SC 07-15-21CITY OF CUPERTINO SUSTAINABILITY COMMISSION
TelecorJerence meeting witliout a physical location.
Thursday, July 15, 2021 4:00 p.m.
-"ffiMEETING MINUTES
At 4:04 p.m. Chair Swaminathaii called the meetiitg to order.
ROLL CALL
Commissioners Present: Chair Vignesh Swarninathan, Vice Chair Ram Mohan, and Commissioners Gary
Latshaw, Meera Ramanathan, and Anna Weber.
. Jimrny Tan, Assistant Director of Public Works - Operations; Andre Duurvoort, Sustainability Manager;
Iqraam Nabi, h'uqovation Technology Technician; Toan Quach, Innovation Technology Techniciaii; Brendan
Norton, CivicSpark AmeriCorps Fellow; Gilee Corral, Climate and Utilities Analyst.
. Members of the public.
Chair Swaminathan read a statement regarding provisions of the Brown Act and an Executive Order issued by
the Governor to facilitate teleconferencing to reduce the risk of COVID-19 transmission at public meetings.
APPROV At OF MINUTES
1. Subject: Minutes from March 18, 2021 meeting
Commissioner Weber moved and Commissioner Ramanathan seconded to approve the minutes. The motion
carried unanimously.
POSTPONEMENTS
None.
ORAL COMMUNICATIONS
None.
WRITTEN COMMUNICATIONS
None.
OLD BUSINESS
None.
STAFF AND COMMISSION REPORTS
Staff updates: Gilee Corral, Staff Liaison, provided brief updates:
Fiscal Year 2022 Work Progran'i approved by Council. Cornrnission items include CAP Update and
Single Use Plastics project with a Mayor's Cup Challenge
Staff engaging consultant for commercial and stakeholder outreadi for single use plastics ordinance
development
Environmental Day, De Anza Parking Lot A, on August 12, 8 a.m. to noon.
Citywide Garage Sale, weekend of September 18 and 19, cupertino.org/garagesale
1
Coastal Cleaiuip Day, September 18 at Creekside Park
Commission reports:
Chair Swaminathaii aruiorinced tliat the Valley Transportation Authority (VTA) Citizen Advisory
Committee is recruiting members. He briefly explained responsibilities of the committee and current
discussion topics.
Vice Chair Mohan attended the July Mayor's Meeting on behalf of the Commission, noting that the
Mayor is attending a national Mayor's conference and will highlight Cupertino's climate action and
sustainability efforts, given the national focus on these issues. The Mayor has a budget of $100 to
support Commission special initiatives.
Commissioner Weber reported on the Mayor's Meeting to select the CREST Award recipient, which she
attended on behalf of the Cornrnission.
Commissioner Rarnanathan reported on her participation in the Cupertino Earth and Arbor Day
virtual festival. She gave a welcome message on behalf of the Commission and co-hosted an electric
cooking demo with Rochelle Bou&er.
NEW BUSINESS
Staff paused Item #2 due to technical difficulties and requested to reorder the agenda to move Item #3 before
Item #2 to resolve the issue. Chair Swaminathan moved and Commissioner Weber seconded to reorder the
agenda items as requested. The motion carried unanimously.
3. Subject: Highlights from the CivicSpark AmeriCorps seice year in Cupertino
CivicSpark AmeriCorps Fenow Brendan Norton reviewed his project through the year and highlights:
CAP update outreach support
Staff equity training
Virtual waste clean-up corrimunity event with 120 voliu'iteers and over 200 hours of volunteer service
Virtual Earth Day Speaker Series
Student partnership with the Community Climate Solutions website
He recommends that staff continue momentum on these projects, continue raaal equity trainings, explore the SB
1000 toolkit, and align affordable housing and transit access with the Climate Action Plan goals.
The Commission asked clarifying questions and gave comments, including:
Expression of thanks and support (Chair Swarninathan)
Clarification on subjects covered in equity training (Latshaw). Norton: the training covered implicit bias on
a personal level and best practices for incorporating measures in government. SB 1000 highlights ways to
use hard data where inequities lie in a community.
How the site of the volunteer project was selected (Ramanathan). Norton: to increase participation across
California and take advantage of the CivicSpark network.
Suggestions on themes or goals for equity to consider for 2022 (Swarninathan). Norton: outreach consultant
received compiled list of stakeholders, making sure we have Ianguage translation. Staff are considering the
Below Market Rate renters and homeowners and affordable housing tenants in their outreach.
Question on the use of Mural for outreach (Weber). Norton explained how staff used the tool during
taining.
Comments and thoughts on incorporating equity intoCAP planning and communicahons, use of inclusive
language, outreach to lower income populations (Swarninathan, Latshaw)
2
2. Subject: Multi Factor Authotizatxon training from the City's Infrastructure Division
Iqraarn Nabi, Irutovation Tecl-utology TecluThcian, reviewed how to access the Duo app ai'id authorize it using a
mobile device.
Staff aitswered tedu'iical qtestions from the Commission on using the app across multiple devices, how the
app works, etc. Staff suggested dowi'doadii'ig the Duo app onto a smart phone or tablet that is readily
accessible to authenticate iiistead of using a laptop. The app will work witb Wi-Fi or cellular data.
Nabi advised the Commission to set up tlieir React Account to enable them to unlock their accou'it if needed.
If a Commissioner plans to travel abroad, please let the Chair know so the Chair can alert IT, to avoid their
account being locked out.
4. Subject: Staff update on drought and water conservation programs
Sustainability Manager Andr6 Duurvoort presented an update on the City's response to the drought. Topics
covered included:
City response for municipal property (Stage 4 drought conditions)
Valley Water Landscape Rebate Program participation
Climate Victory Gardens Pilot: first of its kind in Northem California. The pilot supports property
owners through the process of converting turf to drought tolerant landscaping and accessing Valley
Water rebates. On track with targets, about 30,000 sq feet of turf conversions and 600,000 gallons of
water saved atuiually.
Drought restrictions: Explained the wholesaler, retailer, and consumer relationship and enforcement of
water restrictions. Cupertino's two water retailers, Califomia Water Service (Cal Water) and San Jose
Water (SJW) will attend an upcorning Council meeting agenda topic on the drought.
The Commission asked darifying questions and gave comments:
Question on water audits for a property (Mohan). Duurvoort: Valley Water offers a free Water Wise
Survey. Can also inquire with the water retailer that serves your home.
Use of purple pipe/recycled water, and if car washes are closed as part of restrictions (Rarnanathan).
Duurvoort: car washes are not currently prohibited. Cupertino is part of a working group of local
agencies who are discussing ordinance *anges as the drought progresses. Purple pipe is an important
long terms solution; however the current focus is on actions that will reduce immediate demand on
potable water supply.
Plans to update water meters, noted an example of tech that uses Wi-Fi (Latshaw). Duurvoort: would
be interested to see a solution for residential meters. The City does not control the water mete mg
infrastnicture in the cornrnunity but is considering submetering for City properties.
Climate Victory Gardens marketing, question on tree planting assistance (Weber).
o Jirnrny Tan, Assistant Director of Public Works - Operations, noted the City's policy to replant
any tree if it is removed. Duurvoort: cointywide effort to promote planting trees. Tree cover
important for climate response. Arborist team still watering trees as we reduce in other spaces.
3
o Duurvoort: Climate Victory Gardens was advertised once via social media aiid the participant
list was filled in two weeks. Currently the pilot lias 80 properties on tbe waitlist and staff are
considering options for expanding tl'ie pilot due to the demand.
Clarification on wlio owns the water pumps (Swarninathan). Duurvoort: SJW operates Cupertino water
system, likely the pump station is also operated by SJW.
Comments on severity of the drought, if any forecast on how long it will last (Swarninathan).
Duurvoort: we can bring this to water retailers for a response in the upcorning Council shidy session.
Chair Swarninathan opened public cornrnent and the followiiig individuals spoke:
Rob Seeley, Community Affairs Specialist for Cal Water, spoke on the development of a system to
understand which pipes need replacement. He explained Advanced Metering Infrastructure briefly aiid
noted that Cal Water is continriing to work this as a solution in the long term. Noted that Apple Campus
has a purple pipe system and comments on barriers of installing purple pipe and benefits of expanding
it as part of a new construction process. Noted sources of water and locations in the system.
o Commissioner Latshaw asked the speaker a follow up question on drip irrigation. Seeley
explained a free program including incentives to sripport watering landscape system tune ups,
The program incorporates the list of "prohibited uses" in the tiine up.
Susan Cordone, Conservation Coordinator for Cal Water, introduced herself.
Chair Swaminathan expressed appreciation for staff and the water retailers for their efforts.
5. Subject:StaffupdateonCIimateActionPlanupdateproject
Duurvoort gave an update on the Climate Action Plan (CAP) ptoject and timeline, covering various topics:
Technical work is iu'iderway, including a partial refresh of data for the 2018 greenhouse gas inventory
and reporkg to the CDP Cities public platform
CAP Report to Council is inn development to cover 2019 and 2020 actions and lessons learned from
implementing the current CAP
First stakeholder meeting: co-hosted with staff and the CAP Update Subcommittee, with 24 attendees
from various sectors: businesses, agencies, nonprofits. Approach for stakeholder outreach is to focus on
equity and solicit feedback from underrepresented groups. Educate the group to be more
knowledgeable about the process so they could generate more interest to public workshops. Used
Mural to create a Vision Board - what would you like Cupertino to look like in 2050?
First virtual public workshop strheduled for July 29: using polls, surveys, free text comments, raise
hand and talk to encourage participation. Releasing a toolkit soon for promotion.
Cupertino.org/clirnateaction: will become a virtual community participation forum.
The CAP Update Subcommittee reported on its participation to date:
Chair Swarninathan and Latshaw provided feedback on the stakeholder workshop:
o Went well overall, nicely rcin (Swaminathan, Latshaw)
o High-level brainstorming and goal discussion was valuable, should stick to high-level discussion
rather than getting too far into specific iSSues (Swaminathan)
o Commissioner Latshaw noted an email re Menlo Park being aggressive on natural gas; Corral
will foard to the Commission for information.
4
Chair Swamii'iathait opened public comment aitd the followiitg iiidividuals spoke:
Dasl"iiell Leeds on behalf of Sierra Club Loma Prieta Cliapter noted his positive experience attending the
stakeholder meeting ai"id appreciation for the CAP update public process. He supports aii aggressive
plan and strong targets.
GWYII Azar on behalf of Silicon Valley Youth Climate Action notedher positive experience attending tl'ie
stakeholder meeting and appreciation of the inclusion of diverse voices. She supports a more ambitious
target than the airrent 2040 draft carbon neutrality goals.
Chair Swaminathan asked about eqriity efforts and progress to date. Dturvoort noted staff are reqriesting
demographic information at multiple checkpoints and will report back on statistics for the public workshop.
6, Subject: Staff update on student programs and youth engagement
Staff presented an ripdate on the intern program and student engagement:
Duurvoort reported on projects completed by the Sustainability and Environmental Programs youth
interns: single-use plastics field research to grocery stores, and shident involvement in the Earth and
Arbor Day Virhtal Speaker Series.
Staff presented an overview of the Cupertino Climate Challenge. Norton recruited Youth
Environmental Power Initiative (YEPI) to lainch a challenge for shidents to sign tp for the platform
from July through October.
Duurvoort reported that two recipients submitted invoices for reimbursement for the Sustainability
Grants for Students Program. He reqtiested feedback from the Commission on themes, ideas for the
next cycle of the program, noting a budget of $2/000 to support a contest and $700 for waste aiidits,
The Commission asked clarifying questions and gave comments.
General expressions of support for involving youth and the next generation in climate action.
If the program can be scaled up and recruit more students throrigh a "teach the teadiers" program
(Mohan). Duurvoort: staff would love to pursue an expanded effort, key challenge is limited staff
capacity.
Great learning experience for youth; young people can be effective in bringing climate messages to
Council meetings (Latshaw)
Noting distinction between the experiences of Generation X, Millennials, and Generation Z
(Swarninathan)
Chair Swaminathan opened public comment and the following individuals spoke:
Gwyn Azar onbehalf of Silicon Valley Youth Climate Action offered feedback from her group and noted
her positive leaming experience from participation in the Speaker Series event.
The Commission gave feedback and comments, including:
Appreciation for the youth program, hope it will tie into behavior change, i.e. with the water shortage.
Suggested the next challenge could be a behavior change effort (Ramanathan). Duurvoort: noted
challenges ofintroduce programs atscale and making the most of digital tools and funding. He requested
ongoing feedback from the Commission on the youth program.
5
Caii promote the City's social media toolkit via his personal TikTok chai'uiel (Swaminatliait)
FUTURE AGENDA SETTING
Corral noted tlie upcoming CAP update July 29 public workshop ai'id all Commissioners expressed iiiterest in
attending.
The Commission discussed chaitges ai'id additions to the Future Agenda Settiiig List:
Suggestiot'i to add an item to it"icrease the awareness of sustainability aiid climate charige among youth
and schools (Mohait)
Chair Swaminathan moved to add a discussion to raise awareness of sustainability aitd climate change among
shidents to the Future Agenda Setting list and approve as amended. Cornrnissioner Latshaw suggested adding
"and adults" to the discussion item. The Commission discussed the wording of this discussion and whether to
split it to two different items. Chair Swaminathan withdrew his first motion.
The Commission agreed to amend the future agenda setting list to read as foIJows:
Sustainability Grants for Students / essay contest
Disaiss hosting a public workshop on carbon reduction ideas
Disaiss 2021 Earth & Arbor Day event ideas
Zero Emission Vehicles discussion
Building electrification discussion
Discussion on raising awareness of sustainability among youth
Discussion on raising awareness of climate diange among adults
A motion was made by Commissioner Latshaw and seconded by Vice Chair Mohan to approve the Future
Agenda Setting list as reflected above. The motion carried unanimously.
The Commission briefly considered scheduling a Special Meeting in August, but as there were no urgent
issues to discuss, did not schedule it. The CAP Update Subcommittee meeting will meet before the next
Commission meeting.
ADJOURNMENT
A motion to adjourn was made by Chair Swarninathan and seconded by Commissioner Weber. The motion
carried unanimously. Meeting adjourned at 6:40 p.m.
6