Loading...
DIR-2009-29bCITY OF CUPERTINO 10300 Torre Avenue, Cupertino, California 95014 (408) 777-3308 To: Mayor and City Council members Chairman and Planning Commissioners From: Aarti Shrivastava, Director of Community Development Prepared by: George Schroeder, Assistant Planner Date: November 17, 2009 Subject: Director`s Minor Modification (DIR-2009-29), to a previously approved two-story permit (R-200b-11) to allow changes to the exterior treatments at 10591 Wunderlich Drive. Chapter 19.132 of the Cupertino Municipal Code allows for administrative approval of minor changes in a project. The Director reports her decision to the City Council and Planning Commission in time to allow any Council member or Planning Commissioner to appeal the decision within fourteen calendar days. BACKGROUND: The applicant is requesting a Director's Minor Modification to a previously approved two-story permit (R-2006-11) to allow changes to the exterior treatments at 10591 Wunderlich Drive. On April 11, 2006, the Director of Community Development approved a 1,300 square foot first and second story addition to an existing 755 square foot residence and a Minor Residential Permit for a second story deck. The approved exterior treatments included: • Stone base around the entire house • Wood beams underneath the first and second story roof eaves • Wood frame and wood window trim G~` RJ',~ iaE R?' Y~h~':R ~-t~ m,~ u~.F. I?'•'h~S~"8ti ~ __ l j'Y, ~-`-....` ~ STJC:G, GyLQF ^~ .1~' YA:E Y +~;t~ erg a lV9Lk 1!GM FOR, ...._....._. ~ 3 :.; ~..r ~ wl...~~ v.~Mr . .... .., ....~... r _ 4_ ,; ~ -~., .. ~.~~..;..,...--~ , - ~ A wE. ~- _~ v~r,n:v _ r_ __..,_.r.._.. _ ..... --~--~a , ~.. f J ~, ~ ~ ~ r ~ ~ ~, ~.. ~~ ~..~. ... ~~~ ~ ;....,~ ~.-.,..F ~' i _.. . t .... , .._ ~- -~ _ .. ,~ 1 •..~ ' ~5 _ i OEvCM 1' t N:Y.~ .~:J+~k++4~ 5T~?+:, 5!~'_Q _~^`_"C:: C,~k.~GE J4(M4. CR.~ ~-' ?°~ Me,-:r M~fIDVf Me:4'~i+. tf Y 'uhCi 4 cA bxSi wV'JC `'"eN lu?4~. w~V~ ;~ ~ ~ Ff~iT ELEVAT~N ,~~ _. _.__ .___.... _..- frr-.~s1 - wren ~dmrir, s~• anti caa :.:n swat M~ •+cv.r /!..~y, n reeti.-+ xaHt}r a m~C vccc aru. Ca:XG ren cn.oied aa~r r.Cr!.4+ ~~..~. s. oe« cs : u cam. :are ..tt;e ....a:~ ~mn•a -ao .wt( . ~ vw;r. f~'d . attwwo t'CMf: ~_ i.rs+ter .. .. '~?.cif.,.. f Previously approved color and material sheet from 2006 DIR-2009-29 10591 Wunderlich Drive Pale 2 DISCUSSION: The applicant made exterior changes during construction of the project without obtaining the necessary City approval. The changes that were made include the following: • Removal of stone base from the south (side), west (rear), and north (side) elevations • Removal of stone veneer on parts of the east (front) elevation • Removal of grid pattern from east (front} first and second story windows, west (rear) door, south (side) second story bedroom window • Removal of two windows and one door from the north (side) f first story elevation and removal of two windows f rom the south (side) first story elevation • Installation of new columns and trellis to second story deck • Changing the f rout door and garage style • Painting the garage door dark brown The residential design review process ensures that the mass and bulk of two-story project are compatible with the neighborhood, as well as maintaining the architectural integrity. Since the changes were substantial, further design review was needed to ensure that the original public review process is not undermined and that the changes are consistent with the approved architecture. The City's Architect reviewed project changes and recommended the f oolowing: Graphic Illustrating the Exterior Clzanges DIR-2009-29 10591 Wunderlich Drive Pale 3 • Remove the stone from all walls of the east (front) family room projection • Relocate the carriage lights from the family room projection to a spot adjacent to the front entry feature • Emphasize the entry feature with aceiling-mounted, hanging decorative light above the entry door • Paint the garage door a lighter color Add lighting in the architectural style to add prominence to the entry Remove stone from this element Relocate lights to entry form Changing garage door to a lighter color would reduce its visual prominence Graphic Illustrating Suggested Changes The applicant has already implemented the City Architect's suggestions by: • Removing the stone from the top half of the family room projection (per staff recommendation) • Installing a hanging pendant light above the front entry door (the f amily room carriage lights were not relocated per staf f recommendation) • Painting the garage door to match the stucco color SUGGESTED CHANGES Current (October 2009) East (Wu~~derliclz Drive) elevation DIR-2009-29 10591 Wunderlich Drive Page 4 With the additional changes implemented by the applicant, the Director finds that the revised project is generally compatible with surrounding neighborhood and the project upholds the general architectural integrity associated with the original approval. Adjacent neighbors were notified of the proposed project revisions and no objections were received. ACTION: The Director approves the modifications as listed above. This approval of the modification is effective November 17, 2009. The fourteen-calendar day appeal period will expire on December 1, 2009. Enclosure: Revised Elevations G: \ Planni~~g\ PDREPORT \ DlRreports \ 2009 \DIR-2009-29.doc u.., ~ 4.a ~o~t7 ~~ ~ ~~ ~~~ ~' ~ ^~~ o ,.s t'om'-4 ~~ ~ ~~ 4w Q 24'-4' + + 0 9 ~( po +-+ 0 O V 1t at '~ 4 {:~F QN ,._ ~ r _.__ _, :: _ - ~, - ........... _ _- -: ~ ~.:. _l. ~ y Q ! !l/~~~111 ~ `: _ op A m g ~~ T- ..._t_ r m~~ pp C f~l~ i O aN 1 1 y ~~ ~~y i I I ~ QTZ Z B d5~' bb~ E ~~~ ~~~ I ~ ~4¢( N > ~~N ~ ., j ~ ! i IA N ~ ~~ ~3 ~~ Z~ _; - ~< C oZ~y yT~ ZO ~~ ~R °s O T4'-4' b Ag ~~ /~N I py~~~~~~ C N1N `` ~ m ~~ m ~~~_~~ _~ 011 CCy~r ~~m ~~~e3~e,, O ~ A 6~~ Z~ O ~ J o w ~ ~ o ~ ~ o~ y v ~ ~ o i~ ~ ~ ! m ~ TRAN'S RESIDENCE z °- ~ - z ~ ~ Q W ~ ~ ~ HOME REMODEL l - ° ~ z OWNER: HAI IRAN ~ N =~ _ = Z ~ 10591 WUNDERLICH DR. ' ° ° CUPERTINO, CA 95014 'Tt O Z m r m D _~ O z €~~~ ~~~~ ~- D G ~ T in I N o ~ ~ ; g '~ m ~ s a ~ ~~ n ;a 3 'N ~ ~ w I ~n I~ 0 w (D 0 N oW T N O (O ~D ~ ~ +~S * ~~c '+' .~ '"s 8 ~ ~ '~ `F± ~~ ~~ et. `v L.,, i,. 't 3 i }q~1 ~' ' v E1 a,.:~o Imo: ,;,..a ~~~' R' Y iRC r m r m D '""I z O C H y~~ C O~Q A r~ V z A If O ~N p II O ~~~~~~ m ~ H~~<. 8 ~~L~~o -~ ~ ~~~~~ ~ ~~s ~N y m K 1 4 ~ } ~ + ~ + ~ ~ ~ ~ Q ;n 4 0~ °• v y ;v R v ~ ~ g R ------- ,o•_o. ,qL ?~ ~~ d ~° ~id ~ m~~~ __-__ __- ____ 11 \\ rr .7711 i~~ Z 5 ~~N } O ~~ 1 ; ~~ ' T R. ~ ~ 1 N~ ~~ ~ ~ ~ 1o•-a• I AN'S RESIDENCE E REMODEL ER: HAI IRAN 1 WIINI]FRI ICH nR_ 1 N O ~ e •1 w } °' Z+1 ~ F 4 }_ . ^2 ~ ~ Y :~ ~ :~ e 4a ' ' R 4 Q g og y q ~ ~ b ------ - ,o•_o- ~~ m ~~ ~ D ~ 0 ' z . m ~y`m`m ~~ Z IpG O I~ IDI©® ~~~~~; ~ ~ ~m i o' ~? o "° n s o o~N 3 3 ~ = -- -~ o 0 0 ~ co N N N O i (D W (O (D m m ~ " 1~Jls * .ncf ~'~. ~? ~ ° '~~ ~~ FO P. 19~-D' 8.0. NOR. +1Y-E' I a F.O.P. Io'-D' fV L 0-0' GRADE _I _S• ~_ STUCCO OVER 2' - FOAIA, CDIOR 384 VAIEY WH17E BASE A FRONT ELEVATION 1i4.=t,_U,~ ROOF lltf BY IAONIER LIFETILE, EME NLLA, COLOR CASA GRANDE BLEND, T.o~ +I9'-D" BY +1Y-B' ,Z Y 4~ I c FO.P. Ib-~• aPD CRADE _i _5• PRODUCT ~'IVACS6169 DECORATIVE WOOD BEAM STAIN WITH EAcCLOSNEY TUNCSEAL OIL BASE W000 2 STAIN COLORS. COLOR ANTIQUE WALNUT 4 ~ ty QA ~~ ~~ REDWOOD 1RELL19 STAIN WTH IACCLOSKEY III III ~ INI 19 tll~ ~ ~ ~ ANTIQUE WALNUT SOD STAIN CDLOf2S, COLOR I~ ~ I ~I I ICI 1'~Qr 11-II-11 PA710 r~ +9=0' ~I ~ PR~v~o~sl,`l AQ~I?-eV~.. STUCCO. COLOR 384 UALEY YMI7E BASE A 9 REAR ELEVATION D((V ~~ ^ ~... . N-l`l-b WOOD FRAME AND W000 TRIiA DOOR, STAIN WTH McCLOSNEY IUNGSEAL OIL BASE WOOD STAIN COLORS, COLOR COLONIAL CHERRY TYPICAL AT ALL WINDOW - ,y.. - . D Q ~~ ~ U t STUD`i0°. m a c m ~~SiO ARCH~I ~0 ~Ai'dK L yo F°~ * N0. C29699 REN. 2/29/01 f~ 4 9rf OF CAL1fOf~ N0. Redsion Date W V Z W /~/~ V/ W ~~ D N 0 ~ Zw Q Q W ~g 0 ~' I ~ =~ zU a~°' ¢WU O =zZ ~ W r zo,a ~o~ 0,-U Sheet irtle ELEVATIO NS Project Number: C529 SCale' AS NOTE Designed By: FH Drawn 6y. FH Checked By. FH Date: C823.04 Sheet Number d ~ Of Sheets ROOF TILE BY MONIEA DECORATIVE WOOD BEAM STAIN 1MTH LIFEIILE, SME NLLA, McCL051(EY NNGSEAL OIl BASE WOOD COLOR CASA GRANGE 12 STAIN COLORS, COLOR AN710UE WhLNUi BLEND, PRODUCT Qq ~1 VAC56169 +.O P. 19'-C- Wg00 FRAME AND WOOD T.O.P. r~ _ 7RIU DOOP„ STAIN WITH +1Y 7-B' ~ AfcCLOSKEY NNGSEAL DIL BASE WOOD STAIN COLORS. - COLOR COLONIAL CHERRY 11PICAL Ai ALL NINDDW ENTRY T.O.P. ~ 12 .{1~ ~ 4 +1Y Z'-p' UV, T.O.P. P ~ +1 FAN. T.O.P. !~ N STUCCO, COLOA 3B4 VALEY WHITE .. b BASE A ~ ~° O ~ D F.G. 1y . .. 0T p L ~ ® "'. J GRADE STONE VEIJEER, ELDORADO _2'_p• S10NE, SME SHILO LIMESTONE. A RIGHT ELEVATION ,w°=r-a' ROOF 71LE BY MONIER LIFETILE, SME WLLA, COLOR CASA GRANDE BLEIJD, PRODUCT t2 ~1 VAC56169 Qq T.O~ +19'-0 TOY +17'-6- `a I ;~ o.o.~ T.oL p, .,p- N ` ry~ N GARAGE ~ .. 'I- o I .. O ° I 0 ~F~.F. - STUCCO, COLOR 0Y p' L 384 VA.EY WHITE ~ (~ S~ 1l aA5_ A ' - 1~ V ~~J ! ~ VV V cRAOE A y __ - -- - T,.,_ . - _ ..,_ _. ,- GARAGE DOOR, COLOR TO MATCH SNCCO GDLDR ~ APPROVAL - -oI b -~ 9 Application I~UfT1~9~ LEFT ELEVATION ~ /~- 8 'T E7' - Q ~- -.,~.9 ,.,:, Si nature, ~"~ ~ .,a~,R~, . ~~ ~ _ ,_ ``~~'" y'~~~ '~ ~ase Mana er Il-t't-oQ ~" g .. . , -.~Nr. ,mss'. ,.,,,-,:,,.. ..~ ~. .,,.: :. .. aSED ARCy~ ~U Ef3'Dk L H ~~Dr * ND. C2B869 ~ AEN. 2/28/07 e 9r ~? FOF CAL1fC N0 Revision Date W U Z W W MM LL J ~ NO ~ Zw ¢ Q W ~~ Q ~I d. =~ ZU Q J0, ~WV -0 =zo ~z ~~~ W r zo,a ~ Q ~rU Sheet isle ELEVATIONS Project Number. 0529 Scale: AS NOTE Designed By. FH Drawn 8y: FH Checketl Sy: FH Dale: 0823.04 Sheet Number 0 01 Sheels