Item 3-PresentationReach Codes
Cupertino
August 29, 2019
1
2
•Support Cities in meeting climate goals
o Encourage safer, healthier all-electric
buildings within the building code
o Install EV charging during building
construction commensurate with local needs
Purpose
3
1.Provide cost-effective pathways for both All-Electric and Dual-Fuel
(electric + gas) construction
2.Establish the highest possible requirements that are still cost-
effective for Dual-Fuel construction.
3.Recommendations must comply within CEC energy code guidelines
Guiding Principles
4
Reach Code Recommendations
Cost-Effective W/in CEC
Guidelines
Included in SVCE
recommendation
Base Title 24 Yes Yes Yes
All-Electric Yes Yes Yes –Pathway 1
Dual-Fuel Yes Yes Yes –Pathway 2
Mostly Electric
(residential only)
Not as a standalone
pathway
Yes Yes –Pathway 2A
CalGreen
Tier 1 or Tier 2
Not as a standalone
pathway
Yes No
Ban on Natural Gas Yes No1 No
1 A ban utilizes a city’s Police power, not via a local amendment to Energy Code.
Item Date Leader Participant(s)Content Coordination Technical
Cost Effectiveness Study Feb 2019 Consultant SVCE/PCE
Draft Model Codes Mar 2019 Consultant Cities
External Stakeholder Input May 2019 Consultant Cities, SVCE/PCE, Community
City Staff Recommendation Aug 2019 Cities Consultant, Stakeholders
Submit for Council Vote Fall 2019 Cities City Council, Consultant
Training City Staff Dec 2020 Consultant City Staff
New Code Effective Jan 2020 Cities
Consultant Support AvailableStakeholders
•Transitioning leadership to the cities
•SVCE and Consultants providing support for each of these next steps
5
Summary Timeline
Local Engagement To Date
6
City
Letter of
Intent
June All-Hands
Meeting
City Staff
Meeting(s)
Commission
Meeting
Council
Briefing
Council
Reading
Council
Vote
Mountain View X X X Pending Oct 22 Nov 12
Los Altos X X X X Oct 22 Nov 12
Morgan Hill X X X X Oct 23 Nov 6
Milpitas X X X X Sept Oct
Cupertino X X X TBD TBD
Los Altos Hills X X X Nov
Sunnyvale X X X X Pending
Monte Sereno Pending X X Pending
Gilroy X X X X Pending
Saratoga X X
Campbell X
Los Gatos Oct 15
County of Santa Clara X
7
Single Family Residence –Base Code
All-Electric (1)Electric & Gas (2)
Meet Title 24 requirements Meet Title 24 requirements, including:
•Pre -wire water heater location for future electric heat pump
8
Single Family Residence –Base Reach Code
All-Electric (1)Electric & Gas (2)
Meet Title 24 requirements Meet Title 24 requirements, including:
•Pre -wire water heater for future electric heat pump
•Pre -wire for future electric appliances (+$ 750)
•Additional Energy Efficiency measures (+$1500)
•Solar thermal or Battery Storage (+ $6000)
9
Single Family –Reach Code option
All-Electric (1) Electric & Gas (2)
Meet Title 24 requirements Meet Title 24 requirements, including:
•Pre-wire water heater for future electric heat pump
•Pre-wire for future electric appliances (+$ 750)
•Additional Energy Efficiency (+$1500)
•Solar thermal or Battery Storage (+ $6000)
“Mostly Electric” (2A)
Meet Title 24 requirements, including:
•Pre -wire for future electric heat pump
•Install Electric water and space heating
(allows natural gas for cooking)
•Pre -wire for future electric range (+$ 250)
•Additional Energy Efficiency measures (+$1500)
•Solar thermal or Battery Storage (+ $6000)
Single and Two-family New Construction
10
Performance Path Prescriptive Path
1. All Electric. Demonstrate that the proposed home
will be all electric, OR
Build All Electric. Meet 2019 Title 24 Part 6.
2. Mixed Fuel Building. Proposed Design Building shall
be at least 10 EDR points less than the Total Energy
Design Rating calculated for the Standard Design
Building, OR
Mixed Fuel Building
a. Low leakage ducts
b. R-10 perimeter slab insulation
c. Compact hot water distribution
d. Fan efficacy of 0.35 Watts/cfm
e. Either 1) 5 kWh battery OR 2) A solar water heating system.
2A. Electrically Heated Building (electric space and
water heating, gas cooking and/or clothes drying).
Proposed Design Building shall be at least 2 EDR
points less than the Energy Efficiency Design Rating
calculated for the Standard Design Building, OR
Electrically Heating Building
a. Low leakage ducts.
b. R-10 perimeter slab insulation.
c. Compact hot water distribution.
d. Fan efficacy of 0.35 Watts/cfm.
“Menu options” are formatted with green highlights
1 + 2
OR
1 + 2 + 2A
Multifamily New Construction (≤3 stories)
11
Performance Path Prescriptive Path
1. All Electric. Demonstrate that the proposed home
will be all electric, OR
Build All-Electric and Meet 2019 Title 24 Part 6.
2. Mixed Fuel Building. Proposed Design Building shall
be at least 10 EDR points less than the Total Energy
Design Rating calculated for the Standard Design
Building, OR
Mixed Fuel Building
a. low leakage ducts in conditioned space
b. 0.25 ASR cool roof
c. R-10 slab insulation
d. compact Hot Water distribution
e. 0.35 W/cfm HVAC fan
d. Either 1) 2.75 kWh battery/dwelling OR 2) A solar water
heating system.
2A. Electrically Heated Building (electric space and
water heating, gas cooking and/or clothes drying).
Proposed Design Building shall be less than the
Energy Efficiency Design Rating calculated for the
Standard Design Building
Electrically Heated Building
Meet 2019 Title 24 Part 6
“Menu options” are formatted with green highlights
1 + 2
OR
1 + 2 + 2A
Nonresidential
12
Performance Path Prescriptive Path
1. All Electric. Demonstrate that the proposed
building will be all electric, OR
Build All Electric and meet 2019 Title 24 Part 6.
2. Mixed Fuel Building, All Occupancies.
Demonstrate that the energy use of the
proposed building is 9% more efficient than the
2019 State Energy Code, OR
Mixed Fuel Building
a. Fenestration with a solar heat gain coefficient ≥ 0.22.
b. Airflows to be equal to the zone ventilation minimums.
c. Economizers in air handlers ≥ 33,000 Btu/h
d. Reduced the lighting power density (Watts/ft2) by ten percent
(10%)
e. In common areas, improve lighting: 1) Daylight dimming plus off
AND 2) Institutional Tuning
f. Install drain water heat recovery.
2A. Mixed Fuel Building, Office and Mercantile.
Demonstrate that the energy use of the
proposed building is 15% more efficient than
the 2019 State Energy Code
Mixed Fuel Building
a. Fenestration with a solar heat gain coefficient ≥ 0.22.
b. E/W fenestration area is < ½ of the N/S fenestration.
c. Airflows to be equal to the zone ventilation minimums.
d. Economizers in air handlers ≥ 33,000 Btu/h
e. Reduced the lighting Watts/ft2 by 10%
f. Improve lighting: 1) Daylight dimming plus off AND 2) Institutional
Tuning AND 3) Occupant sensing in open plan offices
1 + 2 + 2A
1 + 2
OR
Reach Code –EV Charging
To enact a reach code for EV charging, increase the Quantity, Readiness and/or Charging Speed.
Building Type Quantity Readiness Charging Speed
Residential 1 per dwelling unit Capable Level 2
Multi-Unit Dwelling 10% of total spaces Capable Level 2
Commercial 6% of total spaces Capable Level 2
CalGreen (Part 11) provides minimum requirements for each aspect of EV Charging per building type
[above charts simplified for illustration purposes]
Building Type Quantity Readiness Charging Speed
Residential 1 per dwelling unit
1 per dwelling unit
Capable Ready
Ready
Level 2
Level 1
Multi-Unit Dwelling 10% 25% of total spaces Capable Ready Level 2
Commercial 6% 10% of total spaces Capable Ready Level 2
13
Readiness
Installed
Ready
Capable
Speed
Level 3
Level 2
Level 1