TR-2009-04bCUPERTINO
June 24, 2009
Suman Cherukuri
22487 Palm Avenue
Cupertino, CA 95014
10300 Torre Avenue
Cupertino, California 95014
Telephone: (408) 777-3308
FAX: (408) 777-3333
COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT
SUBJECT: TREE REMOVAL PERMIT ACTION LETTER -Application TR-2009-04:
This letter confirms the decision of the Director of Community Development, given on
June 24, 2009, approving a Tree Removal Permit to remove one 22" Cedar tree and one
34" Oak tree, located at 22487 Palm Avenue, with the following conditions:
1. APPROVED PROTECT
The approval is based on the tree removal plan sheet and letter from The Davey
Tree Expert Company dated May 26, 2009. The trees are identified as one 22"
Cedar tree and one 34" Oak tree on the plan set.
2. TREE REPLACEMENTS
The applicant shall be required to plant replacement trees on the property in
accordance with the City's Protected Tree Ordinance at stated in the table below.
The applicant shall provide a plan showing the location and species of tree to be
planted on the property to reviewed and approved by the Director of
Community Development. The replacement tree shall be required to be planted
within 60 days of the approval of this application.
Trees Removed Re . Re lacement Trees
Number of Trees F~ Species Trunk Size (in inches) Size of Tree Box
Coast Live Oak .23.5 One 36"or two 24"
Deodar Cedar 19.5 One 36"or two 24"
3. IN-LIEU TREE REPLACEMENT FEE
In the event a replacement tree cannot be planted on the property as determined
by the Director of Community Development, the applicant will be required to
pay an in-lieu tree replacement fee based upon the purchase and installation cost
of the replacement tree(s) in compliance with the City's Protected Trees
ordinance.
4. NOTICE OF FEES, DEDICATIONS, RESERVATIONS OR OTHER EXACTIONS
The Conditions of Project Approval set forth herein may include certain fees,
dedication requirements, reservation requirements, and other
TR-2009-03
10880 North Oak Square Page 2
exactions. Pursuant to Government Code Section 66020(d) (1), these Conditions
constitute written notice of a statement of the amount of such fees, and a
description of the dedications, reservations, and other exactions. You are hereby
further notified that the 90-day approval period in which you may protest these
fees, dedications, reservations, and other exactions, pursuant to Government
Code Section 66020(a), has begun. If you fail to file a protest within this 90-day
period complying with all of the requirements of Section 66020, you will be
legally barred from later challenging such exactions.
Staff has made the findings necessary to grant the tree removal permit in accordance
with Section 14.18.180 of the Protected Trees Ordinance. Please note, however, that an
appeal of this decision can be made within 14 calendar days from the date of this
letter. If this happens, you will be notified of a public hearing, which will be
scheduled before the Planning Commission and the tree cannot be removed until a
final decision on the appeal has been made. If no appeal is made within the appeal
period, the tree may be removed after Thursday, July 8, 2009.
Sinc ly,
i Honda Snelling
Senior Planner
City of Cupertino
(408) 777-3313
akih@cupertino.org
Enclosures:
Approved Plan Sheet
G:\Planning\Tree Removal Staff Level\Action Letter\TR-2009-04 Actionletter_22487 Palm Ave.doc
2
i
I ~
IE PAl9A 'I ~
I ~~I
TO REMAIN (E) PAIN
TO REMAN
_ - 10.00' _ 1 0
~~'
PROPERtt LINE _ _
.
_
PROPERTY LINE
I I ~---------------~
~ (NJ WOOD FENCE I
'. '. TO MATCH EXTG. I
o (EI OAK
TO REMAIN E
f )1~CAR
~
(EI OAK (N CONC. I (NJ REAiEYARO
I
I i
'~
' DETACHED I O TD REMAN PATq
UNDSCAPE
IQ I O (E)GRAVFI
j GARAGETO I m I I N I
N DRNEWAY ~ BE REMOVED ~ (N)REARYARO I
I
I I
~
(Ej CONC.
~
X (E)CONC.
UNOSCAPE
~
N I
', p LANDING TO
REANN
~ TO REMAIN 8
I I
~
IO . . . - REAR I u REAR REAR
Z SETBACK
12 -O„
oIY
ww
(EjW00D
~ DECK TO
I I y m~ (EIWOOD
' 3m FENCEBGA REMAIN
I 20' 0" I 3T-6°
I I
I (E) PINE
'. TO REMAIN
I (E) MAIN 1100SE
I
I ~ I ¢ I (EI ENTRY PORCH
C
~~ I
I
~ I (EI PINE
I J TO REA411N'
li J II
I -~ o x
y~ (E) PINE TO
'. 2 ~~ BE REMOVED
~ Ww
0 ~ FRONT
0 S~TB0.CK----~----~
I I
I LL
N (E)CONC.
WAIMVAI
(E)SiONE
(E10AI(TO WALKWAY
\ BE REMOVED
I ~ _ ~ PROPERttLNE
85, 12'
I (EI PALM (E WOOD EI PINE TO
iO REMAN FENCEBG0.TE REMAN
22487
PALM AVENUE
I
~~. (E)ASPHAIT
ROADWAY
SETBACK '., 0 ET~ACI~ ---- -~~------- ----- I
'. ~ 12'-0" ---- sET6FcK 0
5'-0' w a (E)wooD 5'-0
~ DECK TO
s
VNm I 3'~ REMAIN mIU
~~nnnnJllll .Im
~,~, 20' 0" 30'-0"
~I%
I I I I ~
I ~
I (EIPNE
TO REMAN
-O„ (SEE OETALEO FLOOR
I PUN ON SHEET All-~"
i (N)ADDRgN
I I (CONDRK)NEO) (E)MAIN HOUSE I
C
KwAY
I WA I
I _ I
i: I ~ ; I I
o ~
I °
a ~
"
mID I
I I
o a I
I ~ I I
I I T
R
EAU
O
I7
m ~
/
I I
I (
" (SEE DETAILED FLOOR
I
J
I
V
PLAN ON SHEET A7)
I
J
I - (EI PINE OBE
y
~
REM (Nj ADORION
(CONDITIONED)
0 Y _
K
u
~~ ~{
~
m ~
~ "" ~
Q ~ FROM N
SE K I _ _ _
SEiB0.LN
SETBACI(
I O
I
LL N BAY WINDOWS
(1
(T1'P.fOR 2)
(n INIWOOD (NI CONC,
Q FENCEEGATE
::.M :..:..:.........':.:'.:'::. STOOP
p
~.o I :.'.':
.
...,
f'
~ I
,
,,
:
:::..:..:: H
::::.ARMaY WALKWAY N
(EI PAIAI (F)ORK TO E
(E)WOOD TO REMAIN \ REMOVED
N)W000 (E)PALM
TO REMAIN
FENCE ......................................... FENCEd GATE
O
(EI ASPHALT
ROADWAY
0
~.
0'.
.K
O EDGE OF
0
N
-f or•PmxrAa~ a
I I
nn
I Ai ~ E~QVAL ~-Z~o9-o~-
i A~~!i~ation Number
~N2+-4-
N
®11A1 EXISTING SITE PLAN
ZONNG
SLEET NO. ALLOWED EXISTNG PROPOSED
20NING R~1~10 R~1-10 R~1-10
LDT AREA 10,0005fi.MW. 9,9535Fi. 9,9535Fi.
SETBACKS
FRONT 70' 77' 70'
REAR 70' I7' 37'
CORNER lOT 12'MIN STREET SIDE; 7'-0'EAST. P-0'EAST;
SIOEYARDS 5'MIN. OTHER SIDE 3l'b'WEST 3Cd'WESi
LOT COVERAGE 15%'/F19 BFT. 2,3]1 SFT. 7,~1 SFT
2/%</S%. 77%<A5%.
FLOOR AREA RATIO 15% • 1,119 SFT. ]
311
0 SFT 7
651
0 SFT
,
. ,
.
FIRST FLOOR
CONDITIONED MU 1,850.0 SF7 1,580.0 GFT
.713.0 SFT
GARAGE /97,0 SFT 511.0 SFT
MAXIMUM HEIGHT 78'd' 20'-0'N.LFj 20'-0"N.LF.)
F-}--121A1 PROPOSED SITE PLAN
VJ 1/8' ~ 1'-0'
VaOuri Associates, Inc
V u~~~ln.e~m
WFI AMW, w.e,a... w.
Ncv;@m
4u]$uJGWN Can
lou,un, C.l wWd'
vluF. R211IDLL>,i
Fu. Id981119~1fJ]
F •'1:n.~~.llwsan
ttvpu,.mpm ubx. u~ium a~
axw<,n~~m~~,~mm u<
p~Mi u.
U
O
C
.~ ;
~
~i U
. ~ /~~ O
.f , Ci
'~ ~I
r
o
0
~ p
p G~
~ QI
~ ~~~II N V
~ /~V
1~'~I
`
0 U
E
Z
U
0
0
a
NN - ~~ ~ b
~ y RN
ryr N. 2910
rl b
EXIBDDS $11G Plan
Proposed Site Plan
V
A-1
°'
~, AI/ ~QVAL - 2pd~1-c~{- I
Application Numbw
- 2~-200
II ` ~ "~~re at I
Case Manager
I
I I (E)PINE
TO REMAIN
i~ 0
I~
J
m
J
J
O i
w
w
a
~ a
0
w
~ w
7
z
w
0
a
I
12,_0.
67'-0'
Y-4' S0'-11'
BATH p 1
BED ROONAY
BATHtlt BED ROOMNI
MASTER BEDROOM
HALLWAY
II
u
ED ROOM p 7 W.I.C.
30'-0' C
I ----------- 4_J~JJ MASTER q)
I o DEN
,S I I
I PANTRY
i
I I ~ ~ I
I I
(N) CON. I I
WALKWAY
I I
I Imo') FANILY ROOM
I I KITCHEN
I I
I I
I (N) tCAR GARAGE I
I I I
I I
I I I
I ---------------------~ I
I I I ~_` I I
I ~`~ I j lj
I~ I I I I II
I m I I (E) PINE ~ I I
I I TO BE REMOVEb
% (E) PINE
N TO REMAIN I I I I I )DINT IN) ENTRYI LNIN
N
T-0' 18'-L' 6'-
IW
I ~ L~------ - -- --- ------- --
L _ _ _ FROM SETBACK n
1•-9.
I I
(N) FENCE 8 GATE (N) CONC. STOOP
67' 0'
c i .~\,
°n ~~-~~ N) CONC. WALKWAY (E) PALM - -
8STEPS TO REMAIN
(E) OAK (N) FENCE & GATE ~,
TO BE REMOVED
N I
PROPOSED FIRST FLOOR PLAN
(N) CONCRETE DRNEWAY 11~ 1~4• - I -0'
_ _
RO R LI
RELOCATE FRONT YARD
FENCE TO PROPERTY LINE
wuLL~G6Ne
(E) PINE
(EJ PALM TG REMAIN C = _ - - - ] EXISTING WNLLB TO BE REN04E0
TO REMAI (E) PALM - - -
TO REMAIN
O E%ISING WNLL6 i0 REAIAM
EDGE OF PAVEMEM
NEWWAllS
"6-6 '°~-0' PALM AVE.
• Nnlluri Afisceimes, Inc.
V UniP~BUN
Rrrl Nravl.NUa...ur..., ~.~
Prts~knl
~~
a~lW5l iRRti
u~ R!l1tRI5n
M-a~.d~....;Crm~M~
,~F ~.~ ~..,b.,...M.-.
~N~a~- r<,~R
a.,~,,.~.~.a.nn wem
U
~
rl
a
O
q
.~ ; ~
~
~+
U
' ~ Ce: O
~ a
~ r ~
o ~ ~ QI
v
~U
0
E
i
0
Q
a
us ~~~ ~ b
~M ~
nrr IIS. 2910
r
ar s
Proposed First Floor Plan
V
A-2