Exhibit CC 01-04-2011 No. 19 Appeal of U-2010-03 AT&T Wireless Facility \\ i / : (( } f
a „, i
r_
.,,,,,,, / tS 10.,
UPERTINO
Appeal of U-2010-03,
.t._:XC -2( 10 -04 1 201.0 --31.
USE PERMIT to allow a personal wireless service facility
consisting of twelve panel antennas mounted on a 74 -foot tall
monopine & associated base equipment to be located at the
existing Results Way office park.
HEIGHT EXCEPTION to allow antennas to be mounted at a
height of 67 feet or less where 55 feet is allowed.
TREE REMOVAL to allow the removal and replacement of
four Redwood trees associated with the installation of a
proposed personal wireless service facility.
Apellant: Allen Wang, Grace Chen, Guo Jin
Applicant: Dave Yocke, Trillium Telecom (for AT &T)
Property Owner: ECI Two Results, LLC
4 \
.. L 1 '? i 2C7ft. v . �. \ 1.:1''
!
� � " , 246 ft 1: � +4v v
• 'AAA . r 3 _. �„ o, 1 I I T � @:\ F \ k
X 71 I 334 ft \ j '., ."
� ill AY \, - �--- ... \\ •-`'� ` � ' :
\ 1 �, \. 1:: \
. �s � ' All / A ,� t • r 1 '
e1 Ai �
.2 t
r ,. . '.fir Tt . Al ..Jlt..! C. I , ` W..� ' `, 1� } V \ \�
1 - wl,.. j l \.
-: y _..a.... __, _ _ _
1 '... s.,m;, a
K ' ' 4 , 2 1 , � •??' .. " d..',r%l: i . . , 1' 1 t9 - �n , ' .. 1 • R !r!..A
1
•
Ot
eotaF '/' 1 ! i ,g \
'C'44: ' 1 ,n2,G v
�(�l
11 11
1 ti v
�7CtT y �..�,�_� `� \
- ..„
2t \
! L_ \ : \ \
■
ce
V t
AL:_`►y.... . ■
■
® Y
7 l
L.H• € f 7 r� .-
� � C � �- � � � � � �'���'� s � � � � � ��G. 7 � � 7 ,1 � 1 i 4 � �r 3 �5 $''. s p 1 � '� �;C £ .�5.....� �' - �� g � i2 b ,
++YTI i 9 'i .
jh, f � E [ p � F
I -6 p) 1 3 t • 9- R r 1
,i.3:,,',' �. i � � * � 'M( x � ✓ �� f [ � .� 1 s 9 ?,;4);;,,, s u$ p
llk .
e� y R J I i ' t fi i i '' 4 a B i .' � -
•
i r ,�.. 7i yr r -( f . ' g � " „ y 'A C'''ad s 1 '; ' ' , "� .4,, . �: '.x ""i'p " �. ',. .
6y:. si`.;:� t, .Pe ,� 'x k tYr u" a ,. . . - , f�3� '° {s � � r ` "s
2
Looking So * of Project Site ;
At* 4
.rte ft F. 9 h h.. . 2'R ..
E . i e f S � ^1. n Y
r �, 3;1 . „ a
1r 2
yl.
•
- ATP lir 0111
f
� 3
3
� 1 .
‘, , ..4011,40,x:: , :1 , ,...., ' ,•., s 4, , ` 3 o king North oft ��
7 H 3 t''''' ; Y '''''411"'
.. /\
.
b. . .. 4 : 'rf t : „tairft 4 '',' 1 ' -
: - i -- „,,,,,,,,. V ..p,..;;,', ',06, '
•
'fi 1111,:i 1 `��"� 0 `34�T
P
..
4
k Looki _ .ou t f k Pot, 1 �` ® '
N`1 ' f imperia
1%% '-'", , 4 . CA � k _ s 's ■ ..
N ,� °M;.R_ : °'sa 4 ice 4 L sue' t: 'E, ,p�,i { � k '' 1 '
P.
..,..„. ..,,!,. 1k i
,,,..... ,
___.
_.
n..,
^' .. �.v it .�.. gg y I _.: ack g L. o u n c
Sept. 14, 2010: Planning Commission reviewed
& approve project on 4 -1 vote.
Sept. 28, 2010: Project appealed by 3 residents.
Oct. 27, 2010: AT &T hosted a neighborhood
meeting on the project.
Nov. 1, 2010: City Council heard appeal. Directed
applicant to look at an alternate site
(near main d:rive, behind Buildings 1 &
2).
5
_ f I7 Vie* , v , ¶;
5 \
r 111 ii • . l � ' s \ 7 ' \\ r , •
MI ,_,� L ■1[ } \ \ ii i . - r '
-- -r- - =
` 'I� :l, i >'.
La Or S iV.1��1 1, t j
+
+
} I '
, ,, tl 1 i , I i � 12 Ile 1 w .. ` . . " _ _ _.
a • .t om z :' ' ' , r.1i1 i ' _ _,- IS w), L G.
Discussion:
Ae .. "na• •31..e
• The applicant reviewed several facility
design options with the property owner for
the alternate site during Nov. & Dec. The
owner has rejected the alternate site.
• The owner has re- looked the other alternate
sites that have been suggested for the Results
Way Park and feels at this time the only
feasible site is the applicant's proposal that
was approved by the Planning Commission.
6
Alternate E Con dered
d
4 . mug \
- `," f . \\ Veti'
upic .
fiTrITTIT
•111
AT &T Facility Alternate Sites Aerial Map
Di scli ssi .on:
Setbacll , ....1e .g. t _ RF
Setback Proposed minimum setback from a residential
property line is 207 feet. Ordinance requires 75 feet min.
Height Exception Extra mast height is needed because grade of
the rear parking lot is 19' lower than McClellan Rd. Antennas
must "see" over buildings to cover neighborhood to the south.
Effective height of monopine is 55 feet (48 feet for highest
antennas). Applicant feels the proposal is the minimum height
needed to meet its coverage objectives. Extra height also
allows for a potential collocation of another carrier.
RFE Study Proposed RFE exposures comply with federal
safety standard: ground level: 0.73% of MPE
roof of westerly bldg.: 2.4% of MPE
2nd floor nearest res.: 0.92% of MPE
7
[) scassion: Desi n
Design ',
Proposed monopine will have
> Faux bark cladding
> Artificial pine branching structure _
> Pine needle covers over panel antennas , - '
-
'V
1 i b Alf' ee4 a
Planning Commission Approval included:
> More mottled green coloring of needle camouflage
> Top half of tree pole designed with a more conical form
> Final enclosure materials, design & screening approved by Director
!Moto Rendering of t - Proposed Monopine
w
6
i
resE r . 1, ! 1 1t
.. v!
J
8
. -ear ` g Resources
• Technology, Information & Communications
Commissioner
• County Sheriff's Office
• City Attorney's Office
• Planning Staff
• Members of the Public
• Applicant- Trillium Telecom, AT &T
Recommend t I o n
Recommendation is to deny the appeal and
uphold the Planning Commission approval of
U- 2010 -03, EXC- 2010 -04 and TR- 2010 -31 per
the model resolutions.
9