woodhill Court.(#8 8�#16) 1 Cercis Canadensis-Easter Redbud/1 Lagerstroemia-Pink Crape Mirtle In proximaty to removal area Owner's Lot#209 and Crape Mirtle in the 11 11627 Cedar Spring Ct. Redwood 31 2-24"Box common area island at Woodhill Court.(#11&#16) 1 Cercis Canadensis-Easter Redbud/1 La erstroemia-Pink Crape Mirtle In proximaty to removal area Owner's Lot#213 and One one in common 12 11596 Cedar Spring Ct. Redwood 21 2-24"Box area at Bridge Park CL(#12'&#18) 2 Acer Rubrom-Red Ma le In proximaty to removal area Owner,s Lot#214 and Crape Mirtle in the 13 11606 Cedar Spring Ct. Redwood 32 2-24"Box common area island at Woodhill Court.(#13&#16) 1 Cercis Canadensis-Easter Redbud f 1 Lagerstroemia-Pink Crape Mirtle Island at Woodhil 11911/1191 2Placer Bridge Park Court 11562/11572 Mornir 11643/11633 Bridpe Court 3 Spring Court Park Court See Replacement Tree M Replacement Additional Trees-See M�p for locationa 5ize 5-24"box In Common Area in the Parking Area Island 1-24"box In Common Area between units.11911 &11912 1-24"box Playground in the Common�Area near Pla gound 1-24"box An additional tree between Owner's units 1-24"box An additional tree between Owner's units #2 5 Lagersfroemia-Pink Crape Mirtle 1 Lagerstroemia-Pink Crape Mirtle 2 Acer Rubrom-Red Ma le 1 Prunnus Ceracifera-Purple Plum 1 Pistacia-Chinese Pistache ; ,. -�.��,� -�'�—,�c�l l".5,�__?�� ��='��rr�`��:��r � �o_�l ,-, . . ,� t _. Cr %�� ��-� Seven Springs Tree Plan See Replacement Tree Map#1 Page 1 # House No. Species p�a Replacement Street Replacment Tree Removed Size 1 11651 Timber Spring Ct. Redwood 25 2-24"Box Two in proximaty to removal area in Common Area(#1 &#15) 2 Prunnus Ceracifera-Purple Plum 2 11638 Birch Spring Ct. Birch 8 1-24"Box in proximaty to removal area Owner's Lot#205 1 Lagerstroemia-Pink Crape Mirtle Easter Redbud in proximaty to removal area Owner's Lot#208 and Crape Mirtle in Common Area between units 11911!11912 Placer Spring Ct. (#3& 3 11637 Cedar Spring Ct. Redwood 30 2-24"Box #17) 1 Cercis Canadensis-Easter Redbud/1 Lagerstroemia-Pink Crape Mirtle Easter Redbud in proximaty to removal area Owner's Lot#219 and Puple 4 11656 Cedar Spring Ct. Redwood 29 2-24"Box Plum between units 11562/11672 Morning Spring Ct.(#4&#19) 1 Cercis Canadensis-Easter Redbud/1 Punnus Ceraciofera-Purple Pium Easter Redbud in proximaty to removal area Owner's Lot#217 and Crape 5 1 1636 Cedar Spring Ct. Redwood 31 2-24"Box Mirtle in the common area island at Woodhill Court.(#5&#16) 1 Cercis Canadensis-Easter Redbud/1 Lagerstroemia-Pink Crape Mirtle One in proximaty to removal area Owner's Lot#178 and one one in between 6 1 1633 Bridge Park Ct. Tulp Tree 16 2-24"Box 11633/11633 Bridge Park Ct.(#6&#20) 2 Pistacia-Chinese Pistache In proximaty to removal area)Owner's Lot#182 and Crape Mirtle in the 7 11632 Bridge Park Ct. Tulp Tree 17 2-24"Box common area isiand at Woodhill Court.(#7&#16) 1 Pistacia-Chinese Pistache I 1 Lagerstroemia-Pink Crape Mirtle In proximaty to removal area)Owner's Lot#180 and Crape Mirtle in the 8 11652 Bridge Park Ct. Tulp Tree 15 2-24"Box common area island at Woodhill Court.(#8&#16) 1 Cercis Canadensis-Easter Redbud/1 Lagerstroemia-Pink Crape Mirtle IOne in proximaiy to removal In Common Area adjacent to Lot#202 and one 9 11ti:J8 Birch Spring Ct. Redwood 27 2-24"Box in common area at Bridge Park Ct.(#9&#18) 2 Acer Rubrom-Red Maple One in proximaty to removal area Owner's Lot#174 and one common area 10 115d8 Copper Spring Ct. Pine 25 2-24"Box between 1 1 692/1 1693 Vinyard Spring Ct.(#10&#14) 2 Lagerstroemia-Pink Crape Mirtle In proximaty to removal area Owner's Lot#209 and Crape Mirtie in the 11 11627 Cedar Spring Ct. Redwood 31 2-24"Box common area island at Woodhill Court.(#11 &#16) 1 Cercis Canadensis-Easier Redbud/1 Lagerstroemia-Pink Crape Mirtle In proximaty to removal area Owner's Lot#213 and One one in common 12 11596 Cedar Spring Ct. Redwood 21 2-24"Box area at Bridge Park Ct.(#12&#18) 2 Acer Rubrom-Red Maple In proximaty to removal area Owner;s Lot#214 and Crape Mirtle in the 13 11606 Cedar Spring Ct. Redwood 32 2-24"Box common area island at Woodhill Court.(#13 8�#16) 1 Cercis Canadensis-Easter Redbud/1 Lagerstroemia-Pink Crape Mirtle 11692l11693 Vinyard Spring Court 11651Timber Spring Court Island al Woodhil 11911/1191 2Placer Spring Court Bridge Park Court 11562/11572 Morning Spring Court 11643/11633 Bridqe Park Court � See Replacement Tree Map#2 Replacement Additional Trees-See Map for locations Size 1-24"box In the Common Area between units 11692&11693 1 Lagerstroemia-Pink Crape Mirtle 1-24"box In the Common area adjacent to unit 11651 1 Prunnus Ceracifera-Purple Plum 5-24"box In Common Area in the Parking Area Island 5 Lagerstroemia-Pink Crape Mirtle 1-24"box In Common Area between units 11911 &11912 1 Lagerstroemia-Pink Crape Mirtle 2-24"box Playground in the Common Area near Playgound 2 Acer Rubrom-Red Maple 1-24"box An additional tree between Owner's units ���� � �`����''�"���� f�^ �''� . 1�P�����era '��'{�iu€ti=� �� 1-24"box An additional tree between Owner's units 1 Pistacia- hinese Pistache io "- I 4�°�� r ? �`.1.�� / ����.j�f����. f e� 1a �. � � � � � � �. � � �' .� � � � � � w , '� ,1�;�ri i � - r; � I i `� � �_ � � ' ` ,,, �:-� �, .� U-� U� ti� � � ��L �" - = c� ,,� .,�, �-� ,�, in ,.L �� �' .--� .--i � <_ 1..L -�—Zo/�—5� �o --.._. ._,..a. ,�� � r���-�� . . _ _ T �.�.�._ _��.�.�. . ....__.�.,�...� f r.���;J^.t�l� '`�:�.�:��s� , . ��f � _ ;..; � _ ,_ ______ � �r__ _ ��r=;I r��,�.,,��� o ��? 1� j � -,�" ; i �c.l� �LC.•'I1 � � ( �1���J 11J.��_I L1_�lU �1C�U L1�SJ 1�J � ]� 1C 1 I � `- — ' 1]S1� ,i,j 11�1� ll57J 1 t1510 n 1150�� _ 1150�� 115t�? / � '1,J "�4 7` .'9�i J� J�• . f �15�-' - � �1=��1 ' � 11�20 ll51a �? +- 1151; 11511 !� � 11,`� � Jv� �� JQ �cj J �-- J� `� `fJ� -,f �'1.LtY ! 1 �"� 'niir,i�;^G,�, �,-, t j �(I 1152G � �115�8 ;-,- .°�; ]l���c 175_1 �� 115 � 1,.c �i �;i f c � I i -•P,Ih1i� � C T :�% �f;, _= "1 � c�, 5_� �Z= C:_� �1 � .`� �.�I�� ' �I J_ l.J � �L �`�' � -_- - a- - -�- , l�_�•� . - �� - 1 r�� �- � � ,� ,-�_ - . _ I�<.� ��'-� � '� �, � _ t j� - ��� �� �,� �����5 'i f ''�.;.,�. ; , ; ..-. _, '` ��L` � til� ���'i � � '�1�.\�-; �'�' � ';- _� �,r- I �"- % �-� —� (_ .i• L=_• C � FT .� �� T1 1- � �� ' �'�i 3 / j � <�i)�\-``� . ` '.�� � �LS._�J1 I _T S� .Lll�` r'� �� �� �� - + I�� r ^� � ✓ 1� � il�J i `'� �J '�J. �li- ��ca 1��J �1t -� - ,. � � �in �.-I � r r 17�^ 1� 1�.��-� -- 1 1. 4r°,,`� �..�'�� ' . ,��,��.� l.;-�` �.' I -1 � � �� � l� � •�.I� , - � ��•, � f��� ."� �- i • � �"' --I I i,�.•'• e1��: ( �� � `'�,' / ���1C� Er"f'`' I zj�``-' r-+ 1 �- It ��j L l L \ � �t .rS i .� � . r. ..., ^�r� I ^ �I I 1'��J �1�� �� '���f^��Oi �� (' � r.� \� '• '�� �lJ l —�i�'— _ �,� • )� !—� ! �3 � L� ����_.� ��� r �,=� _�11���1 : i_ i �, ,.,.>`,;� �-�� .;{,F �. . ' � ��:�. J`��_ =:F'R.IlJ�� C:1, �:_��� ��__1:_.--�� 14,� l,�,���;i- '� �`,,:!� '�,_�� ,;.\, � r ';"�,-'r-�i:��� �� �t �i �'I I � �.1_ — I ir�� )�� t-^� ` �Jl�i���r :_�� ` :/l' 11. I ^�I I I 1}1,i: 1 _ �� ���I�'---'� ' j �1'� ,� ._ � r�� .. —�-% � � -'� � � �=; �:L, i ��i r-;,J Jr�,-�-,;�,,;i �--.+-, ,�,��, % ;;� '.,f'r ; � , � �^ ��� � ;-��� 11'�-� - -� .� > >a - ,_ l . � . ,�`:J ��[ � �'� -r?,`,C .r ���� : ,�ti T ; ^, � � 4 t. �� y._�I. ..-�. �. ��a_�-=. co r- .� ,-�� �--/(� µr i 1;11 �-_L'�'� �' �� . 11' J -� -�� '��C11._ ��j� L,.a17 T�� .:1�jrJ.. /^ �,�. I 1� J}�� ,• i ' ' � �t�' -� — IL�� �1A=I �i\.�.��. �c� (`� W I I� j1t'-'--o-i I 1'j t�:�t I C]--j�' �•�, . . . ; :•,�� 1, I':"1 l.. j''}��� , i_I 1•��Y'� � :.1� ' �'-� l�F��� 1�.GI�:� 1��6 •[, � ,._; l �'1�� t,I te ' � �_——. .,�, ��_:� '�1�0o Pi]�,:j; �a,, I � `�`'' 1141� (' .�llt�1�3 lik� � ll�, I J :.i � / - � .__.,r \''.} ���ti':- �. . .- i \ 'r.�-����.�� �h_��� C���-� r�11�. -_ j i ,,�,; ., �� ,a_. :��F;�\f'( < �, �`���.�� r'�;.,+� 1 \< ; �_ ��. :;��, �c��`',cr�; ,.� j,. � l,� �.��l 2'��j� .''�_';\\, , G � � _`��__�� : � -/p --- ;-��:� , , . u_ . '_. _ .�/.�_.,1���,.� ._���..��r�a -_ �;.,:�.�. ; — "�/� t �� _ . � � � � � � � � � �� � � � 1 � 1 � � 1� � Ct. � � � DaF: N�EaDO�.i �- � P��k n ��c � �_ � �� � � 7� � / �' .� .� / � ,� . �- , 1 ►L ��-�!� '�� � ,_ _ � .: � �// �� , _ __ _ _ . ._:�,.r. ; .'� �, J.'��IJiI �L.✓.IIG�� .__. . ,�-/,� _ �� , , ,� � _ ; L �, . �'. . �'� � / �\ � � UUU 1�AY 8UB8 AO s �� Y OR�(S�iR E�t WEYF40TH OR � CHNt3 � � � � � � ARBOR RESOLIRCES _ _ professional consulting arborists and tree care TREE REMOVAL REPORT AN ARBORIST REVIEW OF 16 TREES PROPOSED FOR REMOVAL FROM THE SEVEN SPRINGS HOA CUPERTINO, CALIFORNIA Submitted to: Aki Honda Snelling Community Development Department City of Cupertino 10300 Torre Avenue Cupertino, CA 95014 R�'C��;�VA,L ��/��,�3 '�ru - /-l';:,�,�lG8.:1�'y.�r�!�-(0� ...,.�., pr::�.�..'�� , �'" ._.� _:G'.- ('! _ _.r-.�. .,.. � ,. i _ �; � .........>-.� _.._ .......�wL .. ..,.�. _ .._:..,..:..:_» Prepared by: ` � � ' David L. Babby Registered Consulting Arborist° #399 Boa�•d-Certified Master A�°bo�•ast#WE-4001B June 6, 2011 p.o. box 25295, san mateo, california 94402 ■ email: arborresources@comcast.net �hone: 650.654.335 I ■ fax: 650.240.0777 ■ licensed contractor #796763 David L. Babby, Registered Consulting Arbo�•ist° Ju�ae 6, 2011 TABLE OF CONTENTS SECTION TITLE PAGE 1.0 INTRODUCTION .............................................................................. 1 2.0 TREE COUNT AND COMPOSITION ............................................... 2 3.0 SUITABILITY FOR PRESERVATION ................................................3 4.0 FINDINGS AND OBSERVATIONS .................................................. 4 4.1 Tree #1 ............................................................................................... 5 4.2 Tree #2 ................................................................................................ 5 4.3 Trees #3, 5, 7, 8, 11 a n d 12 ............................................................. 6 4.4 Trees #9 and 10 ................................................................................. 6 4.5 Trees #4, 6 and 16 ............................................................................ 7 4.6 Trees #13, 14 and 15 ........................................................................ 7 5.0 TREE REPLACEMENTS ................................................................... 7 EXHIBITS EXHIBIT TITLE A TREE INVENTORY TABLE B SITE MAP (shows tree numbers and trunk locations) C PHOTOGRAPHS (includes photo index) -- i David L. Babby, Registered Consulti��g A�•boristR Jur�e 6, 2011 1.0 INTRODUCTION I have been retained by the City of Cupertino Community Development Department to review the proposed removal of 16 trees from various locations within the Seven Springs HOA; Cupertulo. Specific tasks performed are as follo��s: ■ Review the following documents (not dated) provided with the removal application: a spreadsheet identifying the general locations of 16 trees, and a map showing the general locations of 15 trees. ■ Visit the site on May 27, 2011, and identify each tree proposed for removal. ■ Measure each tree's trunk diameter at 54 inches above grade or where appropriate to best represent trunk size; diameters are rounded to the nearest inch. ■ Estimate each tree's canopy spread. ■ Ascertain each tree's health and structural integrity, and assign an overall condition rating (e.g. good, fair; poor or dead). ■ Rate each tree's suitability for preservation (e.g. high, moderate, or low). ■ Identify whether any of the trees are regarded as "protected trees" and "specimen trees" per City Code. ■ Obtained photographs of each tree; these can be viewed in Exhibit C. ■ Assign nuinbers to each tree in the order encountered during my site visit. ■ Show the assigned tree numbers on a copy of the site map provided for rny review; see Exhibit B. ■ Identify numbers found engraved on round, aluminum tags affixed to 15 of the trees' trunks (all but the large valley oak). ■ Present findings as to whether the proposed removals conform to City Code. ■ Consider the species, size and amount of trees required for installation to mitigate trees to be removed. ■ Prepare a written report containing the aforementioned information, and email it as a PDF document. � Sever�Spri»gs HOA, Cupertino Page 1 of 8 City of Cupe��tino Comn7unity Develop�nent Depart�nent David L. Babby, Registe�•ed Consulting A�•bo�•istR June 6, 2011 2.0 TREE COUNT AND COMPOSITION Sixteen (16) trees of six various species are proposed for removal, and are sequentially numbered as 1 thru 16. The table below identifies their names, assigned numbers, counts and percentages. . %OF NAME TREE NUMBER S COUNT TOTAL aleppo pine 2 1 6% coast redwood 3, 5, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12 8 50% Italian aider 6, 16 2 13% tulip tree 13, 14, 15 3 19% valley oak 1 1 6% white birch 4 1 6% Total 16 100% Snecific information regarding each tree is presented within the table in Exhibit A. The trees' approximate locations can be viewed on the site map in Exhibit B, and uhoto�raphs of each tree are presented in Exhibit C. Based on the site, it is assumed that all trees presented herein were planted or retained as part of a previously approved and plaiuied developinent. As such, the trees can be considered regulated and defined as "protected trees" pursuant to Section 14.18.035(C) of the City Code. Tree #12, a redwood located at 11637 Cedar Spring Court, is identified on the table reviewed but not the map; its approximate location is plotted on the map in Exhibit B. Seve��Springs HOA, Cupertri�o Page 2 of 8 City of Cupe�•tino Conz�nu�7ity Developmer�t Department David L. Babby, Register•ed Consulting A�•borist� June 6, 2011 Tree #1 can be described as a massive and ancient valley oak with a 63-inch trunk diameter, an estimated 110-foot canopy spread, and a roughly estiinated age of 350 plus years. It is defined as a "specimen tree" pursuant to Appendix B of Ordinance No. 07- 2003. Additionally, due its species, size and age, it seenungly meets the intent and purpose of Section 14.18.040 of the City Code to potentially qualify as a"heritage tree." 3.0 SUITABILITY FOR TREE PRESERVATION Each tree has been assigned a "high," "moderate" or "low�' suitability for preservation rating as a method to cumulatively measure t]Zeir health, structural ultegrity, anticipated life span, location, size and specie type. Descriptions of these ratings are presented below. High: Applies to trees #3, 5, 7 and 11 (four in total). These trees have seemingly stable structures, appear in overall good health, and present a high potential of contributing long-tenn to the site. Moderate: Applies to trees #1, 2, 8, 9, 10 and 12 (six in total). These trees contribute to the site but seemingly at insignificant levels. Their longevity and contribution is less than those of high suitability, and more frequent care is needed during their remaining life span. Low: Applies to trees #4, 6, 13, 14, 15 and 16 (six in total). These trees are the least suitable for retention due to being predisposed to decline andlor structural defects that are expected to worsen regardless of tree care measures employed. Trees #4 and 16 are dead. Seve�7 Springs HOA, Cupertino Page 3 of 8 City of Cuperti��o Con�»�unit��Develop»�ent Depart»lent David L. Babby, Registered ConsultingA�•boristR Ju�ae 6, 2011 4.0 FINDINGS AND OBSERVATIONS Pursuant to Section 14.18.18 of the City Code (RevieN� and Deter»zination of Application), one of the following three findings must be established for issuing a tree removal permit: 1. That the tree or trees are irreversibly diseased, are in danger of falling, can cause potential damage to existing or proposed essential sti-uctures, or interferes with private on-site utility services and caiulot be controlled or remedied through reasonable relocation or modification of the structure or utility services. 2. That the location of the trees restricts the economic enj oyment of the property by severely limiting the use of property in a manner not typically experienced by owners of sirnilarly zoned and situated properiy, and that the applicant has demonstrated to the satisfaction of the approval authority that there are no reasonable alternatives to preserve the tree(s). 3. That the protected tree(s) are a detriment to the subject property and cannot be adequately supported according to good urban forestry practices due to the overpla.nting or overcrowding of trees on the subject property. Based on my review of findings and observations, I offer the following conclusions: a. Trees #2, 4, 6, 13, 14, 15 and 16 (seven in total) adhere to criteria provided in finding number one. b. Trees #1, 3, 5, 7, 8, 11 and 12 (seven in total) do not ineet the findings, and initigation appears reasonable. c. Trees #9 and 10 (tvvo in total) also do not seemingly meet the findings, but further review of whether repair of damaged entry walkways is reasonable could possibly be considered. Seven Sprrngs HOA, Cupertir�o Page 4 of 8 City of Cuperti��o Comnaunit}�Developmen.t Departn�e��t David L. Babby, Registered Consulti��g ArboristR June 6, 2011 A more detailed description and explanation of how fuldings apply to each tree follow in this section. 4.1 Tree #1 (valley oak in the park along Silver Spring Court) This massive oak does not seem to clearly meet any of the three findings, particularly when considering the following: its size, historic age, healthy appearance, potential future longevity for many years, and location a��ay from any inunediate or constantly used targets. The tree does show signs of having potentially partially uprooted, an event likely occuning from excessive weight distribution on the side of the lean. This event appears to have happened nuinerous years ago, and the tree (as trees can do) may be adapting to the shift of weight by larger a�d more expansive root growth on the side opposite the lean. Consequently, it potentially has andlor can in the upcoming years become stabilized. Based on my evaluation and existing conditions beneath the tree, any irninediately concei-n can likely be reasonably mitigated, such as employing a strategic and selective removal of large limbs from the canopy's south side (this likely wanants a perniit), and iilstalling a fence to restrict access within striking distance of the tree. All pruning shall be performed under the direct supervision of an ISA (International Society of Arboriculture) certified arborist, in accordance with the most recent ANSI A300 standards, and by a California state-licensed tree service contractor (D-49 classification). 4.2 Tree #2 (Aleppo pine at 11548 Copper Spring Court) Finding number one does seem to apply due to the tree's structure and location in striking distance of the adjacent home. The tree is comprised of two leaders that currently form a Seve»Springs HOA, Cuperti��o Page�of 8 City�of Cupertino Co�nmunity Develop�nen.t Depart»rent David L. Babby, Registered ConsultingArbo��istR Ju��e 6, 2011 fairly weak attachznent that will continue to present a greater risk of failure during the tree's remaining lifespan. 4.3 Trees#3. 5, 7. 8. 11 and 12 (coast redwoods at various locations) These six redwoods do not seetn to clearly meet any of the three findings. Any evident damage at this time appears confined to surrounding hardscape, and can likely be repaired by shaving down andlor patching raised edges. I observed no damage to nearby structures, and am tulaware of any damage to utilities (and if there is datnage, whether it could not be mitigated). Coast redwoods have relatively fast growrth rates and large trunks, particularly at their bases. As such, they are inore ideally planted away from hardscape and foundations to avoid potential damage. For the six trees mentioned herein, they are not ideally located, and there is the potential for future, more significant or realized datnage to surrounding driveways andlor possibly (and to a much lesser degree) home foundations. However, continued or ulcreased repair work would seemingly provide reasonable correction and not warrant removal. Also, their location does not, in my experience, differ or severely limit the use of property in a manner not typically experienced by owners of similar property. 4.4 Trees#9 and 10 (coast redwoods along Cedar Spring Court) These two redwoods may, but not clearly, meet finding number two. They have roots appearing to contribute to the lifting of nearby entry walkways. Particularly for tree #10, they are raised rather significantly, and inore entailed repair work would be needed to reestablish the walk to grade. Given the distances of the walk to the trees' trunks, root pruning appears feasible without adversely impacting the trees. Additional work includes super-reinforcing the new section of walkways, possible reconfiguration, and pouring and Seven Spri�7gs HOA, Cupertino Page 6 of 8 Cit��of Cuperti�zo Commurrity Developnae��t Depm�tnae��t David L. Babby, Registered Co�isulti��g A�•borist� Ju��e 6, 2011 foniung them on-grade without using base materials (and thus, reducing the amount of root pruning needed). 4.5 Trees#4, 6 and 16 (white birch and two italian alders, respectively} These trees strongly conform to finding number one. Trees #4 and 16 are dead, and tree #6 is declining and has partially uprooted in the direction of the adjacent residence at 11709 Olive Spring Court. They should be removed immediately. 4.6 Trees#13, 14 and 15 (tulip trees along Bridge Park Court) These trees meet finding number one. Each has been excessively pruned to unprofessional standards over the years, and consequently, their structure is prone to large limb and branch failure during the course of their remaining lifespan. Regarding the reported sap problein, tulip trees, in general, become severely infested with aphids, and controls to reduce the aphid population (and thus the amount of sap) include a minunutn aru�ual treatinent prescribed and employed by a qualified professional. 5.0 TREE REPLACEMENTS Applying Table A, Section 14.18.185 of the City Code, a total of either eleven trees of 24- inch box size or nine trees of 24-inch box size and one tree of 36-inch box size would be installed to mitigate removal of trees #2, 4, 6, 13, 14, 15 and 16. The specific species and location of each new tree can be evaluated upon request. As a general rule, I suggest new trees are installed in the same general location of those being removed to maintain overall consistency with the landscape planting plan approved for the existing development. Guidelines for helping deternune an appropriate species and Seven Springs HOA, Cupe�•tino Page 7 of 8 City of Cupe�•ti��o Comn�u�7iry Developme�zt Depa�•tn�e��t Dm�id L. Babby, Registered Consulting Arborist� Ju�7e 6, 2011 locations include a tree's grow-th rate, size at maturity, growrth habit, suitability for a parking lot envirorunent, anticipated life span, susceptibility to insects and diseases, root invasiveness, and proximity to hardscape and buildings. For trees installed within lawn or planter areas along Cedar Spring Court, a tree species more appropriate for planting near hardscape could ser��e to substitute installing any additional coast redwoods (as a means to extend the life expectancy of surrounding hardscape before repair is needed). All new trees should be installed, including necessary irrigation, by an experienced state- licensed landscape contractor or a professional tree company, and perforined to professional industry standards. They should be double-staked (no cross-brace) with rubber tree ties or equivalent, and the support stakes cut below the first main lateral branch; where this is not feasible for a low-branching tree, the stakes should be established in a manner that avoids damaging the trunlc and branches. All in-igation should be in the form of a bubbler-type system placed on the surface of the root ball (versus against the trunk or in a sleeve). Prepared By: • Date: June 6. 2011 David L. Babby Registered Consulting Arbo�•ist°#399 Board-Certified Master Arbo��ist�WE-4001 B t , i.�;. '`{�`��j;��� �� Sere�7 Springs HOA, Cupertir7o Page 8 of 8 Cit��of Cupertirlo Coi��n�uniry Development Depart�ne�zt Dcnmid L. Babby, Registered Consulting Arbo�•is{� June 6, 2011 EXHIBIT A: TREE INVENTORY TABLE Seven Spr•irrgs HOA, Cupertino City of Cuperti»o Con��nu�7ity Develo�naent Depart»�ent ARBOR RES4LIRCES _ professional consulting arborists and tree care TREE INVENTORY TABLE � � h � ; _ >, 3 �3 � � `. _ � � L � � — U U � � �^ ._ U q ;� . 'J �, � = - c3 �J r _ ✓; — � = U _ .� = U � � `" �cy .�^ ^ n � ,� �"J M � M � \ ^ � TREE TAG � _ � � � � _ ' o � = — � � J ,., � .. ,_ oL NO. N0. TREE NAME �= ' � — ' — o > — ✓1 — ✓� �i � ;%;� valley oa}: 1 - (Oue�•cus Iobata) 63 110 75% 2�% Fair Moderate Address: Silver Spring Court(in park) Comments: Healthy tree of 350 plus years o]d. Root colla�•«�as cleared,but substantia] soi]remains bound to roots and lo���er trunk,and as such,limits examination.Observed three cavities that«�ere fi]]ed«�ith concrete manv ��ears ago,all located in the lo���er trunk's���est side. There is indication of the tree having partially uprooted, and the tree functioning to stabilize itself. The lean is an estimated 10-to 15-degre.es to«ards the south��-here ��eiQht is most heavily concentrated.which likely caused a shift,but based on the limited visibility of the root area.and that there appears to be no immediate targets«�ithin striking distance,it does not appear significant. Measures can be taken to help reduce the risk,such as strategic and selective removal of major limbs on the side of the lean,and installing a fence to restrict pedestrian traffic. Based on the size,species,and ancient aQe of the tree.the benefits and measures tal:en for its preser�-ation seemingly ouh��ei�h the tree's risk. La���n for the park is favorab]y setback from trunk for healthy root growth,althouQh,added���ood chips manually spread over the ground��-ould provide benefits. Aleppo pine 2 642 (Pir�us I7alepensis) 25 30 75% �0% Fair Moderate Address: 11548 Copper Spring Court(front yard.north side of home) Comments: Trunl:is situated about five feet from home's foundation.and tllree feet from a��-ood retaininQ wall. Comprised of a main trunk that divides into rivo leaders at about five feet high,and those]eaders form some���hat of a�veak attachment that ti��ill��orsen as the tree ages. The tree is infested���ith pitch moth larvae, a pathogen that does not harni the tree(it is not infested with bores). Tree appears in orerall good health. coast red��ood 3 620 (Sequoia senzpervirens) 27 25 7�% 75% Good High Address: 11608 Birch Spring Court(north side of home,closest one to backyard) Comments: Canopy is asymmetrical due to heavy pruning of section overhanging backya�•d. Base of trun}:is about 2.5 feet from property fence a��d ten feet from foundation. No indication of damage to foundation,Uackyard patio.or fence was observed or evident. Future da.mage to fence and patio ca��likely be mitigated���ithout removine tree. Site:Seven Springs HOA, Cupertino Prepared for:Ciry of Cupertino Comm.Develop.Depart. Prepared by:David L.Babby � 1 of4 June 6,2011 ARBOR RESOLIRCES _ _ professional consulting arborists and tree care TREE INVENTORY TABLE � � �� _ ^, 3 �3 ^ �= � � ; = � ��,� � — _ � o � •- � � — U 7 - v �v _ i \..� r 'l. � '!. � � - f� ^ � � J � � "� `J ,^7 �� � C+ ,:3 V �� � �� - � _ .0 TREE TAG s _ � - _ � _ � � �' ' � � � `-' U � � 04 NO. NO. TREE NA1�9E — .< � " ` ` " , � �' :r .% O �' :% white birch 4 1119 (Betula pe�zdula) 8 - 0% 25% Dead Lo��, Address: 11638 Birch Spring Court(front yard,south side of propert}�.near oaraee) Comments: Tree is 90-percent dead and should be immediately removed. coast red���ood 5 404 (Sequoia se»zpen�ire�u) 25 35 100% ]00% Good High Address: 11651 Timber Spring Court(north side of home) Comments: Base of trunk is aUout eight feet from home's foundation. No evident damage to foiu�dation observed. Italian alder 6 1205 (Abzus cordata) ]2 30 25% 25% Poor Low Address: 11699 Olive Spring Court(front yard,south side of drive���ay) Comments: Canopy is sparse but not dead. There is a possibility for it to recover,ho���ever,it���ill likely continue to decline. The more immediate concern is the indication that the tree has partially uprooted in the direction and striking distance of the home at the adjacent 11709 address;it should be immediately removed. coast red���ood 7 1067 (Seguoia sempervire�u) 29 35 75% 75% Good High Address: 11656 Cedar Spring Court(in front yard,north side of drive���ay) Comments:No demonstrable evidence revie���ed or observed of damage to major utilities,nor that any damage could not be reasonably mitigated. Driveway is raised less than an inch,and could seeminaly be repaired by beina sha��ed do���n and/or patched. Roots are surfaced and abut pier for adjacent mailboxes and light pole. Area drain has shifted due to root/trunl:expansion. coast red�a�ood 8 1070 (Sequoiasempe�vi�•e�u) 31 35 50% 75% Fair Moderate Address: 11636 Cedar Spring Court(front yard,north side of drive«�ay) Comments: Has a spa�•se canopy due seemingly to insufficient���atering. No damage to surrounding hardscape observed. Site:Seven Springs HOA, Cupertino Prepared for:City of Cupertino Comm.Develop.Depart. Prepared by:David L.Babby 2 of4 June 6,2011 ARBOR RESOLIRCES _, _ professional consulting arbonsts and tree care TREE INVENTORY TABLE _ � �= �� � - -� > :'J L ^ _ ^ 3 �3 ` � ,, � � o G ° aD= - c _ � U :7 - v U � - � ^ l-/ � ✓ �, l \ � :J =7 � ;' C .+ - U .. '" ^ ^+M �j �3 ... � � " `� II `� il — '— _ � TREE TAG 1 ^ � = _ � � � � �,�, � _ = U ;y � ^� C j C ...� DIJ NO. NO. TREE NAME — �: `' —° — - — ' �— _ — v_ ;i� G `� ✓; coast red«�ood 9 1107 (Seguoiasenzpeivire�u) 3l 35 �0% 75% Fair Moderate Address: 11627 Cedar Spring Court(front yard,north side of dri��e«�ay) Comments: Has a sparse canopy due seeminely to insufficient���atering. Entry«�alk 5.5 feet from trun}c is raised by about three inches due to roots. It could seemingly be repaired,root pruning employed,and the ne�v��a1k super-reinforced.set and poured on soil grade(a no-dig design). There is a surface root that gro���s along and sliQhtly o�er dri��e«�ay. coast red���ood 10 1076 (Sequoiasempe�vire�zs) 32 40 50% 75% Fair Moderate Address: 11606 Cedar Spring Court(front yard.north side of dri�e�e�ay) Comments: Entry walk eight feet from trunk is dramatically raised by about six inches due to roots. The��.alk could possibly be reapired as discussed for tree#9. Sparse canopy seemingly due to insufficient���atering. coast redwood 11 1080 (Sequoi.asemper-virerzs) 21 30 100% 75% Good Hieh Address: 11596 Cedar Spring Court(north side of driveway,near fence at property line) Comments: Entry��valk four feet from trunk is slightly raised by surface roots,and can seemingly be repaired. coast red���ood 12 1111 (Sequoiasempervirens) 30 35 �0% 7�% Fair Moderate Address: 11637 Cedar Spring Court(front��ard.south side of dm�eway) Comments: Substantial levels of branch dieback.indicative of infection Uy a fungal disease named Botr}�osphaeria. Pruning of infected branches(and sanitation of the tools)is the recommended mitigation to potentially reduce future infection. Drive�i�ay four feet from trunk is raised by less than one-inch,and can likely be repaired. Site:Seven Springs HOA, Cupertino Prepared for:City of Cupertino Comm.Develop.Depart. — Prepared by:David L.Babby 3 of4 June 6,2011 ARBOR RES4LIRCES _ _ professional consultmg arborists and tree care TREE INVENTORY TABLE � 'l. 'J, , ` .J. .r.i .ri � � � _ :, 3 �� c f � ,. � _ _ � � � � ;, o ;,L c _ - _ U U :3 � V J ` '� � iy- � � r � s � - � 7 -O p � _ V J •,' Ac.. � , v � �� , �I - � = G TREE TAG 1 _ � � � � � " o r NO. NO. TREE NA1�1L r: ' ,; `—' .f; —° � �: ,,_. � tulip tree 13 898 (Liriode�zd�•on tulipifera) 1� 20 �0% 25% Poor Lo��� Address: 11652 Bridge Park Gourt(front yard,north side of drive«�ay) Comments: Tree has been excessively pruned in past(not in accordance�a�ith professional industry standards),a factor causing its now��ery poor structure. Over 60°%of its lo���er canop}'«�as removed(canopy severely elevated). tulip tree 14 899 (Liriode�zdrora tulipifera) 17 30 �0% 50% Fair Lo��� Address: 11632 Bridge Park Co�rt(front}ard bet�i�een l 1632 and 11642 addresses) Comments: This tree has been e�:cessively pruned���here it overhangs la��-n,and as such,has created a highly asymmetrical canopy and���eak structure. The structure is further��eakened by being comprised of multiple,competing leaders. The table provided for my review identifies the tree to be at the 11642 address;ho���ever,it appears to be in fi•ont of 11632,and is identified as such in this report. tulip tree 15 956 (Liriodendron tulipifera) 16 30 �0% 7�% Fair Low Address: 11633 Bridge Park Court(front yard,la���n area) Comments: Has a sparse and excessively pruned ca��opy. Also,entire tree]eans west to�e�ards home. Roots are Qro«-ing around and enveloping area drain. Italian alder 16 1886 (Ab7us cordata) l 2 - 0% 0% Dead Lo�� Address: 18853 Shasta Spring Court(front yard,north side of dri�e���ay) Comments: Tree is dead and should be immediately removed. Has significant borer damase. Site:Seven Springs HOA, Cupertino Prepared for:City of Cupertino Comm.Develop.Depart. , Prepared by:David L.Babby 4 of4 June 6,2011 Dcn�id L. Babby, Registered Consulting Arborisf� June 6, 2011 EXHIBIT B: SITE MAP Se>>e�1 Spri��gs HOA, Cuperti��o City of Cu�e�•tino Connaauniry Developmei�t Departme�7t SEVEN SPRINGS HOA Cupertino, California �,�. ,` _ � � � � � � � � � Z RANBOW � 3e flFaYE I370 ?'#35U 2�30 2'(31Q 21�'4D 2►7D Z't25U 21Z9J Z4"1"A Z1196 `iSTO r 2t250 Y13D t5{3 .��� *Sii tl�19 1'6rJ9 1SOB 1t5u7 1t5a5 r6o�G 1�6a3 7uC2 �1507 i � 0 tt�Z2 "tSZi i'�2a �StS t5T8 t'SS7 415'� :5i[ 4'fit3 S$92 i�71 � � it532 tfS31 tT3D tL529 'fi529 4f�.27 4s525 752� 1t523 55527 4i5?7 � m a � "t538 fii�37 �9ss�pS R�1�! D4K t'�ADDAf CT i ,mn '17552 tt55i r� `q ¢ �y T�'c vy j�� .^� 7�c� '� : � � `� „ r ,E�' 3 �i 't56z nso� '�� o, � � ,' t sJ^pc, 's��yh'� �s2 w� . S�Z 115 r 1 ♦ 4 h� �� 97 �Q '� .C? b� c � 15bZ 11581 i�v,�q 7jSj6 � I ���6��,`,� � ` �y �� '`��. i o 1`3Y2 tt5A1 ,�E?� �[.i 4°s �'C� +�`•,` `S0� '- �, � .o"- iiGP2 ��1 '�'� 'g9 � �+ � � ttEt2 St6t1 � Sa99 b 'L95 4't531 ��4� 2 c1 � � o � �t� 11b21 ��.�j '11fi�9 1i!DB if6II7 '�5602 11f�� �-Fj. � ' ��� i163t 'FLS� '.9658 'sc�j 16t5 il6'EG ���� � �� 5'�� � uc1+� �1 taa�yE � '�?9 "'!6?3 '��: ZS 6 ',ia25 tt62: � �-� Z�b �r s'6�,� s� 't5?4 = t53�3.-:�tF-'� ��b '�5635 ^l63c � 11S J bg'1 �� r.(;) ''' 1,� ��;G4 9tSL8 � i'lSLb ;76{5 �16L< ���� �t, � �!9�,{ ° `s? Sr �56 'tE55 1165G � �IS `�g � � : � PAf�t�Y '9.� �� F�j J 116q YS539 '11658 i�557 r ' [� � r ? �>> �,70 1'lbb9 'f3658 SSG67 '�1c65 �655 � a� 3� } ,�'�� l� �21679 `'ttb78 1i677 .-1557b SYi15 �� r�aJ�r I�a� Y16D9+ :1650 '11567 iISBE�5 � � {,� 1559'� �yi97 11696�'�� �kE[f�'it�',� � � �o n�D 9 Sf708 J407 t17a6 't'n� � C��R � ^�+ y '16}� $ Q�y ,�'� '+' 'O �t6E? 9 ~ ����4 � ''6g� � ^� b4 Y a � � ti� �.��14 V d ��f� � �� 1�h � 1���V ��� � ���� T� ��4 yiy q �. ,o' �� b fi�' �Ab y �C�' r�j �,v � S- �1' b �� �h r 1 1 '� h C� oy ''�Q � ` ^�' ,,��fib � �.�`' �� ? v �nST ^ b ,�' rr� � �n `�� �`� ~ ���1A'O �i���? Ir, �r���j ^y� 6t r ~ �p� + �4� � 1�j S^S � i 6 �n,� 1 r � ,` �,�1 .�'` � V CS "� nd7 � +. .�pn � � T� ��7 `^ qt1 �+� b S. ' lt �/ ��yS�, �� $ �.•y+ MU ���s 83 �a �-ry� � + A�A � `0 '��'�° 3 �°� ��'� � . � , ��0~ r+�i' �,��b��b �°,y 17gh . ' . '����� 1\�1��qb � 11813 m ��9�`1 '`,b �j a „�.�,� i1811 T�a°v �.,'�'���' �tSt9 "t7BG2 1;959 ?18L2 �, s'� �'� � 3�5 4fa5z 1s6bS 17252 �� ,� �'E''^ � Sf652 11571 iSOb2 �� 78T2 �i8B1 i3E72 1L� �. Y it8Q2 'It89'I t1BbZ i� �12J� �p � S189Z 'I19D'1 � 'N592 O ��902 t�94� �19a2 TT�.2y _ M92� �45;1 . .smsti �� . �0.5F'ECT �� 3 � � David L. Babby, Registe�•ed Consulting Arbo�•is� June 6, 2011 EXHIBIT C: PHOTOGRAPHS Photo Index Page C-1: Trees #1 thru 3 Page C-2: Trees #4 thru 7 Page C-3: Trees #8 and 9 Page C-4: Trees #10 and 11 Page C-5: Trees #12 thru 15 Page C-6: Tree #16 Seven Spr•i»gs HOA, Cuperti��o Ciry of Cuperti��o Con�»aunity Developme��t Department � Da��id L. Babb��, Registered Co��sulti»g,�i�bo�•isth Ju�7e 6, 2011 f � :� :i � . �:� �,`�r � f���+'�.�� t`�-:'.,M �.� '# .,�� ., �.`�- . 4 �u � �f ky�". YL/• �YR� �i� � ... �Y,{. . ��f,'y 84�i� t;,` . �� •. 9'! �`�., y� . n , r,. k A ,k �.��,,,,�}��4�� �� 4�r � � y^7Y7 .. � . ��,'�{r Yc ,�. . 'V, .. -'.,�� ^y� s. x��i�"�. ' �°��,s��� . b +_' 1 �T 1� .,q��••��_�.'�*' hi^.,i�wd I r, �. � . R,�1�� _ ,� . ,s. '7.dµ g.`�+� �J�~ 1 ..:� ,r. ',� �..ne�...�` ' r '� :f�" - M �.Ir �( �`'� rr �• i . rp� � '���� ,r",�. .q� `• 1ti i � J�•�i Ri'f �t' �' w"`� '^. . . . Y.w�:.•`_.,�..*yl. 1 , . O. �,. � Y �Y'� V �a m+ri S v �4� r �y � b I . . �6' f �r- �``.�� � t� 4 �'�$ �r � �V{ , � .i_.i,�r.", p�, ��J r 9' .r��'Y ��.= � - n ' �.. � �X. R .s��+�� �.,r '�'y,.,r� �F��.` ' � ' .�,4r �r. �-' r ��� , �a_ M..+ i. �;a » .a � r;j !:�_ , t��,fi .t' .�`j�if '� . '� r��� �,.'�� . ...k� � �S� F�;i � �.T�-,1^ � yk;��.. `r' y..' �� � ��. ,. -S � �4-�!y�� s� .« 1 ,.y°"'. . � � � � 1.i i [ .. •, 4' � . Ye n{' i�{'`f`..r,� :. �x �,, �. C � r- ;�.4 � ,. �� ,/r � ,�„ �,,,�, �.r• :�+k '� • r, + �. .:� -y, H.�'...:..� i,.�.� . ., � . .�� �yrx.i[�—� y<' �te ��`S'�. :0. ...��+ � °,� � °!�,� � - I t M,. �.' y`;^ � �RT 4 "'4"i� ' 1s .�','x-� z" ..� ,..+i f�•�e'�b k - �. t � •„.�1 if .�+� '�•°(. s �+i l i i� . 1`, . .+- .�', :i K ,... ` 6 � V ,�� �� *« �..� � t�t.v� � �, � �i' � . � _�`'f �,t� r* y,r ^L� �.+fP: ' . tr�, '�r'�.^.-• a '`-I`s'IG,. `��"I .r i�. �" �' �'+"'�� �� ���� �� � � �'x� ,,. �..�. � � � y ��� �` ;� � . � �r •� ~ �ra �.,�•... �.� � ', 'k'� ��.' 4��� � � , �Y.-_� �� � t�`��, � . .l�,v^gi���"�. �F"�+,_ �a� �j�`��'��'. i{ * �• ��; �",� $.,,�'.� � YE� •. �-y'�� ,, y i,�,��� �w,... :„�;.� �,t y ?�y� -�,{+'2'' .� ,�,. .�"'�,�: .r ►wr'���� ,.4�i..i,y � . �4 t�� �'�'��b���• ih�..�t �.' ��� �. s � '4 y u�..'�. �""r , .� �,�:ee: '^�F :+'"=FS al �-Ws' ^ . e��t�.��� �i" i.4'�,1.. �'4"; y .F-��-.+ :7 r�F`'q,.� ��� ,� � s`• ` t ''� "� _ � ''?•-� '° �a, ti�a �A�� y �y��� �!!zA}�,°'�Y k �°�� - . � „ � ` �� ;� ,�w � �.. - « v , _ . � i . , e� • �,, ',y��X' ' . _ , �+. ., ' � . ��' -�;•��`sD t ..� _ x. , 1 ,.� . "* , �`�, . . - .�. a'' + . . � . , `. �C �.F. �. . .�, q. ��� � 4 n=�P 'L.. .,,r �...t t .,t�..,,, ..r Y -�—y� x :fA�*. 9 �y t�'�x:'yr i{ti �". ��"�r kwq. � ��„�S Al 4 ...� , _ ��7•� �� ...F���+e., ,jQ, ..__� ..�'�i. I . . � '},, r �..`:. rt}r ~ �*y },��+�� ffi ' + � � wj'rt r.,.,�, a �� .- , . I. .. � .'o. .. ._.. .. 4, . � r . . � - .: � , , `. 1 > I ;a-.._ � y�; ' � ' illl ,y�,,, ._.i:' » .... - �: ,� � ^ y ° - ` .. °�r.w��:...��.....ii � _ �'� l..:...� ...^,'��v '�... _ _ _,„�. ....7 . ..-.. . . . . . .. .__ ....� �. wvR�.. . ` 1 ���( , . � .� � �.,ryYn:' ,� �� � � .i.*'a!'*`.� # ai� ' � � °��+�L ,,�"� ,�'^g . *x "a�t`sr�` :�,��,�`"t, r , w'.R�`�'' �w y'.. %3� � � 't, x. � ",".�" �'a�,' �. -• . x _ ,�. . ,:�, ,.� .. .�'..: f,.:C' ' :_np� .. . , ..,. X ` �� .�� � � +� �yr.��C�:. � ;4 �.( .'�.. . �T �,; � j �,�"�,�,j . �a'�""��$ ?;'.� ` � * ° �� r , ._ t�i��.., �r wd.� ,. � � - • � x � � � � " t . . � .� '�',�,�r�. '!�� �"�.�` � ��r' � � .� � � ; • �.._ . ���+ �� ''��. � • � . � - ,. � �. „ .w�.71 �.'i � . '► _�M1��� � /�,��, `"S'�. r".; �y �'a '�� P.�C�� ��.. �. � sI �. ���1�..yp._���4,y„�T i�� �!. -".iY T�Y 4 4�,�y�RY��'ir,�R�y��ir��� i. `�'; .. .�Y 1������r �����! ��� j'�rof tf�` ... . :. �F '.�"�'Rk""�q`�� T�'"#"- r"��� � ► 1 ��,�� ,• �� ��� .. �� . � ' • 2 �� , . . �, , :'`�- „ M1���3 ��.^,�-� ., . '� �1'� �` ` _ �� .:���. ��,� �'Al - .... > � � + � . �, ,+�j, �. ',� .,.�._� k �c`�' . . �` ,y:� . �.. ;�`� ; - c .��d �. � .-. , ,._+�. . . �. , ,�y �:� . .-t� �;,�'��� �. .;..� �; '^'�,'�" + .;. .g�'.� � ,yY, �Q ri�^° 'h�;,;;. . � � . `q,;1Y � �" , �� �� a"H� �`.� 4r� '� •z:. R +�"j ,_ >;;j'� - ����`� ��� ^�� . . . . �: .. � �"�'�-z s'. :.' . �t �'�`. ^��.j � ��t .... . p'iw'v. ��. '� .ni� w .. r ..,":� ���� , �' ., . ��{ s. �� � ., �� "`"' �"'4x .�." 1 �,. �� ;.� a ��' �i ,r µ � � '">' `�, *... . `,a, `�` �, v� `�b t, � N` . . ,�„�t,r{�. M r t� '� �' i •"��� r `��� � �# ���y-�. . � ' �'�..�" � ����. . r, , I .,� , ;��, � l' �n• .r `, ..,y�` • `'� _ _ ° , � „ ', . C� �.s • 3�a'�, . �^r , ,r g`�,�x .'' st�, ' " ;3(� � „ � g �" �L'���' � : ` . - aS ,� ' + ;y�'�., �Y... h ,��.. "4 ' y- <.'�t°.P"y� a`� , �!.'�i..y,y �., G.�. �``� t,r y:. � �� � r ' "4i • � i' *r '��!I,":�`- ' !. . , .;;.3���, � 'M.�- R.� �,��-,s, 3 ,,� ``.` kr„�;?���' ..Y':�, M ` , . � �r, , � .,._ �, ,,, . . . . . •� - , ,J • ,�` x '"-� , , ,�,v . , i�'. , . „cr� �,t'.� :e' • �;� ,�.�..`:� -.,�. ,t. i+`�'"`. : ..5.,,.';�.�!""� ., .�''v c� °'� ♦ � . ° _� � , �` , , . : I i � � i. ;'sr . _ .�,� t ,,p:a.,�, .r � . i ,�, -_-'� _� .�� x.��y. s` :. ' " +74. . R ,�- �,�, r{.�'1�.. - 1 I_ "'�` _ a� � �' an . , . .,.: � .. �, ,., , _ , i i•: .��"r�r , �; t� �..�� -+ �" }�:.� . -` � �'�'= i��� �'...� �...y, ..� . �� "x�.�t�} ' " w •- '...��� ,.. �- � r `�� _ � '�,� �' i , i : , (�~ ���� 'Y .. !'-`� '�S, t '`�.. �"'�. _l, ..yi 9 � 1�_� ra� f�,� � �. � '��. �� �g. .,� y� � �6��5� ��•�i�° .���r*�� ���' .ir r A t R r �~ y .:�y- ����,,.�... r y,�(� k. ;n. � Y . _ ^��, " 4�4•r '�«Gr )�'�•`C �g.. �;�X�,� ', •�.,4'R' : � ti � :~ � ,� -.���� �"�`., ��"- -rL r��.��4�a�t �/�-•s._ x �2','�"�.ti«�.-�-``k, a�r �,,p�." '� ;��i � ~ .. _ f r� Y'� - i.c.¢ � � s'�a.�°a+��"�� ..+-.l'�� F;.. s�.'4..yx�',# � ."� � � � � .�,? � .-�a.�W� .� yg. Y'rsv .��n � � '� �I 'I� . �11 ^�,' � 1� ��.� .. •�� 4c....« �� f _ ':y`.. III . �.�.� �'�. y�k�l� q. 54.. +f. �y� .'M1 J�. C`p�� y'� � ,s�P"`A � ^� 'Y` .{�",}�t��S;,Mt .�'��.� �._��,;X� � , .�.Y L ��'i �..�u]G. ","F� � ` . f , r �: .� , �,�. �. �- p -,,.y _ _;:.,z:�: „r, . ,. . .x. , �.„�, '. � � �m "'^'t ,;Y. u,.G, �.. .,;. � . : , s ., I I s; . ,, .. ,.. .. � . _. _.r�,. f ..� j,t� <v� � . ��a4� ,i. .44 � . � } .`C'�_.�F?�'fLsB.�:.�.�.�,.. '�, - �� '�t � � ,�� �� ,,• 1:�.... '"�,,f�.,�., .'.'�?- . r * . . �, . . ,r�:� „ *'°' ;p. ;I . ��~ ,._,_ ��� .d..,._..�..�..,... — - - _•` � � �, : a Seven Spri�7gs HDA, Cupef•ti»�o Page C-1 City of Cuperti»o Co»�munity Developme».t Departme���t � David L. Babby, Registered Co�zsulti»g Arborisf� Ju��e 6, 2011 4 i „ � , . � �� �&�P �� �`;�+ ^,fr �' ;; � ,�� r ,;�a3 •�" �� �� . '. •� I } �� � !� � I .,i I - � -' j � x �*�� �I s, I � i ' � •t � �`.si«��ti s i II f � . . r --�''� . d'• �� . � ����. . .� I r '} N��t.'.,T��� �� ' I ■ t . � • Y , � .� _ .'' , �• _ �� �!4' `° - � M .._ . . .. _. �a"� � .J'Y� , ,. r< < .t . T ... . , -. ... ., . _' .} � " _'_.�..__-. .. _,_ . �. � _.r-.._.__�. ._ ,,. �, r . _. ... � . -. ,,F,� -�- -'' . s_ . t.. • _ _ �� �� ��,d,.._.._.=-- . *;,y� _�°'� "r��,�,i t �^���., �� : "' :_ '_-_". __�ti, .�1 ��,:. . 'ti - �+e., -w�' a T,.k � - � �� r � �� - � r . ` , ... � ..__.. �_. � I j �4 ` � . .. � � �. �� �• .� � ti I a �r'„n� . � �. r A .. � �. �r 9 a''` 'xt � ,. , . a - x. .. �' r�y t:s- 'u��� i� ' �e� � x M r � � �,i '�'' ".,�._ �y� ..,._��. . , .. � :;, : €� �� . •. , � - � , f � ' `�'� �_'' "�` ;��'� � ..�. �.�._ � � -_ i �� •.� ,,, * � � r � -� -�"� �., ��: � �. ~, ? � � `"�� ^�;'. � 'i! --s 4�� - I '"`"�h` � �'` � , �, �' �� -. i��i�Ii•,��,i����*�., ��� ,*�, �+ . � a . � �I '! I 9 �f�lY j'�'f '' � , ''° �'�� "n `# `' ��:' ' . . � w I ��5 � � ':. : �a ��_..e*�_ . q'�$ ��".e � e'i� . �. �• .,w'�.: �"+"}t�^ r� :...'C�'�2�f�:y;3' .� � ,. 'i. .��.�'� ����• rk� �''" ...: .�n.s�'�. � t� �_ _ ���} - �q�_r � �I `''�`'�i..� "5.�. �r ��"•` _71[?�i �«< �✓ •• �' , , '� ^1�s,Nr � ' . : . , -. N�{t,S+ . . '*!�� - ' ' i ' .y� ' .r x ,�. .1°'� ,'.r �..£':t' .�.._:'. ...'l}� a; t �� {� d y�'� ,,d'" ...' '.�. .� .�,.. ,.... ..�,. -,, '.-.- . .._�. ,• -. • •.�►�. ":'§..� ��r.. ��+�.� ,� .. '�:.^ - . .. ..._ '� . . .' ."'°A'g'��, " �" .. � t � " ' � �.. +�'. � . � , r _ .� ... . • Q� ��w�'+R!'ar.#�`•.,�...:,. f .,-. . ... . . ,.. <. ..♦�F "v��rxn �f', �+a���� a � . '' �. �_ . . .,,,t ,�, �e , �v,2t•r.." .' r � ' - . . . "''�:... i �-�. :A.., y, N. .. ..', ..., ..: ,t . .':. �y,, ' .k ?:.�°^ ",..*Mix.�' rE.4 N 1 .%s'. �t-�...... ., ` � , .. . �.. ...::� . ..... .. ... , � ..�.._ � ...<. .. :��: ...a-.. .* . ... :.�... _. ., ..,. � �:... ...,. . . .'. .'. ..�.,.��: - . . � . . . ....: ,.._...:..:.: ..:.. . ........ . �._..::.- .. ..... . .::".. .::.�...�:� .-:.� 1 •��� . k +�w & A, "`�� �� W 4��� �.'S T _ �,�� �1� ,c� .���`i � � "i� '►'. - _ . y„ `�,t.' .� �y.,�:' :% � r``�•�, �-, '.-�., ~� . , � . . y .. � ., � ; �:i,�.., ��. -, _� , � � �,�� �,,.,���. y`� y ,« w i '...«'��, Y�,Z ?:' N i;W.�� ",�.�e�� '�''`�,� i -.4'.J ..;s�'i,� s� r ��� k .� a ,__ n ,�-r.y � �4 "�+ � f'�' � s . �-o� -� �1. �,�� �i. •,�.,� s 1'�I' _ f .r ` ','�,�►'' > _ �,, � �s. �� -. .,y, .� � � � I', � ' � �, .�;�, �. .. .:�� � �.ti _�'_ � „ r. . � .. ''8 i�.., a!K`. C`„''k�,�n�`�''�y^v.-T. �r. F � , ...5,`^`-L 1'.. _w�. r.R"'�.JV�.iK'�. ,1 � �� ..�'. iH.�:i � "�;��4 . �:. _[ i „ „ M� . :- � � � ' � ! ��-.,_t� � K.:. _ V t - _` �*�(. .� — A�.- .�� . � F� � ^�. . #' �. � � .... ;y.-'3aum � L.n.-r e. t� .��� � � S-���� �t '�....;'°�:,�..y' e'`y,..:�,. ._`�'..�' a��' �' . . +►��` _. . , �, �` .'�, � : - -} �". � . , _ � , .;,....�°�, ;. ; _ 1� '�°�= : � ''r"*,�"�3��f ,„�;,`'� �.�` ' ���� — ,'�:: ,; � , �EY,� ,� . �.�- � ��- � ' '.fi Y�2i�*;,:` 3��'�`1re.Ft'ti;�•y •: --' '`+k�..- ,_ �'- �4i, ✓'f �-1�4 `�d ;,�Y: '-�t... � ` � . r�. � �,y .r-.,.� . s. F r ^Lf✓ +�, �. *j""v. �� � ���� �"'� Y � � ti�.� ~ � ` � � • . . . ._. . �. _.. _ �, ,r� �*P•,e �-' . � L .:�,� . I * ri .. . M � � 1 �. - .,,�; l` �.', ��. � ..,. �� � ✓t�y' �t ��: K.;t �� .,.. �� X. � s rdrf�"Ta��v ._.., .�, . . . . �. . � ` ,��g.� . , ..� �� a u .3 •:M' '4F : .- , } -. .. . = y;w • '--t -�''rt" - • � . r+„ . ,.k '� j,,,.. . y ,�.. � ..`� ,•. w ... y. -._N� i %�� t ��µ� F � I I. \. � . � '�"�� i r.��-��• •�.��l $�� �'� ..�'. � —I'Ih .` �- I ' r_�� �F .w) ���'•� ...ru.a.-sc�'�.c�r, -............. �i�',�iri ,y '¢� � � `„ �y,l I .. � 'KY . �~��� �� � ...._ 4 �. � �µ�N�:I ! � I�,� ! ���.I� lr��. ,- I@. .. . �5 — � -e.�t�e.aEV...�� Y�r _ � ..,..,_,_..,,_ — . . " ...... .,, ' � . ._.._ .. `� '. r,,,,,., .. ..M, .. . � � .:au�,�.'. ,�.. $'� j .. - ___ � _ �.. - ___�_ - „..,. , ... . �' _ -_ ;;�-'� s.y^:�- �,_'� ' . .. �...,�..si q1.� . ..... � � � j� � ,,.�,:.� •,r.'.. i !i iM� ��.,»� �����I��+� � '���� R a ;�" %�; � M,...,� ,°y,=.�y �y.� ' � - < r. .,. , . �, , ; . � ...� `'� *�k'l� f�x� -+ � i�` � �"c4"' . �, d� � F '�.�.�����'.. �< T " � ` , ,.,��., �„ , .�� . � , , ,_ -r.-.i�.cn_.�vs �aaw.+vu..sae�.W.rsv — ..._..�.>..�....._�.�..�__'Ml.�'L�� ��z_ . .y� .sr�x.� Se�-e�z Sp��i»gs HOA, Cupe�•ti��o Page C-2 City of Cupe�'t1120 C0171197Zf111��Develop»�ent Depart�nent Dm�id L. Babb�%, Registered Co�zsulti��g A��bo�•is� Ju»e 6, 2011 .t_., . � r � '� °� ��� � �� FK.. i'" � / t �' a }•f- � �i J.r�l~._ .� ' ti ' � Y.� N. T t � �:.� �� , , .t '�.,,..� .:� �• �� x� A -� -i � . � � i '� �'::� � ' .� - r _ ' '�q.� � �°� °: - i t� w� .�` ����t ,�� .�i_ ,�, u .��� i��-' �. ' �� :�. ,:� .. �� _ ���, _ �;. � � � . � _� _ _ �f . . , E . .. . . � , . , . � a�s w - ' , � , � ..�: , ,_ �— �,. , ., .- -_ ��' .,d � � r�. � .AC�` ++. S4 C. ., • ; ,� 1..'� „ . �• .. ..._. -' __.-_ . '. .. . . ... a - y �,. 1, �.� �. �� .M" ,. : �. � -• . . . . y. . . .y�. r 9�. .�_ 1 - . ,�• ,�� y� � . � . �. .1.- . � .4�- �-y'� ,r. . � . , , ,. -,. � _, r.ws`�R R � a � I �`�,y� 4 . . �;� � �1 �.�Y � �IL� 4^ �.. . . .._.__....._ ._..�._.,- li. a, .. �y„�...�.. "."... 3��.._�� l�L �y �1��.. �. i r '�''�'Ee�, '.,a , .i��,, .�.�--�,,, - - _. ; , : .._. •-- . i �,,,. _4." :��, ��,,, I 1� � . ���""�! � � � ._ ��; , , ' _. ., , a . _ ..�' i � - ` '. iRiti 'i "����19 ".. I' � ' •'�,+wi�al�.., i ' I ' , � A,t;�. _ �� ., ',�, � , � �• ._.na �.. � . { � . - , ,;- E �► .. _ _ �^; _ � '' i ,�;�� �;";- ,_�. ' � . T°` Q` 'v... �� �' � � �I `l ..... ,, .- � ! . ..� ._� ..- � f�._... .... ...: . ...... ..�., .. :... ,� .����a......e...,m.�>.:.t.�..._�._�____,..L� ...�_._.... .,.:.... ....�.�....>..-..,K.� ,._�. .-_.. .�..�- . �..�- ...�_. � . M.'�d�kp�� �� .. I. . i v: J._ I N� � • �'`_ � ....�iYY� 1. �C"Yf'� _ .�.rr�rr���. .�.. _. �. �..r�.�,•w�+ar �. i 6 ,.. _ :..,.._-> >__:'.__ ..,-:_ . :�__-_:_ :: ..._."'_ .. .... ..' . . .... :..' . .. �...-�,.....�.:_ . �. .. ,- . ..__ . _ � .,..�-�"""..'.. . �3 1 ��e t� .. , *�, t , r--'_.-_-- $, �� y� r„ ..�...» � 1 '� . 4{`.. �i, t..: +��. ,� � . .. . � `` � ��{., c�� � Y �. � ��N�� � fi � xti �' 4 � ' yij .. ' .__. 1� � r �,�. �r. 4 I /f t� � ^�f�i � > I� � • y _�.. 4 •� ��{£� Xi�', t��jL � $�; ' : �,��f' f '+� � � ,��!s: ,+4�t m,'� r,�" ���'� ' � �,/� � K¢��� _ .'_'� rf.�t,� A� �'"��� a'�y�1 �f i� .. � >.' • '. ..�.....,. _..�,...'--- � r i. -v . it , + r��'i+ Y' � ;} .. - -. .� � � ! � i rt�K�} $r�; #' w �' 3 '�}F.��� �,� �� .� , , ' r�. a. �s _ ���' �+i� . �u�y�' -...,r�y,� �. �� �� e'.M�`� ZR 'i � s Jr!'r��� •�.f �. Y 1 K,'. .,A, �� ' L°� .� w� �t: J,�� � �. I i 1` . ��`;��:s �' �r. ;;�;-t �j}��k`�� ?�! � �r��t m^ ot � # c f( � ;�,��,,�� �� w Y f �t� �T f '� f '�x t s 5p,�X��; (a *�.. % . `''��� ���� f,�'� �,'�� � � �,��P. ��f" " ,�... � , _ r �"�, i�t' . �� { . . .y .b 7��z.,.. . _ . � * ���,���3 �# ,' �k���� " ., ..�� .,s� =j� :G��" g ..a �' p '"y � �# 'y��� � - �*.::il►"�- ._ "{,; . - -�:",'�.t�f..:� .+.� �` .. � ° 4 ... -r �.. � �'a�' -�" } . .t'. �� '►,,d��-p'Y" ��` rt at»+ »an,��e ��... -' ��#.��.2���`�t� ���#.t - `. c� '�n`' '�"�+R+. •- ,'�-'o r��,,,��.' �� ; } i^ ,A„�_.. k-� � �;' �'.�S w t „ R*�e ` 'Yt 1 � .P � 'iT�`�.. � t M.y�q.."1'"y+w �d.! { .{I� 1 �~ ,1�': f 4 i ` *`a' �� �',.� ��:�', - .. 7�. +���L.��3 . t �r�.�' �iT°f,_� .1i4 �. .# '�� . y r'ys�°��' � '¢i " . "�':, n.,y~j�"� K�1.h^' �} "`.�_1 'L._;.`�M+''�w.�?� ��,� _ �$ T �Y.waT.�� , �'�:`l' .r ..• J „���Ir �y�fr. ., }'t-.� ��`�"�M� �: y,_� +�yg • �L � y}i��S � � 4 S. .�S .�. L Y�� 17'M""�'Y� �.+. �� � �.., . . .r�,r X ar ,q ,5��'j- �;� ri„�;��"v r�.,�a �}��r.,� .. . t --k.. ,a, {s t� i'�: '�,y ^4, � ��' �, � 1:aM �.. °T �e,Zj��,�,,ii�'���"'� i„o,,,�'�#v�,`� T� �S.r.- .' . .t� -�:{+r .s++s-,rK y. . � }. � .. � a^ u,�te Y�t �.+ , x f`•x; �- ,+�, 1 �. i .�k.l:8+ e p w '4i!'�.r'� w: i. t:"J F � .�'�w..pT�A ��"� �'�1 'S�SYy#y�M��M` ..µ d� �� � ♦Ae.�wi . ������n�.}�� eli�l� 'P# ,'� ::.,f »."`�' �� '� ��..'�' a .;°. '.M. �y�.� a�� '"����„ r '�p . ,^4.*�♦ �R� � . l�M.' ��y, ..{1. .�y-} � .`�. ����v�' `� .'���.� � . ��..{ +.�R��,� .s3'� -T��, E t l� 4 � �.{ 's`�s c £ :yt a x ,, .... z. .{ ` ,�,'.*,.. r�} °`i��".�p�1� � � .ya,�,af�.� 4 , �' x 1t h. f 4 ` :. F!�k ��t�J�� � �x� '�.� N" _ �''t ."�.��� '..�.. �r�s �p, -����� "3f��4ws,� �' � ::'� �'iDj Ft ��{�� ilA��,� �f ,St rtb,.� �` �Sw'�L .. � x � t .� ^ �a'w p �a �c."� �. ..� � .. .j �.�. . :.�a ��� �°� �#� ,��� �t�skp, *yM ��^��'a^�..<�,��v .� �' !ry.'C��'�'��+ ..'�r� �."�i,� .p � a � ,�° }�y� 1� '�'�S :'*f�iyf pl 4� � .k �;�'° ..,�'�'�a �"r,tV. a .,�',. . '�''�:.'f.� v*'�7,.`.,�Y�4 y.��l .�frV-.,r'� t11 ' ... " 4� w' ��w� _y 4.�rx �•' 'N'F ,� 1�.,""Kµc ,'...,p j,++�7,'+� R�,.; � ♦..:r � :A4'�. 'k..s��;� t+tr qt,.p t .. ,J R Yi. �." �,* �.�p���+ #�.. �„�•'� . '�1'.� �7F�.°+5�,�.5.a„y`y ,. arr� �w:�'�r �,,�r • . ��s,�...1 g�," w... �( .'s-pE`�: x a.;��"�p�"�: � Seve��Sp�-i»gs HOA, Cuperti��o Page C-3 City of Cuperti��o Com»�u��ity Development Depart»�e»t � David L. Babb��, Registe�•ed Cojzsulting ArborisfF June 6, 2011 � �. : a���- � _�.. - �;. ��, � ._ . __ _ _ -�, �;,� . _ ,..: , , %f � _ - -.� . I ;�� � ,� �i , , , .� �L ,. . .,.. . : ,e� � � � ,.: r. . ;:. :_ I � � � ,� x � . , � ---- r. . , : _ _ � , z_ . � .. �• . � _ .. �'r � ' �F'." �v, � .5y.�..;�'°"� * �I «.ami' �, _ ... e 4�:. ". �'k,y�� �. ��'�+" rs,S �� r^ ... ���.�-����°'��..�.. ,�t �I -;, `� _....t, �c., � -- 'Y�,�—� - � _ ,; - � � I � .t._' _ ,�,.'�. �� -S � '�"'°. �1���, / �,`� I w '" �• .� ° �,k � ' �. ., � % x , ., �w _ r�, . . ,.,,'`1FS... .�,�"'�� I . ,� :. .. � .. ,:� _, . r . .. . . �R" . . ..+�,. r, Y� . . ,.`w>` . F�� ,. � �,. ` I����� §��";��n. � r'�#"`� .;� �` N �. i , : _ , , . I� � x^� .,: Yf� . . . 1 .� �• .. �,�' � "�tF � X.:�- e � �'�/ �:v`°` � . � r — f«+ �t . ( 'T.'� � -Y<� .�rae' -+rtk�- jc� ; .. � . . � � � c i 1.a+lr';�,L�u. Y .1 �"� "" . - s , '` ��. �1,. �. t I -- � ��a .- � ���� � � I�� r�" ' ��� ' .,:.'1' ,' ��An� � `5_..� �:�y ,,,,e . , '' `'`' i� i� � .�!»"L��`�� "�,�r.�.�. '' .. .� _� . . 4j �. x �F e,�. . 'a*4,��� � .. ��ak� .. . ., - , n r * � _ . . x � , `, : �r' T'�� �+�. c.� +t`���.. V�s+�.. . �,w-� � ., &.. ` �-�t ��R,f i `i'�.. .'CI �,+ qn �?, `E' � � 'k''.' o- I y�* °�. 4!�.:�*+,s !�. S s*e� � K . .. � � . �. ��'I+t'� ..'Y� I r. T�',R�ir ��i a. .. .�� ��y#Q'c��v'��`+sy,s's'.� -.i� ' `�'�~�a§s.�� y�s h���°•� . Yi }� � I � ; ,.�,+"M�x_ �. � •+F+� •5 A y � k, r � �' w;. . ,i. .,,,�"•.,......�`- ' i ;..��0. � , t.', �t,-�a a .�',�r�.� �,'wr...,��-°�`v�:' ��.'.. �R 1�. �';�� . :_ .. � ._ �. .. . ,r �.�_ >> � , . . � ��g � ���, .� . .�. i � ' ��� ,.� �."� �,a -' � � ;�.a, � ��,:, �� � �� � , , .- ..,� 'r �� �"` � � - - _ _ _ _..�.-.� .. ---�� __ _ ,.._-, z�.�=. _�a3a. , ��.r :'. . � .,�': . - r, i, , ..�^!"",� . . ,,�. �. '«�.".. ,� � �"��,*� �. `� ° ` �' , . t�-�"• . � � - "r ., t ��4sre�.�s. "S ,g_ � ' :. �" `�'"Tr4. .�+�i3q . ..� '' � ' � - — 'a � ...A M", -',-.. �°, . , �'" ' « `� py, 'T9 B.�" # ^"� '' N,,�� �� '�r ��a� { ���r��. . . • �T ...x � . �, � � 3.. , y :�� x, , '� �,�� , . � '�s. �•� . �.<4 �z � � . �:�� i� � s '�"���f y�y � M. � - :.„ . � $ ' � »,_ � a,� a� .�., ., , .�;. ` . � , � ,� `` ,t. � "'�` ..:.�,'�' `�r'°.�„ �Y= .` 1. / W' .,.� �� . � . � ��/ � - ` � r -. _� �.:� �;� "�'�k��..i���..�, . ,,t �r!/,a � .. r �Y.f; . ti: � ,. , . .. ..a . . �.� .M���! . - u . . _ .. . Jl���Y T r�` • 3, II�� ..,}i r �j �`� 5 � �`'�l ���T�' ^ .4 ..Ti- � ` n�.. � ����..: >�„�".. �_ ,r !+ �: '. .. c�. ru� s ., , ^ • . -w.9E�'=�s�i� ..,�, �@:- ,�„�. � ,- �� �,. •� r�� r � *; _ �. � �'' Y ",�.�' .�;r,.: �' :� '� . ,, - . r . �� -�,�� �.� � :..`�,-_'� � s,� �`'f r,� �-�s..��,�• .-,� a 4� _ ��,.� �s �°'_,:;:'�`_ ;;�.. �,�;;' ;r ��: � �"��� ` ��� � � ��:,,.� k_ '„fi�. � �. ��-µ � . ��'., ' �~�` '�''����w�, •� " _'� � ; � Y•e �, F.C�.!k" �y,� ° �,� � �. ;� G. _.'����� '..�}�`+ 1 _ �J�'. . .♦ .,x ..t �. ti. yy�� . . ,. . ,. �, , _ � i;y �.,1 ,. � ��� , s � � �- r.r �r.. . - -� : �,�..� �r _ V � . �'�� . 't ah (`;. . "' . , ,�. . ""`��'. ���.t � ,� �ti�+Ax ,y� �' �>c }�s'~.y +�' �-.� ~ _ i ��w.�.. . �.�- ` - r�. .. i � ' '� �. '9r� � .4r��`�,''����`�`v�} .Y,.A' �d':-: � i �-'''�w._ I . . . . . w � t , - , y,, r.. -"t t� � ,r�� y :. . �•� . tir+ � • . ` ,+L.,y ���1 .. � �. , �,- j�, " ��MZ � .R.�- ,��� �t t"�' t J. �,., � L' 'f4``.. �.�t"t*�.t„�n��F '�° a�nA`�� "��� y� ��.`�� .ar.:, • �, � • .. I11 q� t �, �� p i , "F' ' ' % 1 .{ _ . .� '.;+ � `� p ` y �f .:J" �. ..'K. �� � f. ���� `^+�� '��'tl R �n � � F _ � � �',.. } �' � �y� � ., �. ,: :.� .> .�[?"_ ��. � I d�.� '� �+�a �-�ss.,tslF. ��rs v +�,�. l �1. �•• '�'� � '� �::. _ �ta.it`F"',9 � '� i t �. �.�`'��..�� *��: ft t.tk ��. r� . �����.�� ��j 1j. '`� '. j �j'r�°' , �A,s. �*r �,;;.ar"6� y. �� �, f;�' ,$ '"^'y�r� � �..� s�' ��, 's . ,,• . '. �s."' .�.-. ! `rt � * y Q� �l � � ` '. ,::�� � " ��f!f �:� . �`YOa`.R I i l '4 � '���..1`7'��j .?�, ��� ..a .. `� 1�r .�} t W,. u ._ .c .. . e / � f`v. 'Y w�`�� � �. n 5 '# �. '~.,.. X` + � t I� �•' ,,y;�"e.�4 fS ,, '+,'- ' .Y .�'� ae+..,s5.:� �...:, �` � I I g •'�'' '�"Y�� �" . e '3+ysR ¢ q{.._ ,; ' � � �;' �3r`'} '� �} ����a �,�`i us:a� � i ,;I�,,,�3�° � > �'�sy, ��`'M - �c '4"' +'a �• �S a r _ � .�,�,�� �;•:.:�> �*+,� �, "�'�� A'�.`.�� i�'.9Fi t:����}7`•� � � �'�.+�vr� �tiT �� � .. �6 ._ �. ' ! _ , . � ' �q+lsl� `y� .i j `��n't r � ,�`��� x "� ......�- �.,�_ �`����� � �a�. 1� � I �_ : �. ' "` ,�� u f ��:�,���� ,� � � ���- ��ry . , . ... i . , , sa�� � � �, • { . � . �` �''. - : ,�. _ .,� . , , . .e.�..:. 5 _ , ....,...,....,.,....�..- , ,. _ , � �-- ' 'w : i;' � ;a�..�� ��•*. ��p _ 4'S ���' -1'�� .:';.. �, ',..; ' . l.��.�Y r��' r�..y� v!�',y�q1... .,x�p'i�.,y , � � �"�' ,,.�� 'r �,"-. "�•c6,. ---..,_ �c . .. _ ����i3. �, ✓Y� .� e.< "s�° � v. Seven Sp�•i��gs HOA, Cuperti�7o Page C-4 Cit��of Cupe�'11170 C017�171Z�791��De��elop»7ent Departme��t � I 1//I �.• . .� / • II ' • � ! ► • y�+ � �.• y� ; _ . .�- i a + Mr � .. , . r �• . �Y �SS"`+i,yY�"Y ��"�1i � ,�� .yY' •n�' _.�..,;+e ./1�� , •y r� •� ! 1 `� .,.1 '�1� T�d ,, 4'����.`�. D • .���r# s ".'� a ..���� :,♦ +y�' t;• � .:,�"' #� �-- '� -. �.�';.�?��' �;. � '�'� �+�,s�'- �- � ,v. � �,1.. �;; .� �_ � r � '��+ ,• �. ,, ti�� ¢ ''-. � "s:.. .ie, :`• �M� � :n . s . ' " �'�r`;,' ..a}hMS '.., wc :.y,y� p ��'� f JI"�� • • ��. . , � �.� 4,.� .� ,;S�• . • i � �!�� ,�.� �µ tT .��. �,"�-�:� , ���^: .. t�� i ;�,, > ■w 51�-x,f'fr .j �« �I �� 1 - ���7 �, ,� s� ���,�'•���� ' .,ti� . ��► �.�i.rc���� -., .'. � �' .� �'� �,� ��`'t��T �. �.R� 1^ 1� . r » a � a t _. ' � . �, �-� ,;. }<<x°.iy.:4� , � � ���.���..T..�� .�' �� �� L .�� , „",.+4� r . � �„� � `*».,. � R. ». . �� ':� t"Zi "�`�d� .t,�'E� 'J�, � ��%� s� � . � : H ' k ,:� ' � a' . . +.� t.� ' f �M 'N `. .Y.,� � �`W ��� *�� . • .� . • .. . . + _ tit '� �� . t • .� � r � .'. ,. � �. , '.�' . ,. - ��, .,yc :. �i►`'' ;�x t��. ' .�.�: � ��, �' .J, ._ . , d � ,`..� �+ . . � -, ..�, �.. .. x , ' ,� 't . � y. #, �. M.�� . 2;� ,�' „ • �,. ..r,. . �., .. t•�,R� `s "#tx�l'. �.s �. � 'J�.:� , �:�'a ' M +� �. ...,." < ih:ti� ��i ~ • r r N�f._ �'Y�a'A'.'�� . h f ) �! .: � .� p 'j^�}� �; �� � :'A.�.Y. .. � '` II��� � b��'F.. �YY� p A�,�. �,�#` ay _ � e Y r �, .. . .Y:' r..`: ,; ... , ILM '�'; ``� ��e S 4 � F � t. .� � •f� ��j�� � �. � .� : ' ...i � + '� ��,�Y't�.i'�.4-dr r.�.'F ,�d � -+d ' , . � ... ' ia..- ���� "��' .+v� *'�. 1 .,�� C+�iv�-rd�.r-n'�"'�'.� :� °'�'�.Ki.+� � .��1 � w�'.eui Iw ��• ,hw= ,. y r, t�: ��° �' �'� ., ._ � � i �:.'� k "'�k"S :: �};�y� .+ , � �C`�• � . °` .- .'r Y � �" b-� l� ',n'ii` . '�_' �.a.... ' ,� ' � i '2.'1 , .�; x�� �.j,)•I � a . r. ' . . .. � �~ �� � ���•��Y��� . . . . ��R �,',-f �� V� ry^�''�.4/a5 yRt . .. , � . � ..� i) V.� "�A � ,"V,' �= i r�c'=ES�;_ . � .. . . �,?�.. ;o r..z�.;'� , , _,. _. . � . . � a:Y2'� �.i��::. , � . � . . � i=� „•�: u�' .'�C`. �w� ��. �'�'V�•Y� `�,` . v � . , :;�� ���►: ��rt�� •: r'�, .r �� . 'X� �n3C' �M�� �• � �l' �',i• ��'.: •^ ,.�►.�. �• .►;,}����.,,.;�y, ,,.. ,,-� ,, y �.�Y'� - 4, ���+'�'}t�.�- :��.�' 'y• ....� 1,. .��� ;�.�„� -r.. i:4 `r'Sr .� •� .�..i� �� ��,� '�I�:~J� .�� �''�� ' �► y• � ';i•� ''. � ivlt�' +,��►�➢€�;c;w , ,c�A,� rs��y ♦ 4�'�' .��� . r y��-�3'�, ` � �, ''�. �� . �"' .+�. �+`i � .R . ,��t+!' ,*, ��, \�# ��,.� � ��" ��.�`p F f +' _+ , �*� �` �i Tt, ��•+ �.�r:£ ' V ��,'r���J ! ~]7^� .. �. ,.• ,` '.+�•��.�*�VI�' ��y� .��R ..�ri' ,�, ;��, F. �7 �' ��"� �`�'�• �•� :. 'i..i ":.f,�.���• .,'A t. r.• ♦ ' t .�. ^st 'j � "'�i , ```���.. .�•Y.A.1i.�1;•'A� ♦. .,: � s��,g.. +"�+5, ���. . yyy,; .'1 . ,� � �-��., � �. �� � .`� �� � �� f �� ��. � s• ;��. �''�+ �� .:. r. ` ' 3-.�� �J����t�a, • Y� ���, � �4'.7f M - � ,.. a'� D. l�d���r,. ...�J�'��.�'� . ! ' +!".` •V.'�'� +� , - �� :,, .� � -r:.. _ � . .' �✓°�. � �. +� '. �. ' �'_ �''. � „s� 'k �' ,p• a a'�,� ;��,'"�-�' i:�:. .. , .,. , � ,. . ' '.. ' F. _ . �M�y�� . �� �t ��x T�.,h1��'� f�+�*� "�� : . � ` y� . . 3! - . �'�7. . ♦� .w � , •.., , � �� , �.' _ !. , � +q '. . _ ;.. V.. . ��� •,. �. ' .. .. s- .'. ..� �,�. ,i, bp�:... -..,....., - �+i"'�.s:a.� g .y . �.. �. � � ..,••> A ... � ,ae ; f•J � . . ��. �i3..,���^',,, �+ �F',.. }��...�� R � • ;M- �. ��`;, :.�.r. . .. � . � . �,� '�. ..•�� �r �� " '� . t . ` . . .( �` � Y, �.. ��'' _3.:. es� .�.�y!-... g .. �.,a� ..� . �� �� 4�., � '` '}t.i �S��� t �'Y`1! `h� I .�,r\ r.. _ . , ^, f e 1 i -� `� .. �.. �, h „� ,,=g r� �, ��qr II� !s�, ��r ' • . • '• '�� �� j � a `s . _ `.'�'"� �: ��jyt,-` , ' t } �J I ° , # • � !' �a ,,, ''`" �� � � I I pa .;Y� �. , s ,-,t 4 I ',�� ,., d � �, �4,i��., � i ,�t • `c« a'�'x!�.t"`i t ;t a � � :w a.tt`"�iz s� �.4'��r� � :�F t �,t: 'a j�,.��, . ._ ,— ��'h'� ! �.G w �Y���" �� a N ����r+ ♦ r«;,` ^��� f'.-�.. a �'iC�,f* " l�rt,� .,�S � ,+I�.. 5� � t r, � .. M ro+^�.7y . L ` �i! ,�.st � ,� � � ' ���.• � � h1.,`�"^C. �.� S.1 ..#.` 3�!'t;; � t k '�V• v, ., � .., . ii. �" � ��'V,`� ���e;;'.u"Vt. 1S1 'G 4"• a _ - •��n::a.. —ca. f� t*' :'�a i i � • , • �i � •��� / I I �' ' I ' �'// Da�•id L. Babb��, Registe��ed Co�zsulti��g�-�rbo�•isf�� Ju»e 6, 2011 N�� � �� � � x�•� -�: �� ��� �� . ♦ .s.-Y.�.�Y. t - - .,j i`P ����'t,.s�� �3 .^`i� ,� !� �C �r�. : � '� ,tr.', �;�� t.ts n-y, , _ . �r. ��._ " �.yr C t�� �;",i.. �._�`' •'� ,G�►,,,;`a_-' -.• :i: ' ,�, ��� � � t ti 1 !;,�;. "� . .y1 at'. �\l�� r' 1� .'•�I!_"`-. � z �� �A :��� s _;�' . i�`: ' a M�s;as 'y• - i I- 4 I � �k*�•.�_,�,�� ,� `9,.�.t `�af �f�.'F'w�a' - . ',. �'�� � <4 '�► .f�. r'�`m'. 'C:iL.. �.. �`�'. r-� �`'.-. �� ` -w, .',r. .�C,#-"� L.a � „-�a�^ � 'S-1P.�..� `�. '.� y��r�_. ..� ____ . � ,��. ,.J+I, � ..._. '_—__-_.._'_ , uf. � . yMS�y� ...._ ::� R1M _ <,�`� '�t _"_'.... . � . __ . . ��� • 'a� ,��. , _. � I f . � ___ , . � —� -.�._ . - r� .. - q�� , r ..rt�{ .._ � • - ., .�. - a'�- r ��. a�..,r ' -A.,,,..����, _. . - :.:w�. _�.���.' ��;'d�:. �_ ` ,: �''�,� ��. � �,��� - - � `<", . ,� , . �; �, .._ �.� .� 1� � �� ���� - � =::.�.. ' '� . y.. y�r_ :a� �' . _ . '�_;r _``� - . . _ - • _. . , s �. � r � Y .- . �'y r. -_. ..,.,..--y,�,�pe., •. � . . �. "3 . _' � p .� r � y ' � � _.. _.__ �`. ,. _ �, . _ .:.� ._ r. ___ —��� r r'/�'r.. . �; '-S� �ir��'r� .�..7" ' �5� .�.... +..E. ��"�ak"_.;s.���^,�.�__./ -/I ....r .,y� .. •.i I '��!" .v� � �� % ��r� �p�[ - �s�� �i _!Y$ �.� �- �. �� � I� �,� �� Y,� � ��f� y.�,�F.��'�4R` ' �} '�w�:w� . �i 5,,59+'. j ,.-. . „;. � ��.,, .�. „yp.,'� 4.fd. �� _Y �'C. P. .� .:'"*�'�' �� ._._.. .. � I I ,,� ..,�.�.�..a...+��.����---^ .._ _„_,..�.._..--�:- i �_ __ . __ .. .. _ - �, r �;�� - ^Y � s€:.`i".1., ✓ y +'�.r�� �. � . �u�"r� � � :���r.r�'...�r..�+� . � uF — �. �-r ...--= . � �S":'S"".. a, �-a�.��- . ,r+. I ��.� '.€ �.,�..�� � � :'�� .rb,. ' .�� �,. � i� y; ��' "X� . �� ►.. � .. �„c �� , ,. � . 4 , ;,;+.4�',etr -�w+' � �s . a S �r�� �� a�� �., - ,r�� �� �I � �� � � .� �' ,�� , ,.. ��•:a�- .'"'�';` .�r �, ,� r p t f . �n ' F .'�'�rn`A1 ,'; ���. r . l° � �?sw"�* +''� � �•� 1 � ,�� .�'`.' �,� �- .��°,� �� it � ���;',,�'�x--w,"" �.� =.:�'�s~`"�;��' �. '' �'��'.�� ,. .s `'�s: �` ?1`,.z�.�k;'i ,,,�4..-5� ;:,'{a - .� ���� 'µ`"��; � � ��. ' Y;•� �,�,���-�-+5'�C�`T; .:` ,���s...wR � ' .a._: �" �r�a ,,�.yu , '�,,,� ¢ .., � n r�,�...�.� _ -.,J�F� ,���.':���} �{''c„ � `Y Y SP y '1Y ��-`54�s'ii.,���S/'.�#-� ;��. .� `��..3,�i"�R`. f }���r°'t� J t"""� ,<I .»; rs=�+i."°�" 1 . �: �'$i^ � v- 'Or 4�:. -:t :: ,<$M tk��h:S...,...�:�. �na4rlKae� Seve��Sprir�gs HOA, Cupertif�o Page C-6 Cit��of Cuperti»o Commu»ity Developme��t Depa�•tnzent