DIR-2001-26b
10300 Torre Avenue
Cupertinol CA 95014
(408) 777-3308
FAX (408) 777-3333
Community Development Deparbnent
January IS, 2002
My. Roger Wert
Northpoint HOA
10880 Northpoint Way
Cupertino, CA 95014
SUBJECT: PLANNING COMMISSION ACTION LETTER - 26-DIR-01
This letter confirms the decision of the Planning Commission, given at the
meeting of January 14, 2002, approving a referral of a Director's Minor
Modification of a use permit to remove and replace 'B trees at an existing
planned residential development, according to the enclosed copy of Planning
Commission Resolution No. 6121
Also, please note that an appeal of these decisions can be made within 14
calendar days of the decision. If this occurs, you will be notified of a public
hearing, which will be scheduled before the City Council.
Sincerely,
h
Cy~'
Colin Jun .;;;-
Senior Planner
Enclosure:
Resolution No. 6121
g:/ planning/ post hearing/ actionletter26dirOl
Printed on Recycled Paper
26- DIR-01
CITY OF CUPERTINO
10300 Torre Avenue
Cupertino, California 95014
RESOLUTION NO. 6121
OF THE PLANNING COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF CUPERTINO
APPROVING A DIRECTOR'S REFERRAL OF A MINOR MODIFICATION OF A USE
PERMIT TO REMOVE AND REPLACE TWENTY-NINE (29) TREES IN AN EXISTING
RESIDENTIAL DEVELOPMENT IN ACCORDANCE WITH CHAPTER 19.132 OF THE
CUPERTINO MUNICIPAL CODE
SECTION I: FINDINGS
WHEREAS, the Planning Commission of the City of Cupertino received a referral of a
Director's Minor Modification, as described in Section II. of this Resolution; and
WHEREAS, the necessary public notices have been given in accordance with the
Procedural Ordinance of the City of Cupertino, and the Planning Commission has held
one or more public hearings on this matter; and
WHEREAS, the applicant has met the burden of proof required to support said
application; and has satisfied the following requirement:
1) That the tree or trees are dead, in poor health, diseased, have major wounds,
damage or poor structures that are likely to lead to falling and potential damage to
existing or proposed essential structures.
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED:
That after careful consideration of maps, facts, exhibits, testimony and other evidence
submitted in this matter, the referral is hereby recommended for approval, subject to the
conditions which are enumerated in this Resolution beginning on page 2 thereof; and
That the subconclusions upon which the findings and conditions specified in this
resolution are based and contained in the public hearing record concerning Application
26-DIR-0l set forth in the Minutes of the Planning Commission Meeting of, January 14}
2002, and are incorporated by reference as though fully set forth herein.
SECTION II: PROTECT DESCRIPTION
Application No.:
Applicant:
Property Owner:
Location:
26-DIR-01
Roger WertjNorthpoint
Northpoint Homeowners Association
10880 Northpoint vVay
Resolution No. 6121
Page-2-
26-DIR-Ol
January 14, 2002
SECTION III: CONDITIONS ADMINISTERED BY THE COMMUNITY
DEVELOPMENT DEPT.
1. APPROVED EXHIBITS
The recorrunendation of ~pproval is based on Exhibits A & B titled "Northpoint
Tree Removal & Replacement, 2001."
2. TREE SIZE REPLACEMENTS
All specimen sized Monterey Pines and Canary Island Pines approved for
removal shall be replaced one for one with a 24-inch box size replacement tree or
shrub as specified in Exhibit B above. All other non-specimen size trees shall be
replaced one for one with a lS-gallon tree or other recorrunended replacement
specified in Exhibit B above.
PASSED AND ADOPTED this 14th day of January 2002, at a Regular Meeting of the
Planning Corrunission of the City of Cupertino, State of California, by the following roll
call vote:
AYES:
NOES:
ABST AIN:
ABSENT:
COMMISSIONERS: Patnoe, Chen, Auerbach and Chairperson Corr
COMMISSIONERS:
COMMISSIONERS:
COMMISSIONERS:
ATTEST:
APPROVED:
I s I Steve Piasecki
Steve Piasecki, Director
Director of Community Development
I s I Charles Corr
Charles Corr, Chair
Cupertino Planning Commission
g/ planning/ pdreport/ res / 26- DIR-Ol
I ~___________---- -- I~ Ii '2 2 '21
I / ~ N ~ liS! N . ~~P>> ~' I=- 10 \D CD -.J I j -
IN l[O.b 8 ~ ~ ~o.2 ~ ~o"" .i!l:S ,?r1?\J,.,1 2Q3); ;:' -.J -.J -.J -.J l' N
~18 VI ......... N, . \ON '- \D _, _, ?o"'>216 \D 0
'f;,/II ~ ~ .A '" V' v< V' <J' (;,1-'" U' <1), '::1
..--_ .?O~~ ?O ,II) ~ z 2026 7lL~ i ~
~ ~ ...20255 ~ 0 202<''?
",-0 l2CJ2a I "")3;24 .__..~ i ::>J
I~'" ~ [ LV Z 1;:0245 '?u.:9",. -l (:0247
'v 2i ?027' IXro,14 g J2M~" ~ !xl?.,,? ,e~
J ~ I ~ ~~~f€~;, ~ 20m I:: ....' ~ .1""-17 f,~~
I 20272 ,,0 2024~ 202'04 -. ~ 202\5 .20"'66 ~. 20217 3)288
I 202"2 Vl "-;; 2 '1 20274 Vl -. Z C
... '" 0 02.;.>3 p 202Q"> 202% ?is 1202071
~ ""'" ~ ,. >>,., I>>". m. >>,911 20218
i '024' ~ 202'-' >>,.., ~ >>'" 120".1 '" 20,,71 2Il2Gll
",om -' 1'0'" ,'0'" <:') '017' L 20m 1 2Il2"
'--' 20203 20244 " ~
-w 2. 0'9:; 2.02'34 c-..!' l' ~ 19 ~ r:" ~ . 202:l8
J~ ~ g ~ ~ IS! ~')-:'g,2 ~ 2 .~H~. ~ ~ 19 ~ ~ ~ 20228 ~
!\J r..;; ICT \D IV '~ ~ N - ol.O CD ~ - I Cii
N N N N....J ~'\IJ . ;>. ~~-I~-/!'"- -.
[ ~ _ ~ . _, 09<' ~ - ~ -I .
!~J@-~~~ ;- ~ I~ ~J*U~ ~,
~_ -= ... 1085:'> 109~' ~
N ORTHOAK 110~hl _ 10962 V cfORTHSEAL
, Q f fSQUARE v''''''' i IT] 1,0"",, - . _ -JSOUARE ))
201 ~I _ Im71 c;
ZQl4t r= @ ~I~ g '::' - r;;; I OAT'> ('l IT]
'120131 J 8 ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ d I 0001 ~.
201 Z I :='~ ..-J--1--L -LJ.QiID... ~
2D1(J1 - ""=" - I ;3
"fj! ~ % ~ ~ ~~II~ tI:=~ 1 .;
u --.J-1 -.J I' 10$'07 Lor
NORTHRtCXJE Q t0917 i
(1. I-~QUARE V 110927
i of" r~~r 10937 eo
l ~\ ~ -- ~~
= nf~ ~~ir ~~D
,:~ ~" ~ ~ ' ~e _ )f.~ ~ ~1 ff~RIO~
I nNORTHVIEW icees bill ~ T11--rl...., ~ <.!> ~ ~ ~ ~
I~....' / ~ ,II~' I~ 121 ",.'" ~ · ~O';'H~O", L
1>>] -~ - 1 090~ 10841'1. 17 I
I, . ~ - ~ ~liil ~ ~ o;r 10910 '0." c: fsou." V
-;1 ~E &? ~ ~ ~ 1092., 10068 'P ~~~:l-
:: -;- r--::-~ ~ 109" I~':" U U ~ ~ g ij ~
I I 200 ~ m:IDmJ- -- ~ ~ ~~~~
1 : ';'3 .~; _ ; ;; Qj~~~ :::.-'-E,
: : ~ ~ NORTH"'IO J~}-.f. ~ f3 ~ _._ ~S4 [~-1 ~lf
1 I 'OO~ ' 084' ~!. :'i ,,,,.,, , = -:)'0'" ,"'-b ~ ~ i
, , 't'L ,08>' - Snu...", U , 089' ~ {(::J,% '" " , I'" ''''
J I zoo _ ,..., _ 109 1.1) 0 f 20154 I-. '(?J_
I I _ ~ ~'--'~ - 8 IQ U- 1-_ I C9~~. . 20 1~2 I ?5~ 20 133 20 144 W ,3 2X)9:',)
I \ ~ 'It'~;;. Ri ~ ~ ~ ~ - 20122 1;0 l.:.120123 201;>4' ~ zoos::> !
", J:! ~ ~ N ~ N N '0923 ",,,,' -_<1 . I % 20075 :
<~_~~-_ ~~~_ 1=-~~ ~ ""O'J is' p ::~~l ~~} :;:.........II,I..~
____ ~~r---i;..EL!li ~ '0'" ~ '" ,009' ~> ~p.~ I'~~ '":I I
_ _ _ "po. _ = 2<:QJ" ~ """ ,. ~ -.2~
_ __0_ 0;':;--_ _ '09&' '00"1' ~ '0073 ~ U ~ ,"" N:.
-~E__:_ ~~73~~~nDni~f
__ ~'.m..'.,.,,"'...............i,''';,;miMill'''m''''
@ ~
~---------------- -----------~
/' NO jRST DRIVE
I
I 0El06
I oel~ 1"
~J
I 08:36
10846 ~
8l..U~Jp,
Y DR
Iv€"
rnn-mn'
~
:0
o
)>
o
Exhibit A
(fJ
o
c:
~
:0
rn
'~ ~ ~; [= DHr~ (3 - Q ~
". N .c..
o-..-J
I ~U~ rnu!J
10880
. 10890
109::0
10910
10920
10930
-z.~
NORTHSKY
(l I
ISQUARE
:t
o
3::.
fTl
Vl
-I
m
)00
o
i)
~:J_L
~6~
~~~
r
'::::"'9-
I gg
g;~
z
o
:D'
-i
:L
"C
o
Z
-i
-i
:D
m
m
::0
m
:s::
o
~
r
:1>
Z
o
::0
m
"C
r
f)
m
$:"
m
z
.:-l
'"
o
o
.....
S
I~ It '" '" '" ~ '" '" ..... ..... ..... ..... ..... ..... ...... ...... ...... c p 00 ...., Ie ~ ;:..> '" ...... ;p-
- '" 01 ""'" ...... '0 <0 00 ...., '" 01 W "" ...... "'U
~ 'II:
~ ...... -l
~ I~ I ~ ""'" -../ t en .p. ::::J ::::J .j:>. .j:>. :J en ...... ::::J ...... U1 tV ...... ;p-
O W w en ro- r0- m m -- .t>- m ....) ro- U1 It -..J U1 ...... Gl
-..J co m OJ w .t>- m -..J tv <0 (l) N
V'I ....) 'II:
Ii (l) -, r -0 () -0 -0 ii' ii' ii
r-- 3 .Q C C C (f)
C C [l) ~, c C
() 0 0 .., :J '2. -ti (') "'U -l
- 11 ' ID ::::J n. . ~ "7 ""2- "7 a. 0- il il ~ ~ I ~ 0- m m m
~ '< M- m ro (l) m.: ro ro (l) ID ~" [l) OJ a. a. ~. 0: 0: -<
~ .., ro ro 0 (JJ ro Q "'U
1-; , -0 -0 3 " -0 ""2- -0 ~ 3 :::r 3 3 :::r
~ E 5' c; c; .., .., .., .., m m
(JJ r:r " ~ 5' c 0- 0- 0- (fJ
Ii en (JJ 3 (1) 3 3 (1) ~ (1)
~ .., .., ..,
~ ...... ...... tv I ~ N N N ...... ...... ...... ...... N N N (l) (l) N (JJ ......
I' I ~ 0 0 0 ' CJ CJ <:) <:) a a <:) <:) <:) <:) OJ ro I ~ <:) m <:) r
...... <:) ...... ~ (fl ~ 0
$:. 0:> co W tv 0:> 0:> 0:> 0:> W a M- ...... co
Ie .t>- o 0 U1 tv <0 W ...... W <:) ~ m m -..J -0 -0 Ii -..J -0 co (")
I' ...... ...... ...... m
"'i Q) .t>- .t>. N Q) .p. .J>, w w 0 0 tv 0 U1 ;p-
I' I, ;: ::::J ::::J ::::J ::::J ::::J ~ ::::J ::::J ::::J ::::J ::::J ::::J Q. '2. I ~ ::::J '2. ::::J -l
< tQ. 0 ,;;;: ;;;: < ::5, d' 0 0 0- 0 5,
I,j If il il ..., - 0
<D' m 0 0 0 <D' (1) Ci 0 (i: 0 iil iil 0 m ill
~ (Q ::€ ::::J < 0 0 (Q ~ ::€ < ~ 0 .:;f ;;;: < ::€ :;f 2
Ii (1) <ll a. n. (1) (1) (1) ^ ::::J ::::J I' rn ::::J
tTl
:::r ::::r "T1
J~ rn .....
ro 0- w 0 0 ?::J
w m ;:::;: -0 ::::J ;:0
;:::;: - 0.. "7 (1) m
i . ~ :::r (1) :::r ::::r :r ::::r ::::r :::r ID 0.. ::::r :E I ~ ::::r :r 0. 0. t\) ;:0 ;p-
w (1) rn (1) ~ (1) (1) (1) <1l m (1) (1) .., C/)
~ ::::J W m m 2 ID ID ID ::::J (IJ m (fl ID m ro ro '<" m
5' ;:::;: rl' :=F :=F ;:::;: ;:::;: a. m ;+ ;::;; ;::;; m ill 0. S 0
;: <= :r :r :r 0 :r :r :r ro a. :r 0 I ~ :r :r a. a. 2
l u (Q M- S. (1) 0
c ID m <
c ro ::::J 0 D- C/)
rn 5' ~ ;p-
I ~ r
'1 (Q
() 10" 5' 5' i5 ;:u
11 0 ~ ::r -0 ~ ~ ~ (IJ (I) (1) m m (") m
, ::r () '"fr ::f () .., () c c c c c
:::r ~ (I) (IJ rn ?" <' ::r " .0 " 0 " ::I: '"0
::::J :::J, 0 .., .., .., ~ :::J
(jJ S' (fl 5' '5' 5' Q r
~ 0 -l a. -l -l 0 TI TI TI TI TI ;p-
o :J ~ (Q u (Q (Q (Q !!L ~ ~ ::::J 0' 0' 0' (') (')
:::r rn iil 0 (l) (") (")
0 0" 0 c 2 () 0 0 0 0 ~ ~ =+i =;; ~ m m
::r :r ::r ::r 0 2.- Q.
iil ~ .., :E ::r ~
ft:.'l .., ('j) ~ 3 ('j) ('j) <1l iii' iii [l)' ill ...... ~
13 3 3 3 m
J.
... ~ (') -0 0 (') (') ;0
0 (fl (') ::€ (') (") m
-1 ?" ::r c ~ ;:r ;:r :r :r ::r ::r ::r ::r ::r ':J"
Vi" '2. :r Q. Q. Q. Q. Q. ::I: "'U
r+ ::::J en -0 <1l -0 -0 -0 (fl ;;:+" (jJ ::::J 0 r
~ 0 0 0 !a (]l ;!;. (ii (ii' ~ (') Ol (') 0 '<" -< -< -< -< ;p-
::::J ::r ""2- r+ r+ :r c- :r ::::J 0 0 0 0 0 (") ()
lJ m III Q. ill ill III ro
'" m 0 (') 0 0 (') 0 ~. Q. ill ID 'Ill III ,W m m
~ ::::r c <' :r :::r :r Qf ^ ^ ^ ^ ^
~ ~ 3 (l) :r w w ~
(IJ m (l) m ..,
...
\,"I '< '< '< '< '< '< '< '< ',< '< '< -< '< '< '< '< '< '< ;p-
~ I, m m (IJ q, q, ro (ll (ll rn (l) m m '" m m rn m m ;:tl
(fl (fl (fl (fl (fl Yl en Yl (fl en (fl (fJ (fl [f) en If> en If> o:l ()
J I-- 0
() 2
(fI '< '< '< '< '< '< (Jl '< '< '< '< '< '< '< '< '< '< Gl (fJ
C % (l) ro ro (I) <ll rn "2- ro rn m m ro m m rn rn (IJ m
(fl (fl ifl ifl ifl ifl ;:+ [f) ifl (Jl [f) ifl [f) en ifl ifl ifl () 2
- (fJ
C
-< -< -< -< -< -< -< -< -< -< -< -< -< -< -< -< -< -< ttl (fJ
m m m ( m m m m m m m ( m m m 5 5 m m ) m m m :;0
(jJ (jJ (jJ (jJ (jJ CfJ' (j) (j) (j) (jJ (j) (j) (j) (fJ (j) (jJ (fJ ({J 0"
-< I
m 0
2 ~ <
~1 $: 2 0
0 -l
m
(:;~ ;:u
OJ 0" m
:; "'- s
w ;p-
...... 0
;'"'" -- -l <
CJ m
...... m
ie'l 0'
1(5; ::tl
m
~ 0" '"0
;p- r
," -l ;p.
m ()
-- m
-""1 ]; 0"
()
. '---"
_. - r:J
z
o
::0
-l
I
""[J
o
Z
-l
-l
::0
m
m
::0
m
s:
o
);;
r
)>
Z
o
::0
m
""[J
r
f)
m
s:
m
z
.::-I
I\)
o
o
.....
'"
::::r
rr
....
co
:s:
".. I;t; ".. ".. ".. ".. ".. (W ~ ~ (W (W w w W N l>
Cf> ".. W N .... 0 -.j N ..... 0 <J:1 ."
'l:I:
~" ..... b ~ -I
.j>. .j>. 10 =- =- ::J ~ ~ g ::J ::J :r>
OJ OJ .j>. -., W W -., (0 ill G)
(0 "-I (\) (\) '-...J
"-I 13 'l:I:
-0 -0 -0 ~"
() m 3 5" 3 () 3 .D (j)
ro c c c "" (j) E
::J -, -a () 0 0 ::J 0 -0 -I
"52- Cl) 0..
~ rtl III ::J "'" ~ ~ n: ~ m -<
(1l -< - 0 III (") -0
-0 ::J" -0 ~ "0 3
u -0 "2- -0 u Iii m
5" C c 2" 5' 0- ::J 5" 5 0-
m '3 3 (f'/ m OJ (!) (1l (1l (!) (/J
-, -,
""
..... 10 10 ::J ..... ..... ~ IV IV ..... ..... r
0 <:) 0 :::T 0 <:) 0 0 0 0 0 0
()) ..... ..... c ()) 0 ())
f, (0 IV :::t: co
-.r w 0 ~ 0 <:) p U1 W W U1 ()
-.r ..... ..... IV OJ U1 .j>. "-I =- w l>
;:;r
5. ::J ::J ::J ::J ::J f. ::J" ::J ;; C ::J" :::!
:<: ~ :E -,
:::!l 0.: !!> ~ (Q. 0.: (j1 0 0
0.. 0 0 0 m 5" m [l)
(0 0 0 0 (0 co ,.,. Z
(!) 0. 0. 0. 0:: (0 0. ::J t1J A
::T
~ ill ~ /j) (") ,
0. ,.,.
-, -, 2 0
a c c -n
;::. 0 If> n- () "'- 0
c () ~ 0 :Al
III fi ;U m
(") --; -0 /j) :3 ~
c :;r :;r m m q m :;r l>
..... (Jl 0- 0- 5" 2 ;U
c:t (!) (!) (") ..... C (1) m (/J
0. III III 0 --; 0 ~ 0 [l) III 0 0
l1.) ;:::;: ;:::;: , 0 , I ;:::;: ::J rl- :s:
3 :;r ::J" 0.. 2- 0.. C 0- ::r c:t c Z
0 0 (i; 0 m m 0
III :3 0. :3 :3 < (fJ
10 ro l1.) l>
(!) 5 3 S" -" ::J
::J S" r
0- l1.) ro ro ro
~ CO ;::!. ;::!. to
ro
() (") (") (") (") ;U
IIJ -0 :::T 0 (f) 0 0 0 () 0 (") m
:E c '< Q) ~ ill Q) Q) ::r ill 0
--; ~ ~ ~ rn ~ (f) ::r :r: ."
m "2- (!) ,.,. ,.,. r
~ 0.. -, ~ ro ro (i; (f) (i; -l 0 l>
ro (!) (") ~ (')
0 -0 - 0- Q. 0- 0. 0:. :::T 0. (")
ill
<" C- c ~ <" ~ ~ ~ 0 ~ 0 m m
'3 -, 0 0 0 0 ~ 0 :;,: .....
(!) 5!. 0 (1) 0 0 0 0 ~
0.. 0. 0. 0.. 0-
-0 :::T -0 ll) ll) " ro ;:c
-0 ~ () OJ 0 0 m
;:l: '< C ;:l: -.. III cd' C -0, ::r
rr (Q 10 () to :I: ."
0 --; -a ::;r 0 ::;r :J ::;r :;r r
rn 0.: m ll) Ul III ~ III "TI ll) (f) 0 l>
-0 ::::l -0 ::J ::::l 0" :J 0 (')
0 Ii) -0 0 -0 :;r ()
--; C C- -0 --; -0 -0 :::;; -0 Q. m m
c ~ 5 c 5" 5" ::J Q. 5 ll)
:3 :3 (!) :3 (!) (J) (J) ill" (1) --; 1'0 ~
'< '< '< '< '< '< b '< '< '< '< '< l>
(ll (1) (ll (ll (!) (!) (ll ro (!) (!) (!) ;U
(f) (f) IIJ (fJ (fJ (fJ (J) (fJ (fJ (J) (fI OJ (")
- 0
I ~';? z
r, ~::; '< (fJ '< '< '< '< g '< , '< '< '< '< G) (f)
(ll "2- (ll m (ll (ll (ll (J) <IJ (!) m m
(fJ ;:;: (fJ (fJ (Jl if) (fI (J) (J) (fI (fl () Z
" (f)
'-- c
:' E~ -< -< -< -< -< -< ~ -< -< -< -< -< OJ (fl
:ii ;\ :!;" m m m m m m D m 5 m m m m ;:0
{/J (fl (fl {/J (/J (f) {/J (fl (fl (fJ {/J 0
/"'" ::.: " I
I ~ -, ~;~ -< 0
~r m
~ <
J\' z 0
, 0 -I
( :v m
('-"" ) - I~ ;U
IC ~ !-- m
\ ~- \ 0 :s:
1'(; l>
'\ '0 -I 0
.~ - m <
m
, 0
;:c
m
0 ."
11I11I ):> r
-l l>
m ()
m
0